
N E T W O R K
December 1998 Vol. V, No. 3
Page One
This issue is the Dec 1998-January 1999 issue for two related reasons.
For unavoidable reasons we had to take a quick decision to move both
our administrative office as well as the Open Door Outreach and Intervention
Centre. Since disability NGOs have difficulties with both acceptance
as well as finances, it took us a while to finalise the deal. Till
we were certain of a secure mailing address, which we could carry
in the journal, the December issue could not go into print. We wanted
to wait for both our new location as well as the new telephone to
be finalised so that the information could be distributed through
the journal thus saving the organisation an expensive and extra round
of mailing!
This is a busy time of the year. The TEACCH methods are an important
component of the pedagogical method used at AFA. Our Assistant Director
Sandra Dawson attended the TEACCH Summer Training at the University
of North Carolina to refresh herself first hand on a method she was
familiar with and already practicing.
With the support of the Rajiv Gandhi Foundation AFA has launched
an all-India project with pediatricians that will lead to earlier
and more accurate diagnosis for children with autism.
In August, AFA travelled to Calcutta to conduct training workshops
for parents at Dolna and professionals at REACH. A group of parents
there are now trying to actively establish a support group and are
in the process of registering themselves as a body. We hope such exciting
developments replicate themselves in other parts of the country as
well.
Early-October saw our annual training workshops. Thanks to the postal
strike most people received the information a bare three weeks prior
to the start. Since traditionally a majority of our participants are
usually out-of-towners, many of them could not get their train reservations
in place on time. Some of the most persevering did however. But most
interestingly we had a large number of parents of very young children,
mainly three-year-olds, participating.
What marked this year's workshop from other years was the demonstration
calssroom that was set up. Evaluation forms from earlier years have
indicated that participants wanted to visit the Open Door Outreach
and Intervention Centre to observe firsthand the AFA methods. And
of course, that is not possible; in addition to being closed for Dussehra,
AFA would not be able to accommodate 70 participants in the tiny centre!
For those living in and around Delhi, this is not a problem because
Open Door is truly 'open'! Any one can walk off the street into the
building to observe sessions through a large viewing window with one
way glass. Parents and professionals have been taking advantage of
this unique facility since Open Door was set up, which we strongly
encourage. However, no more than six or so people can view at any
given time.
A wonderful solution was found and implemented at this year's workshop.
A demonstration classroom with one-to-one and independent work areas,
play and group-activity areas, and childrens' schedules was set up
in a small room adjacent to the main workshop venue. The tiny room
was planned around four children, two verbal and two nonverbal, although
only three could make it in that holiday season! A camera captured
events in the classroom, which was projected onto a large screen in
the workshop room as a therapist explained what was happening to the
audience. It was incredible and exciting to note the children's comfort
in this totally new and strange environment as they checked their
schedules and went about the business of the day! The demonstration
classroom perfectly complemented the information shared on communication,
behaviour management, teaching methods, the value of acceptance and
comfort around the children that is essential in helping them grow
and learn, and of course, the importance of a structure.
Early November we had our Annual Awareness and Benefit concert at
the Indian Institute of Technology Amphitheatre. A week before the
event circumstances made the original venue unavailable throwing everything
out of gear; but Friends of AFA jumped in to help and we ended up
with a wonderful Concert.
In November I was invited to represent AFA at the launch of the World
Autism Organisation in Luxembourg. It was a privilege to be there
and elsewhere this issue carries a brief report by Paul Trehin the
Secretary General of the Interim Council.
And in continuation of our series on alternative therapies we have
something on music therapy in this issue. If any of our readers have
comments to add we will look forward to carrying them in the next
issue. And of course all our usual features including Helpline.
We wish all our readers joy and peace and a wonderful 1999.
Alternative Therapies: Using Music
to Teach
Sandra Dawson
Since time began, music has been a form of communication that animals
and humans aline have used in different ways. It communciates messages,
defines boundaries for flocks of birds, groups of animals or tribes
of humans as well as creating a background for social gatherings.
Music has developed and evolved over the years into a complex form
of art that is still used at social gatherings, for communicating
needs and specifiying social groups, but also for entertainment as
well as therapy for people with mental and physical handicaps.
This is primarily because music as we all know has an effect on the
state of mind of a person. Different kinds of music extract different
responses from people. The different responses can be seen clearly
if you take the examples of a rock concert and a sitar recital. While
one has the audience on its feet and head-banging, the other has them
relaxed and just listening. Both groups are enjoying the music...just
differently.
In recent years, therapists have experimented with using music therapy
with people with autism. Some have had positive results while others
have shown no significant changes. As research continues, it is becomming
clearer that music can be used with the autistic person as something
that is therapeutic, like a good swim or deep pressure massage, rather
than as therapy designed for psychological and psychiatric disorders.
Parents of nearly every child with autism will tell you that one of
their childrens' favorite things is music. This is why music is used
so often as a supportive teaching method for people with autism. Have
you every wondered why children learn a song much better than the
answers to their chemistry lesson? Or why you are still able to recall
a poem that you learned at school but not the debate speech you made?
The reason is that our minds are able to assimilate or learn and retain
words that have a rhythm or tune much better than words that don't.
With many autistic children, their ability to pick up a tune is far
stronger than their ability to learn language. To be of help to the
person with autism, we can use their strengths to support their weaknesses.
Here are some simple suggestions on how music can be used, especially
to teach.
Music can be used in its simplest form to aid in communication. Many
families relate the experience of thir child with autism singing long
before using any appropriate speech. Or, some children will sing lines
from a song that is in some way associated with what they actually
want to say. For example, as part of a group activity, a little girl
sang a song with the line, "the bears went over the red bridge,"
and the objects used for demonstration were lego blocks. After that,
whenever she wanted blocks to play with, she would say, "the
bears went over the red bridge de do." Another boy would say,
"Old MacDonald had a farm" when he wanted plastic animals
to play with. In these situations, 'innappropriate' words set to a
tune were used in an appropriate manner. So what we can do is provide
children with the appropriate words to say, in a tune.
Since music is already an interest and love for many children, it
can be used as a motivator to learn language that is otherwise difficult
to comprehend and use. Many times we find ourselves in a situation
where we feel the child understands what is said but for some reason
is not following the instructions given. In such a sitution, it is
simple and easy to sing him your instruction-- and you may be surprised
as the child gives a willing response! Sometimes a child going through
a phrase of high negativity might be unwilling to comply with any
instructions. One way of getting around it would be to sing the instruction
out, and this often is extremely effective.
People with autism often have a flat or monotone way of speaking.
Here, music can be used to introduce variations in pitch, volume,
and accent. While singing or talking to the child, voices can be changed
to sound deep, sharp, squeaky, soft, loud, whispery, and so on. Other
than grabbing their attention, this also helps them to learn to vary
their tones when speaking. Often parents tell us that their child
will not listen to a story being read. Try this: use music as a background
to a story. Read to the child from a book while soft instrumental
music plays. (It is often better for the music to be instrumental
so the words of the song do not distract the child). One other way
we use music at our school is by singing to them about things that
are happening around them. This is almost like a running commentary...but
in a song.
Now, as we are aware, Autism is a social as well as communication
impairment. Children with autism often find it difficult to play or
establish connections and cooperative interactions with other children.
The things they enjoy doing may be different from what other children
do and they are often on their own even when others are around. Music
can be used as a base on which to build group activities, something
the children will relate to and connect with. Simple songs or nursery
rhymes can be taken and the words changed to instructions that will
tell the children what to do during the activity.
