N E T W O R K
December 2003 Vol. X, No. 3
Towards the end of November an event significant to Americans with autism
took place in Washington DC. An Autism Summit Conference was held, at
which the federal government for the first time mapped out a 10-year
Autism Research Roadmap, addressing the growing 'problem' of autism
in the United States. This is a landmark step for the Autism Society
of America (ASA), which has long advocated for a major government commitment
to autism. In addition