A favourite activity at the Open Door Centre is a simple game in which
each child gets a turn to puck up an object and put it into a container.
The tune used is 'London bridge is falling down' but the words used
are, "Amit, pick the red block, red block, red block. Amit, pick
the red block, red block, red block and put it in the jar." The
name is changed, of course, as the turn moves from one child to the
next.
Another one that the children love is an activity in which each child
has to identify himself and then follow the instructions given. It
is sung to the tune of, 'Are you sleeping, brother John?'
Adult sings: "Where is Amit, where is Amit"
Child responds: "Here I am, here I am" (or the adult sings
for the child while raising the child's hand)
Adult sings: "Amit, please clap four times, Amit please clap
four times" (child is helped to follow instructions while they
are given). "Very good! Very good!" Each child is given
something to do that he likes, and that is at his level of ability.
At home these simple games can be played with two or three family
members taking turns to do things that the child is familiar with
or will be interested to do. One can include simple activities to
do around the house like switching off fans, shutting doors, picking
up toys, etc. It is basically a fun way of getting the child to be
involved in the activities of others.
Music naturally facilitates play. Most of us adults, tend to take
ourselves very seriously and our focus too often becomes the disability
and not the child. When music is involved in our interactions, it
helps us to let go and ENJOY being with the child. Just like we do
when we around regular children, we can play games that involve singing
and dancing, nursery rhymes, popular songs heard on the TV, and so
on. We can have fun with them, too! And when we are having fun, we
are sharing with them a common pleasure that so rarely happens with
autistic people. When we are having fun, we are also establishing
a connection that the child takes pleasure in and so will look forward
to in the future. We really believe that for anyone, learning is better
and faster if the experience is exciting and enjoyable. So when we
are working with an autistic child, regardless of what we are teaching,
music can be used to draw or keep attention, help the child to focus
on what is being taught, and get the child motivated to interact and
learn.
By its nature, music is structured and facilitates structure in the
environment in which it is experienced. Many times, when a person
is feeling extremely excited, stressed or uncomfortable, music can
be used as a stress reducer. Its steady and predictable rhythm provides
vestibular stimulation that, as we are aware, has a very calming effect.
For those children who have hearing sensitivities, certain kinds of
music acts as the much needed sound stimulus that aids in sensory
integration. One thing to remember is that each child's choice of
music may be different. Some may like soft music, while others prefer
loud thumping music. We have to try different kinds of music and volumes
before we figure out what they like and then use that as needed.
Some parents have found that they can get their children to do things
on their own, if there is some music playing in the background. Music
is also a great way of keeping the child occupied and keeps them from
getting stressed out because of nothing to do, if the parent or caregiver
is busy.
Using music cannot cure conditions such as Autism and mental disabilities,
but it can help alleviate negative behaviors. The ultimate aim of
any therapy used with the child with autism is social integration
and communication of the child. Music therapy can be an extremely
enjoyable therapy, but is is effective only as a supporting training
method to more structured techniques, and should not be used to replace
it.
If anyone has used music to teach and would like to share their
experiences with others, please do write and we will be happy to share
these!
Visitor From Mars
Bhaswati Ghosh
Hunny was the 'WINDOW MAN' - literally. He would spend the entire
day gazing out of the window - tirelessly. He wouldn't speak to or
interact with the other kids. Nor would he communicate his feelings
or needs non-verbally. In fact, he appeared to be totally devoid of
any emotion.
As I attempted to understand and decipher the silence of young Hunny,
I saw myself moving a little closer to the world of autistic children.
Autism - a rare disorder believed to affect at least one out of every
five hundred Indians, hampers communication and social behaviour.
Over fifty years of research in the field has failed to detect the
actual cause of the disorder and hence no cure has yet been found
for autism. The only available solution is training the affected children
with communication skills.
Recently, I got an opportunity to work with autistic kids -- thanks
to a colleague who has such a child himself. Although it was only
for a couple of days, the experience proved vital in many ways. For
one, it gave me a better and more objective understanding of Autism,
of which I only had a vague and somewhat prejudiced idea. For another,
it provided me a better understanding of my own capabilities and limitations.
While my co-volunteers took their time getting acquainted with the
other children, I was compelled to draw some response from Hunny --
who was distinctly different from his peers. He preferred total isolation
and would just stand at the window for hours together. His blank,
expressionless face conveyed no feelings. And he didn't seem to have
any need, interest or inclination.
I just stood beside Hunny by the window; at times I would look at
him - not in awe but with a humble request in my eyes urging him to
be my friend. I would gently call his name and talk to him with the
confidence of having known him for a long time. But it turned out
to be a hopeless one-sided exercise. Hunny seemed totally absorbed
in his world outside the window. He just wasn't responding to me in
any way. I was disappointed and tried to make friends with the more
responsive and seemingly more vibrant kids.
However much I tried to leave Hunny alone, there seemed to be a strange
bond that drew me to stand with him and 'his' window. As I went to
him for the second time, one thing was clear to me -- at least he
wasn't resenting my company. I was happy. I left him and sat down
with little Akshay who was having fun with his colouring. Suddenly,
Hunny came to me, held my hand and pulled me towards the all-too-familiar
window. I was exhilarated. Hunny had chosen me of the whole lot of
volunteers, to enter his world. I joined him in watching the trees
and buildings outside - this time as a friend. There was more in store
for me -- Hunny started smiling and giggling for no apparent reason,
but his message was clear to me. He was telling me, " I am happy
to have you with me." And then, he hugged me in an assured manner.
My day was made.
Lack of information on the disorder is a major bottleneck in improving
the prospects of autistic children. There are too many myths and misconceptions
surrounding it. Autism is not a mental disorder, only behaviourial
one; it is present either from birth or manifests itself during the
first three years of a person's life; 80% of all autistic people are
males. Not all autistic children have the same behaviourial pattern
-- in fact each is distinct from the other.
And so I found out. Fourteen-year old Arpit was obsessed with his
toys -- HE MAN, GI-JOE and the likes peopled his universe. He was
happy to lock himself up in a room with his bag of toys, which he
wouldn't let anyone touch. Also, he would speak only in imitation
of a female voice (I suspected his mother's influence) and that too
by way of instructions -- always. Even if he had to ask for water,
the tone would be one of instructing a junior. Tiny Uttaran who has
one of the sweetest of faces in the world, would just skip, jump and
run all over the place. He did not speak a word but would exclaim
"koo-jhik-jhik-jhik....." at random intervals. Which told
you about his fascination for trains, not uncommon in most children
of his age.
Akshay, who screamed and hollered for going back to his parents in
the first day, could be pacified only with crayons and a white sheet
of paper. While you drew out a hut, a tree and the Sun for him, he
picked up the right colour to fill in the sketches. Every time he
insisted on being returned to his mother's custody, we told him how
happy she would be see his drawings. That would again activate his
enthusiasm and he would ask you to draw the next figure for him to
colour.
I noticed a distinct trait in Akshay's behaviour. He had a penchant
for repeating words and phrases. It could be any thing -- things he
might have heard before or some issue bugging him. Like on day one
Akshay's catch line was "Mummy paas jaana hai." ( I want
to go to my mother ), which he would keep repeating, however much
you tried to distract him. On the second day his theme line was "Jijajee
ko phone kiya ki nahin?" ( Did you ring up dear brother-in-law
? )
And it was Akshay's choice of words on the second day that told me
about another common symptom of Autism -- a need for repetition or
routine. Akshay would constantly repeat sentences, which had no significance
for him, but has stuck with him - somehow. Another interesting feature
of Akshay's speech was garnishing every sentence with the exclamation
'Arrey'. Like, " Arrey arrey, paani pina hai" (Arrey arrey,
I want to drink water.) We soon found out that it wasn't too difficult
to turn all of Akshay's "No"s into "Yes"es. If
only you began each of sentences with "Arrey!" Akshay would
happily give in.
So when he threw a tantrum over eating lunch, we would cajole him
- "Arrey, arrey ! Akshay, khana khalo" ( Arrey arrey Akshay
let's eat ), and in an instant Akshay would agree to have food. These
small breakthroughs really delighted me. After all, there was a way
to the autistic child's heart. It could be as simple as speaking 'his'
language.
Even as all these children were fascinating - each in his own way,
one of them was strikingly different from the rest. Thirteen-year-old
Dipen looked a smart, energetic and tough kid -- with a passion for
sports and cars. He was on his toes all the time -- either playing
or hitting the other children. Add to this his spectacular imagination.
As I sat next to him in the car, he told me that the car ahead of
us had lots of diamonds and went on to explain his elaborate strategy
to procure the gems. With that sort of vivid imagination, he could
well make a wonderful Bollywood screenplay writer, I thought.
Actually, in all his mannerisms, actions and words, Dipen defied
the very limits of Autism. At first glance you would mistake him for
a normal 13-year old boy. Only on closer interaction did you get to
know about his autistic traits. For, even though his world was made
of grand imagination, he was almost closed to the other person's world.
As long as you abided by the code of his planet, it was okay, but
if you insisted on him to accept your norms, he would put up a stiff
resistance. So there it was -- Dipen's communication was almost one-sided.
As I mentioned earlier, 80% of all autistic people are males. Which
explains why little Vrinda was the only girl in our group. But it
was for entirely different reasons that she emerged the ultimate star
of the show. Barely six years of age, Vrinda has the most charming
of faces and the most captivating of smiles. As if those weren't enough,
Vrinda is a gifted singer. She is also obsessed with crayons. And
her liking for crayons is not just restricted to splashing them on
paper. It goes to the extent of her chewing them up! Vrinda is a good
communicator -- she can tell you about her needs. Another reason she
stood apart for in the group was her ability to express emotions.
Autistic children do have emotions but most of them don't express
any. But Vrinda's emotional outpourings were clear. When she had crayons
in her possession, she would flash out her knocking smile. But when
you took away her colours so as to dissuade her from chewing them,
she would throw the choicest of tantrums. She would jump on the bed,
take her voice to a screeching crescendo and remain in that state
-- till you finally gave in to her demands.
Vrinda has one more queer interest -- to bathe; no matter what time
of the day it is and irrespective of whether or not she has had a
bath. In a queen-like manner she would command "Vrinda ko naiya
karna hai" (Vrinda wants to have a bath) And before you knew,
Vrinda would be happlily sitting under a tap -- enjoying a cool shower!
Vrinda's conversational style is no less interesting. Instead of
the first persin pronoun 'I', she uses her name 'Vrinda' to voice
her wishes. "Vrinda wants thanda paani." "Vrinda wants
to take a walk in the garden" (another of her favourite past-times)
and you had to be at 'Her Highness' command.
From silent Hunny to chatty Vrinda -- the world of autistic children
is vast, unpredictable and extremely fascinating. In those two days
of my association with these children I learnt a lot of things. The
most important realization was that though their world might be different
from ours, it is no less rich or vivid.
"Namaste"
Kathy Lissner-Grant
This is an aritcle I am writing for the autism journal in India.
My name is Kathy Lissner-Grant. I am 33 years old and have Asperger's
Syndrome. I live and work independently in Denver, Colorado. The work
I do is part-time for a group home for teenagers with developmental
disabilties. I am one of the people who works from 6 am - 9 am. The
job consists of getting the teenagers up, ready, and dressed for school.
After their buses arrive, me along with a couple of other staff people,
get them on the bus. Once the teenagers leave, we clean the house.
This job entails alot of physical labor. I live independently with
my Himalayan cat, Aziz, and my parakeet, Dhahran.
My interests revolve around countries, maps, flags, collecting things
in foreign languages, reading history and current events, and keeping
up with what's going on in the world. I have the Indian flag at home,
but I don't have a map of India. I have maps of the Middle East, Russia,
USA, Canada and lots more. I also don't have much knowledge of Indian
history. I only am familar with events after 1948. I also have a couple
of things in Urdu, but nothing in any other language that is spoken
in your country. My hope is for the people of your country to know
as much about autism spectrum disorders as much as possible. In this
country, many people are ignorant about autism, especially about people
on the higher end of the spectrum.
My goal is to educate as many people as possible about autism and
Asperger's Syndrome. I have spoken, written, travelled, and given
information about autism. I do this because I feel it is important
for people to know about people like us. Also, we are a people who
want to be accepted by society. And one of the paths to acceptance
is education. Also most people with autism who I have spoken to are
happy being who they are, it's the society they're not happy about.
They find most 'normal' people narrow and biased. Also, I hope that
your government will recognize people with autism spectrum disorders.
After all, India is the biggest democracy in the world and this recognition
would set an example for the former Communist countries and the countries
of the Third World.
Also, if your country recognizes people with autism spectrum disorders,
it would be good because of the big population you have. By recognizing
the millions of people with autism in your country, your country will
prosper and be recognized as an example for the world, especially
Asia, to follow. I am fortunate to be an American in that I have been
well educated and am working and living independently. My dream is
for all people with autism, regardless of functioning level, to work,
live, and be the people they are in happiness and peace. If anyone
wishes to contact me, my email address is:
kgrant@wishingwell.org
My snail mail address is:
Kathy Grant 1235 E. 18th Avenue Denver,
CO 80218 USA
And the Music Played On
Abhrajit Bhattacharjee
I had been waiting for this evening for more than a year. After all,
not only are Action For Autism annual concerts fun, they are also
evenings when we step out beyond our 'comfort zones' and give of our
money, time, and ourselves. This year, the Third Annual Action for
Autism Benefit and Awareness Concert, held on 7 November 1998 at IIT,
Delhi lived up to this promise but was also different and special.
One of the reasons this year was different because many things changed
at the last minute. Originally organised and publicised to be held
at the Farmhouse Restaurant in Mehrauli, the venue had to be shifted
due to unavoidable circumstances, just five days before the concert.
This meant many of the original plans for the evening had to be shelved,
along with a whole new publicity drive. The Open Air Auditorium at
IIT, Delhi was booked, and the parents and friends of Action For Autism,
who this year volunteered to organise the concert, rose to the occasion.
This last minute change in venue, not only threw a lot of logistical
details out of gear, but had the greatest effect on the stars of the
show. I do not refer to Val Shipley & Treble Clef or Parikrama,
both who helped make the evening a success; but to the children of
the Open Door Centre. Just imagine blinding lights, an overwhelming
amphitheatre, hundreds of people, and not one familiar object on stage.
Insurmountable obstacles for most children, but not our autistic stars.
In a striking progression from last year, we were treated to solo
performances. Cheers, applause and Val Shipley's impromptu accompaniment
punctuated the air, as Vrinda Chaswal, Sudhirto Chakravarthy, and
Neeraj Barua knock the socks off an appreciative, albeit, unfamiliar
multitude. Their courage, optimism and outstanding performances that
added a new dimension to the song We Shall Overcome, which all the
children sang at the end.
Many people came to IIT to get rocked, and they were not disappointed.
Val Shipley & Treble Clef, kicked off the entertainment, and set
the mood with some slow, but serious acoustic rock. In the same vein
as Clapton, Knofler and Page, Valentine's versatility and talent buoyed
the entire audience. These were songs we knew, we remembered, and
we cheered Valentine and his amazing voice! I believe that this is
the second time that Val has performed for the Action For Autism annual
concert, and I am sure that we want to see him back next year.
And then it was time for the priest kings of Delhi rock: www.Parikrama.com.
Little on their web site (which, by the way, is possibly the first
Indian site to have their songs available on-line), prepared me for
their blitzkrieg performance. Smoky, raucous, and loud, they got the
crowd on their feet and into the pit. Jim Morisson and the Doors were
the order of the day, but we also heard a few original medleys, some
Sabbath and more than a little of Van Halen. Parikrama also shared
some of their renowned experiments with us. Particularly memorable
was the fusion in the impromptu jugal bandi between Sharat's violin,
Sonam's guitar, and Gyan with his tablas. Playing encore after encore,
mind-blowing riffs and feet stamping medleys, Parikrama showed us
again why Delhi loves them. To me Parikrama is special for more than
their music. This evening was yet another example of Parikrama's support
for people with disabilities, and those of us who are different, and
proud of it. Play on, Parikrama, play on.
Many of us do not realise how much it takes to put on a successful
show. Friends and parents of Action For Autism certainly do. It was
their time, creativity, availability and initiative that made the
evening soar. Whether it was making banners (and awesome T-shirts!),
staffing desks, shaming friends and colleagues into donating money
or even waiting outside the Farm House restaurant to let people know
that the venue had shifted, the organisers deserve our admiration
and appreciation. I hope that after the applause and kudos are forgotten,
everyone who helped, remembers the Concert as an example of concerned
people getting involved to make something greater than the sum of
their achievements. People like them are inherently more powerful,
concerned and qualified than institutions, governments or universities
to change the lives of their autistic friends and family. That is
what made the evening different and special.
Book Review
Lekha Nair
Asperger's Syndrome: A Guide for Parents and Professionals
By Tony Atwood
A child walks up to a complete stranger, holds his hand and says,
" Do you like Deltics? They are the most powerful diesel trains.
I have 27 photos of Deltics". She then proceeds to describe these
trains in great detail, without waiting for a response from the stranger,
and indeed, seems quite oblivious of his reaction to her statements.
Another child goes to meet the kids who have just moved in next door
to his house and says, with great enthusiasm, but no other greeting,
"Nine times nine equals eighty-one! "
Both these anecdotes might strike a tolerant observer as interesting,
even endearing, if slightly odd, but hardly the sort of thing that
might warrant an immediate visit to a psychologist. Yet they are used
by Tony Attwood to illustrate the characteristically subtle and intriguing
social skills deficits that are the hallmarks of Asperger's Syndrome
(AS). These include a lack of empathy, little ability to form friendships
with peers, one-sided conversations, intense absorption in a few special
interests and poorly coordinated movements.
The disorder was identified in 1943 by Hans Asperger, a Viennese
pediatrician, who recognised it as a version of autism, but his work
only gained wider recognition during the past two decades, largely
due to the work of Lorna Wing and Uta Frith in the U.K. (See references
below). This book is the first which brings together, in one source,
the issues of diagnosis, understanding and interventions. It is written
in a clear and simple style that makes it useful for the non-specialist,
yet is remarkably comprehensive and accurate enough to be used by
professionals. The author is a clinical psychologist who has interacted
with over a thousand people with AS, ranging from children as young
as three, to a retired professor who is a Nobel Laureate. He brings
a tremendous empathy and respect for the people he has known and studied,
and emphasizes that often their creative and highly original thinking
has contributed to the enrichment of the fabric of society.
Just as in other expressions of autism, Asperger's Syndrome is a
spectrum disorder.
Each person is different and the abilities and impairments can vary
widely, but the pattern of behaviors, once recognised is clearly identifiable.
Yet even today, the central problem remains diagnosis. Since most
of these children have fluent speech, and other than in the area of
social skills, intellectual development seems unimpaired, most are
not diagnosed correctly and have to deal with the consequences of
their disabiliy throughout their lives, with no clinical support.
The impact on families can be devastating, since the vast majority
of parents don't know what affects their child, and while they cope
as well as they can, they inevitably have to deal with society attributing
the child's behaviour to "psychological" causes, or "bad
parenting".
The book addresses the issue of diagnosis by listing all four sets
of standard diagnostic criteria that have been established internationally
by various professional bodies (DSM-IV from the U.S., Gillberg and
Gillberg from Sweden, Szatmari et. al., from Australia and the WHO)
and then goes on to elaborate on each of the factors involved in the
diagnosis. The subsequent chapters address specific areas: social
skills, language development, special interests and routines, motor
skills, cognition and sensory issues for people across the spectrum,
frequently referring to writings of people with AS.
Attwood's basic approach throughout the book, is to describe the types
of difficulties experienced by people with Asperger's syndrome, put
these into perspective by analysing the reasons why they occur and
then give specific suggestions and clear strategies that help the
person to learn how to deal with them. At the end of each chapter,
there is a one page summary of suggested interventions, which serves
to reinforce the material presented within.
Regarding the pivotal issue of social skills development, perhaps
the first crucial step that is the key to successful interventions,
is to understand that a lot of the difficulties arise because the
child does not automatically understand the unwritten rules of social
engagement. Knowledge that the most of us acquire through incidental
learning or "social referencing" (imitating other people's
behaviour, gauging their reactions and responding to them), has to
be explicitly learned by people with AS. He uses the analogy of "culture
shock", where someone from another culture ends up doing all
the wrong things because they don't know the assumptions and unwritten
rules of social interaction. Once the reasons are explained, the person
copes better. The most effective way of doing this is using a technique
called "Social Stories", which explain, in an objective
manner, why a particular activity occurs, and why certain behaviours
are expected during that time.
For instance, to teach the child to stay quiet in church and respond
only at particular times, one can start by stating simply, "People
go to church to pray. In church, the pastor delivers a sermon, the
Bible is read and hymns are sung. During the sermon, the people sit
quietly and listen. It is important to be quiet so that everyone can
hear the sermon. Once the sermon is over, prayers are said and hymns
are sung. Sometimes during the prayers only the pastor speaks. At
other times, all the people speak. Some prayers are said silently.
I can remember when to be silent by listening to the pastor and also
by copying my parents." These stories are most useful if they
are written down and read with the child. The statements should be
appropriate to the age and maturity of the child.
Children with AS often have difficulty making friends because of their
limited social skills and single minded focus on their own interests
and impaired perspective taking skills. The social story technique
is a very effective technique for enhancing the social skills of children
with AS, so that they can learn to make friends and play effectively
with their peers. Statements that show how to start, maintain and
end play, such as "Can I join in?", "What would you
like to do next?", "Can you help me?" etc can be taught.
When he wants to be alone, instead of abruptly leaving the scene,
he can be taught to say, "I want to play by myself now",
in a neutral tone of voice. While the need to use such statements
may seem obvious to most children, and are part of everyday conversation,
this is not usually the case with AS children, who would be more likely
to state the obvious and say "You won't do what I say. I don't
want to play with you!", with no idea that such a categorical
statement is hardly conducive to building friendships.
There is a need to explain what is normally called 'theory of mind'
i.e. empathizing with another person, and imagining yourself in another
person's shoes. 'What is the other person feeing when you say this?
What would you feel when someone says this to you?' The author describes
in detail Carol Gray's Comic Strip Conversation that uses a comic
style pictorial description of the different levels of communication
that occur in a conversation. Stick figures, speech and thought 'bubbles',
symbols and colour are used to enable the child to see aspects that
they may not be aware of. Team games and tiffin break are great oppurtunities
where an aide could be with the child, clearly explain what is expected
of him as a member of a team, even something as obvious as not passing
the ball to an opposition team member who asks him for it.
Other useful suggestions made by the author include teaching the AS
child to
use other children as cues to show appropriate behavior, explain body
language, monitor and rehearse appropriate behaviour for various situations,
teaching the child to not vocalize thoughts in public, helping the
child with auditory discrimination and distortion problems by providing
written instructions or reducing extraneous sounds and clearly enunciating
sentences with pauses in between, teaching the child how to modify
stress, rhythm and pitch to emphasize key words and associated emotions.
Special interests can be used to de-stress, motivate and developed
later in life into a career and a productive life. Given the right
inputs children make remarkable progress.
There is an extended section on Frequently Asked Questions covering
etiology, prognosis and a variety of doubts that often plague parents.
While issues are tackled squarely, there is a humaness and a determinedly
positive outlook that is uplifting.This reviewer found this a very
useful well written book. The only quibble, in the writings that he
quotes from people, ages would have been useful to know, while preserving
anonymity.
References:
Asperger H.(1979) 'Problems of infantile autism.' Journal of the
National Autistic Society.
Wing, L. (1981). 'Asperger Syndrome : A clinical account.' Psychological
Medicine, 11, 115-130.
Gray, C. (1994). Comic Strip Conversations. Arlington: Future
Horizons
Launch of the World Autism Organisation
Paul Trehin, WAO Secretary General
On 21 November 1998 the World Autism Organisation (WAO) was officially
launched during a ceremony held in the hemicycle of the European Parliament
in Luxembourg in the presence of Her Royal Highness the Grand-Duchess
Joséphine-Charlotte.
The initiative for WAO was taken by Autism Europe, starting from a
suggestion by Dr. Hans Wulffsberg from Denmark. This idea came from
two observations:
1) There is no official WHO documentation in the field of autism.
So far, WHO has no office for autism or publications on autism. Neither
does UNESCO have an education program for autism. WAO will advocate
for such worldwide endeavour.
2) In many countries of the world, autism is not recognised nor accepted
as belonging to the ordinary disability groups. Thus autistic people
and their families do not have any of the rights or access to support
systems that other disabilities have. Such is the case in India and
China for instance. In China on the other hand persons with many other
disabilities have quite good living conditions. As for Africa, few
have heard about autism. The majority of autistic people of the world
reside in countries where services are either very weak or non-existent.
One reason for creating the "World Autism Organisation"
is to get recognition from such organisations as WHO, UNESCO and United
Nations. It is urgently required of WHO to give official approval
to the most recent, relevant diagnostic instruments, publish the most
relevant medical interventions, as well as the 'treatment' which is
primarily pedagogical.
The other reason to create this new organisation will be to promote
support to autistic people in countries where it is inadequate. This
will be done through information programs and professional training.
The organisation that was announced on November 21 is the framework
for starting our world wide support group. To that effect, we proceeded
on Sunday 22 November, to the formation of a first "Interim"
Council of administration in charge of setting up the future organization
structure and functioning rules. The people present at the founding
meeting elected the Council. The Interim Council then elected the
following delegates to the Executive Committee:
President: Pat Mattews (Ireland)
Vice President Africa: Willelm Kabemba Lutumba (Congo)
Vice President Asia (South Asia) : Merry Barua (India)
Vice President Asia (Far East) : Conchita Ragragio (Philippines)
Vice President South America : Isabel Bayonas (Spain)
Vice President Europe : Christos Alexiou (Greece)
Secretary General: Paul Trehin (France)
Treasurer: Joan Roca i Mirales (Spain)
The other members of the Council are:
Hans Wulffsberg (Denmark)
Evelyne Soyez (France)
Kees Helmstrijd (Netherlands)
Rita Thomassin (France)
The statutes presented on 21 November are by no mean set in stone.
The founding members present in Luxembourg adopted a slight amendment
regarding individual membership on Sunday 22 November. It is more
than likely that during the period between now and the first General
Assembly in May 2000, the statutes will need to be revised in order
to fit the needs and preferences of autistic people and their parents.
The Interim Council has been requested to collect comments throughout
the world and make proposals to the first General Assembly by which
time we would like to have a maximum of countries from all continents
represented.
The first General Assembly of the World Autism organisation will
be organised in the year 2000 coupled with the YEAR 2000 AUTISM EUROPE
CONGRESS, in Glasgow.
World Autism Organisation and Visits to
Dublin, London & Brussels
Merry Barua
It was my privilege to be present at the launch of the World Autism
Organistion by Self Advocates, Parents and Professionals. My journey
started in Dublin. When Anne-Sophie Parent of Autisme-Europe sent
me the invitation to attend the launch of the World Autism Organisation,
my first concern was how to get there! Pat Mathews, President of the
Irish Society for Autism (ISA) stepped in with an invitation to Ireland
and an offer to sponsor my travel.
I arrived in Dublin on a cold wet November night and on a following
cold but sunny Monday morning John Saunders drove me out to the Dunfirth
Autistic Community, a 32-acre residential facility for 37 adults with
autism. Residents live in individual apartments or shared homes depending
on their preferences. Woodwork, pottery, pig farming, poultry, farming,
and a deer farm are among the various vocations available to the residents.
The carpentry unit is large and spacious with every kind of carpentry
tool available. Much of the woodwork is done using the unique bog
oak that has lain buried in Irish soil for centuries. I spent a day
at the pottery unit with Eugene the potter who works with the residents.
Both David who helps train at the carpentry workshop as well as Eugene
are enthusiastic and extremely innovative in teaching skills and adapting
and evolving ways of teaching, keeping in mind the needs of the person
with autism.
The Dunfirth community has been made possible by the efforts of parents;
another example of what parents in India want to understand: If we
want facilities for our children we will have to work for it ourselves.
No one is going to do it for us. Even during my stay Pat and other
members of the Irish Society for Autism was meeting and negotiating
with state health officials, for setting up of residential facilities
in other counties of Ireland.
From Dublin I travelled to London. The National Autistic Society
of UK was holding their annual conference The Autistic Spectrum: Theory
into Action. The day before the conference the NAS had planned a meeting
of representatives of International societies to discuss setting up
a forum for sharing information, practice and policy, and networking.
Would I be there? With Pat's generous offer under my belt, I had informed
I would.
I was glad to have made it. A few years ago when I was struggling
to put together legislative information on Autism for our government,
Lena Anderson of Sweden was one of those I had contacted and received
help from. It was exciting to meet up with her and also meet the President
of the Swedish Organisation. There were others I had been in touch
with, heard of, read, or whom I was meeting for the first time. For
this reason too I was glad to have made it to the pre-conference meeting:
the actual conference was a mammoth gathering with over 500 participants
and I have difficulty dealing with very large crowds and tend to shut
myself off. I would have been totally incapable of going up to these
interesting people and initiating a conversation! something I was
able to do with little difficulty the previous day. Perhaps this is
the reason why I have no difficulty in creating a great rapport with
persons with autism!
The Conference had talks and presentations by Lorna Wing, Simon Baron
Cohen, Fracesca Happe, Margot Prior, Christopher Gillberg, tony Bailey,
Patrick Bolton, Judith Gould, Amitta Shah and Tony Attwood amongst
others.
On to Luxembourg. I arrived on a brilliantly cold morning. That afternoon
the launch of the World Autism Organisation took place in the European
Parliament building, which I located after slipping on some frozen
ice in my silk sari over a completely deserted highway! Some of us
had the privilege of receiving and being presented to her Royal Highness
the Grand-Duchess Josephine-Charlotte. As one of the five who would
be speaking at the launch I was in the privileged bunch! It was rather
exciting to stand in a row while the Grand-Duchess shook hands with
each of us. I must say I was impressed when her Highness commented
knowledgeably on the work AFA was doing in India!
The launch itself was a brief and dignified affair, starting with
a welcome of her Royal Highness by Gilbert Huyberechts, President
Autisme-Europe, with each speaker keeping within the time limits set;
an example that we in India with our verbal fecundity could well emulate.
Hans Hoegh, Secretary General International Disability Foundation
made the Opening address as Honorary Chair of the meeting followed
by an address by Mrs M.J.Jacobs, Minister of Disabled People Luxembourg.
This was followed by an review of the situation in India by myself,
of Action for Autism, an account of the Establishment of a regional
South American Organisation by Isabel Bayonas of APNA ESPANA, the
future role of the WOA by Dr Hans Wulffsberg, concluding with Pat
Mathews Vice-President Autisme-Europe and President of the Irish Society
for Autism.
The launch was followed by cocktails and dinner. One encountered
a charming informality and friendliness that was quite incredible.
And then the reason for the difference struck me. Of course! I was
amongst families!! Each one of us was a person with autism, a parent,
or other family member of a person with autism. There was a bonding
and closeness and friendliness that was unique. One had the opportunity
to meet with visitors from China, Congo, France, Denmark, Germany,
Hungary, Ireland, Sweden, the Netherlands, the Philippines, Spain,
the United Kingdom, the United States among others, and of course
from Luxembourg. I was struck by the exceptionally high motivation
among parents in many of these countries in taking the initiative
in accomplishing services for their children. Of the events that followed
on the next day, Paul Trehin has give an account in the preceding.
The next day in Brussels, thanks to Anne-Sophie Parent and her excellent
arrangements, one had the opportunity to meet Theo Peeters and attend
a presentation by him. Theo is a highly respected professional in
training parents and professionals in the TEACCH approach in countries
like Denmark, Kuwait, The Netherlands, Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia,
and Sweden.
As a Professor of Literature interested in neruro-linguistics Theo
was introduced to Autism and seduced by the subject, and went and
trained at Chapel Hill in North Carolina. Illustrating the truth that
an interest and love for the subject is way more important reason
for involvement, than a degree in Special Education or background
in Psychology.
Theo's great strength other than his obvious love for the subject
is the total lack of jargon in his presentation, so beloved of many
practitioners. As he put it, "When I am using complex unfamiliar
words, perhaps I have not understood my subject too well!" We
look forward to Theo Peeters coming to India and sharing his training
and attitude with parents and educators.
On a Purely Academic Note...
Tamara Cohen Daley
While of little practical interest, it is nevertheless intriguing
to look back at the history of Autism, and particularly the history
of Autism in India. Since the late 1950's, articles have appeared
in Indian medical and social journals and books in which the authors
describe cases of pervasive developmental disorder, using the terminology
of the day. However, it is also interesting to ponder the possibility
that reports of what we now call "autism" may have appeared
under different names prior to the 1943 article in which Leo Kanner
named it so.
In possibly the first reference to autism and the pervasive developmental
disorders in the Indian literature, a report comes from a Viennese
pediatrician A. Ronald, working in Darjeeling at the time. Ronald
presented an overview of the detection, causes, types and treatment
of what he termed 'abnormal children' in the very same year as Kanner's
hallmark publication: 1944. This article holds significance not only
for its potential early reference to autism, but because it is one
of the earliest scholarly discussions of child mental health in the
leading medical and social journals of the time, and the first in
the Indian Journal of Pediatrics.
Ronald devotes the article to discussing various types of "difficult"
children, including the "deviant" behavior of anger, disobedience,
lack of cleanliness, vanity, lack of politeness, jealousy, lying,
and fanatically truthful children, as well as 'frightful children'.
At the end of his discussion, Ronald adds one final type of "difficult"
child, what he termed the "precociousness of a child." What
follows is his description.
"The precociousness of a child is not always limited to specific
spheres, not to conception alone, on the other hand, it extends to
the whole of mental personality
such children are quite different
from others in respoect of behaviour, speech, movements, and work.
The child-like conduct has partly or fully disappeared, the mental
attitude of such a child becomes somewhat strange and repulsive
such
children are no longer child-like, they do not play and are not cheerful.
Partial precociousness shows itself in the development of a particular
sense, for example, musical sense, calculations, mechanical handling,
and so on. In this group is included the so called prodigy
"
(p. 24)
This description, while tantalizingly short, highlights a number
of the same areas as Leo Kanner in his 1944 article. Ronald notes
that this type of problem does not just effect one area, but 'extends
to the whole of mental personality.' Today we might call that the
"pervasive" aspect of the disorder. Ronald's observation
that the 'child like conduct' of such children is compromised, and
that play is absent; one of the most salient features of a young autistic
child. Just as Kanner noted, Ronald also remarks that these children
may show a special ability in an isolated area, yet concludes with
the foreboding caveat that despite these abilities, these children,
"who do well in school and go ahead of others, do not always
succeed in after life." As any parent of a child who has remarkable
mathematical or other abilities, or whose child passes his exams knows,
these talents do not necessarily guarantee that the child's adult
life is secure.
Certainly it is conceivable that Ronald is referring not to autism,
but rather to children with a less pervasive problem. Yet the possibility
remains that Dr. Ronald may just have provided history with another
early description of Autism-- and all the way from India!
The TEACCH Training Workshop
Sandra Dawson
Chapel Hill, a tiny town making up the triangle of towns ( Raleigh,
Durham, Chapel Hill) houses the University of North Carolina. The university
grounds roll over acres and acres of land, land that is covered with
pine and other trees, lining every road, clustering to form tiny forests
and every now and again opening up to small ponds that invite
the local ducks for a swim. I had the opportunity to visit this pretty
town for the Summer Training Program at TEACHH (Treatment and Education
of Autistic and related Communication handicapped CHildren), a division
of the Dept. of Psychiatry at the University of North Carolina.
The training itself was held at a local preschool where the TEACHH
staff had set up a demonstration class. The five days of the program
were intensive and demanding because there was so much to learn. Though
I have been working using some of the TEACHH method, at the Open Door
Centre, this first-hand experience has contributed a great deal to my
training as a therapist.
The program started off the evening before the first day, when the
participants staying at the hotel met for coffee and snacks. Gary Mesibov,
Director TEACHH, was there along with Alice Wertheimer one of the Trainers
who is also a parent, to welcome the group. There were people from all
over the USA and a group of about six from Puerto Rico. They felt they
had come a really long way for this...until they met me!! After a couple
of days I got quite used to hearing "India! My goodness gracious!
Are you very jet-lagged??"
That evening, just meeting people and sharing made me impatiently look
forward to the first day of the program. TEACHH has conducted studies
and research in teaching methods for many years and has developed a
whole new approach to training people with communication handicaps.
The strategies involved were developed at the time when Dr. Eric Schopler,
Dr. R.J.Reichler and Ms. Margaret Lansing were working with Autistic
children during the 1960's. As understanding of the disability grew
it became clearer that treatment of the autistic individual with psychoanalytic
therapy, based on the premise that autism was a psychological illness,
was not effective at all. What was really required was the construction
of a program that would involve the family of the child as co-therapists,
and that they be taught a special education approach that could be tailored
very specifically to their child's individual need based on general
guidelines.
The TEACHH method was described as a supporting teaching-aid that can
be and must be adapted to specific situations in order to be truly effective.
The aim of TEACHH is two-fold:
a) To gain control of the teaching setup
and then give it back
to the children.
b) To teach independence.
What makes the TEACHH approach different is that the focus is on the
environment more than the child, though they are really our guides.
It tries to bring changes in the physical, social and communicating
environment to accommodate the difficulties people with autism have
while training them to perform in more appropriate ways.
TEACHH also focuses in on the fact that people with autism are extremely
strong visual learners. Therefore the addition of visual clarity to
teaching anything produces better results. A word commonly used and
heard at TEACHH but taken very seriously is 'STRUCTURE'. It is their
strategy. Structured Teaching is basically a layered module of working
that helps to communicate in a visually clear manner and built receptiveness,
understanding, organization and finally independence.
There are different ways of building structure in the child's life.
Some of them are physical organization of furniture, division of activity
areas, schedules and work systems, clarity of instruction and organizing
time.
On the first day, Roger Cox, the director Education at the University,
give us an overview on Autism. He helped put it into perspective and
briefly summarized what autism is all about. He then went on to introduce
to us what the training program would involve and familiarized us with
the five children who would be in the demonstration class.
From the second day on, most of the program was practical work. We
were each given the opportunity on different days to write in the child's
diary, do an assessment, prepare independent work and prepare an independent
game for the children. Different children were assigned to us each day.
Each one unique
and yet so incredibly alike; some so similar to
our children at the Open Door Centre!
The demonstration classroom was set up on the guidelines TEACCH has
laid down, and accommodated the five children we were going to work
with during the program. The room was physically divided into clearly
demarcated work, play and and social activity areas. Each child had
a schedule to follow that clearly showed a sequence of activities to
be completed in the day. Picture or word cards were used to communicate
to the child where he is supposed to go or what he is supposed to do.
The illustration on the card was specific to the area (e.g. a book to
denote the reading area, a tambourine to denote music time etc.). so
the child knew exactly what was expected of him as soon as he saw the
card.
The entire day had two one on one sessions, that lasted ten minutes
each, one independent work time, one snack-time, one tiffin break and
one group activity for each child. We were allowed to observe and plan
for each of these sessions through the days of training. No group was
given any help at all, which meant that even the ideas for the activities
had to be completely original. There were people from various backgrounds
of teaching and training in my group
some who had and others who
had never had any experience with the TEACCH method. Sharing and combining
our experiences with children, to create activities based on this new
approach was quite exiting. Watching the children follow their schedules
so comfortably and willingly was a great motivator for me.
Interestingly but not surprisingly, structuring social activity such
as play was the most difficult. It 'close-ended' and shortened social
time in such a way that it became work. But then autistic people work
much better than they play and structuring play helped them feel more
in control than unpredictable and open ended social situations. Tyler
the five-year-old we planned the game for had never enjoyed a game of
basketball as much as he did this one. Jesse the high functioning boy
in the group has recently started attending a regular school. The teacher
makes a special effort to provide a written schedule that helps him
go through the school day without getting frustrated or confused. At
social times during the day he is mostly on his own, but in a designated
area which keeps him calm and happy.
At the end of the five days, we had an evening meal together with some
of the high functioning autistic young men. The one at our table joined
in the conversation whenever possible. It was very interesting to hear
his opinions about the college basketball team (which he hopes to be
part of), the town, the government and life in general. The entire staff
of TEACHH is wonderful and committed. One could see them truly enjoying
their work and growing more respectful and proud of the children they
work with, with each passing day and each step of improvement.
It makes so much sense to help a child the way he or she needs to be
helped rather than stick to old, run of the mill, completely ineffective
methods. TEACHH methods can be used alongside other methods to make
them more effective. The structure provides a strong base for other
therapies. A little bit of structure for the person with autism can
go a long way in helping him learn faster and better.
We have adapted and brought in some basic guidelines to structure the
Day-Program at the Open Door Centre and hope to do more in the future
too. We are already seeing positive results as the students feel more
in control and independent. In the following issue we will discuss the
TEACCH method in more detail so that if there is anyone interested in
setting up the structure for their child, they can do so.
Helpline
Q. I am working
in a special school as a special teacher. I have a student who is autistic.
He is 22 years old. He has little bit of eye contact. He can listen,
understand and obeys sometimes and does some type of sounds. I want
to cultivate eye contact and slowly train him. Please give me hints
or papers or something so that I can cultivate eye contact as earlyas
possible for my student.
A. The young man you have written about,
is he a new student at the school? Twenty two seems a bit late to start
intervention. However, no age is too late! In helping the student the
one important point you want to keep in mind is that you do not use
force to teach. Force can mislead with short term gains but is totally
ineffectual for long term learning apart from being a violation of the
disabled person's rights.
Following on this, to improve eye contact you do not force the person
to look at you. A few things you can do are:
1. Sit at a level that is slightly lower than the student so that you
actually make it easier for him to make contact with your eyes.
2. When presenting something to him, like handing him a pen/pencil,
hold the object at your combined eye level. What I mean is, if there
were a straight line from your eye to his, hold the object on this line
of gaze. This will create an opportunity for him to inadvertently look
into your eyes when reaching for or looking at the object.
3. If the student is interested in an object, bring your face, and particularly
eyes, within the line of gaze that is an extension of the line from
his eye to the object of interest.
4. Where possible hold the object of interest up between your eyes as
suggested above.
5. When making a request or giving an instruction, take the student's
name, give a brief pause, and then complete the instruction. Try and
lower yourself within eye gaze when doing this.
6. Whenever you get a look from the student, no matter how brief, be
excited and acknowledge. We have to be really and genuinely excited
in order for our true feelings to be communicated to the student with
enough intensity in order to really enthuse him.
7. Most importantly, we want to keep in mind that the student will not
improve eye contact because we want him to do so. Ultimately he himself
must want to look in order for the strategy to succeed.
Now that the student is 22, perhaps you want to focus on teaching him
to work independently and learn vocational skills. Perhaps he is doing
so already?
Q. I work with a child who is developmentally
delayed, with autistic tendancies. He has been biting other adults the
children and me. Do you have any suggestions on how to deal with/stop
this behavour? I've tried time-outs, using angry facial expressions,
strong voice tones, and giving him something else to chew on. But I'm
not having much luck. I think he understands most of what is being said
to him is simplfied but he has no verbal language. He is eight.
A. Okay. Firstly we find that in most
cases, time outs, angry facial expressions, strong voice tones do not
work. We know that this is a child who is socially impaired. Chances
are that when he is occupying himself twirling a thread or obssessively
building with blocks one feels 'Oh thank goodness' and generally leaves
him be. However, when out of stress, or frustration at his inability
to communicate there is an attempt to bite there is, if I may guess,
always a big reaction. So here is this child who learns soon enough
that when I put my teeth against a person's flesh there is this excitiing
thing that happens: there is a frisson in the air, this person makes
a big noise and interesting faces, and generally a lot of exciting things
happening. So maybe I want to try it again to watch the interessting
developments that follow! Soon it develops into what we call
reaction getting behaviour.
So what do I do? Do I sit there and ignore it and let this little fellow
bite a chunk out of my arm? I dont think so! Instead, since I know he
does this I could be focussed to catch some cue that tells me he might
do this, and position my body such that he cannt get a bite. If I am
in close poximity doing an activity with him maybe I could keep my hands
casually and gently on his shoulders so that even if he wants to lean
forward for a nip he is unable to. For group activities with other children
I seat him in such a manner that again he is unable to get his teeth
anywhere near for a bite. When a bite does take place best if the child
receives no reaction for it. If it is one of the teachers just remove
yourself. If one of the other kids, again maybe you remove the other
child and give the recipient of the bite a lot of attention. Not 'oh
poor you' kind rather a rub on the spot, or a kiss or a hug. The idea
is that the biter receives NO attention for the act and instead the
bitee(!) ends up with a lot of attention.
This is certainly not the only way but we find this manner of dealing
with most challenging behaviours very effective. Has worked with a range
of our kids. Perhaps you will find this useful.
Q. I am seeking information on including
autistic childrent in primary school. How to handle negative behaviors
such as biting, scratching, hair pulling, pinching, and kicking.
A. We are often told by families that
their children have behaviours such as biting, kicking, pinching, hitting
etc. that are a cause of a lot of concern as they are undesirable and
also difficult to deal with at times especially in social situations.
As you are aware Autism affects the social development of a person.
A social skill that we take for granted is the ability to get another
persons attention. Children with autism do not know how to get attention.
What they do learn as they grow is that when they are sitting alone
or quietly or doing their own thing, people may pay little or no attention
to them but as soon as they do something like kick or scream or bite,
they get an interesting reaction like a shout or a scream, or a loud
'No'. the behaviour is often discussed at great length and a whole lot
of attention and importance given to it. For most children such behaviours
are learned and reinforced by the reactions they get.
So if we want to eliminate these behaviours we need to IGNORE ALL BEHAVIOURS
WE DO NOT WANT and ACKNOWLEDGE/PRAISE ALL BEHAVIOURS WE DO WANT. Catch
the child sitting quiet and praise him for that. Completely ignore him
when he is pulling hair. We also want to structure the environment so
as to avoid the behaviour happening in the first place. Behaviours that
hurt can be avoided by taking care not to be near enough to get your
hair caught. Take shoes off before sitting to work so you don't get
hurt when kicked. Hold the child's hand gently so you can anticipate
a pinch. Occupy the child's hands as much as possible so he uses them
for constructive activities instead of pinching!! If anyone does get
pinched, for this method to be totally effective, it should just be
ignored. People in the environment need to be especially aware not to
discuss any of the children in their presence because this too is attention
to them.
One other suggestion is to provide them with alternatives of behaviour.
Most often we tell our children "Don't pull her hair" or "Stop
Hitting" or "No! Don't bite". We tell them what not to
do but not what to do. So give them alternatives. "Hands down"
"Leave hair"
"Sit smartly"
"Feet
to yourself". And whenever he is behaving as desired we want to
praise positive . " Kept your feet to yourself
smart boy!"
or "Being gentle when you touch
excellent!" etc.
These are some of the methods used that we find very effective in the
long term. One important thing to keep in mind is that when we ignore
it MUST be done with comfort. Even if we don't look at them or show
our discomfort they can sense it and may use that as a button to push
everytime. I hope that this will be helpful. You want to remember that
results will not show in a day or even in a week for some children.
But remain persistant and consistant for the effort to eventually pay
off.
Q. Your article about Sensory Integration
Therapy in August '98 issue was useful and interesting. Please let me
know the names of any Sensory Integration Therapist in South India or
in any other part of the country.
A. SIT is an interesting and useful therapy
for individuals with sensory sensitivities. The demand for this therapy
is increasing throughout the world and is used with people with autism
as well. We have found in our experience with people with autism that
though this therapy may help, it does not address the main areas of
affect, which are communication and socialization. The exercises involved
in the process can be enjoyable and fun. But for your child's development
it is crucial that he receives Behavioural Therapy in a structured environment
on a regular basis. You could do the different exercises for SIT at
home using things available at home in the most inexpensive manner.
However as a parent, the decision is yours finally
We do not know of any therapist who does only SIT but the Spastics Society
at Chennai should be able to give you a reference.
Letters to the Editor
Raphael is a little miracle in our lives. When I first made contact
with you Raphael was clearly an autistic child who along with having
several other deficits, was non verbal, barring just 5-6 words vocabulary.
Now he is a happy child who speaks all the time, of course not like
any other six year old but showing better and better use of language
and using it as an effective tool for communication. Although he does
exhibit echolalic use of the language at times but it seems that he
is trying to practice, previously heard sentences and also using them
to communicate. Sustained conversation is still difficult, but mostly
his language is meaningful. His receptive language is even better than
expressive language. In al other development areas he has made remarkable
improvements, including sociability and self help. (plays with brother
all the time, and has learned swimming too) His diagnosis would rather
be Semantic Pragmatic Disorder now than Autism !!!
But changing diagnosis is more of academic thing, because our treatment
approaches remain the same which are based on his situation and needs.
He is back with us in Karachi and we are trying to put him in a mainstrem
school on a part time basis and at the same time providing special language
classes.
Regarding progress in Karachi, following Dr. Mesibov's visit only
my self went to Division Teacch to get the training there. Another school
setup a classroom for autistic children but according to my information
they do not have specially trained staff for that purpose. There are
two more schools who have a classroom each for autistic children but
they also probably have the same problem. . These three schools are
serving for various kinds of physical and mental disabilities since
long time already. In any case the schools are making some efforts in
this direction and may be in near future we will have a better setup
here too.
As for myself, I have started a school (finally) for autistic children
and now have three students. The name is Autism Institute and its address
is, 62-K, PECHS Block 6. Karachi.
Dr Shoaib Ahmed
Karachi, Pakistan
Thank you for the wonderful workshop on Autism you conducted in
August 1998 at Dolna, Calcutta.
Though I am not the mother of a child with autism, I have to counsel
parents at MENTAID and help in assessment of the children. The workshop
has helped me tremendously in identifying children who may be autistic.
The practical examples you gave made all the difference.
I wish the autism movement every success and hope the Calcutta Chapter
will open soon, so that we too can refer children to an appropriate
place for education, instead of being compelled to absorb them in Centres
with the mentally handicapped.
It was also good meeting Neeraj. The very best for the future of
Action for Autism.
Iona Kundu
Director, MENTAID
Announcements
Act Now!!!
The one question every parent asks without fail is "What after
us?" Yet how many of us actually DO SOMETHING that will give us
answers for the future? How many of us actually stop to think of real
concrete things keeping the future in mind? Still, we will never stop
asking. "What will happen to my child after me".
There are no magical answers. What happens to my child in the future
depends largely on what I DO NOW IN THE PRESENT. If I work towards a
society that will welcome my child I will have to work on it from NOW.
THIS INSTANT. Not, "well he is in a school now so I don't have
to worry now I will think about it when he is 18'.
ACT NOW!!! If you want to take the initiative, if you want to be actively
involved, if you want to be in touch with like-minded families, write
to us c/o Action Now.
Rett Syndrome Association of India
It is proposed to form a Rett Syndrome Association of India which would
be a non-profit association, with the following objectives:
~ bring together people whose children or family members are afflicted
with this disorder
~ collect information on the studies being conducted in this field and
the treatment usually recommended
~ find out possibilities of rehabilitation for patients, in order to
bring them to the mainstream to the maximum extent possible
In short, a modal agency which would address all the issues associated
with this disorder. Those who are interested in joining the association
may contact:
Roney Mammen
27/3383 Makkar Lane
Perumanoor
Cochin 682 015
Tel: 316753 Res
Telefax: 321524 Off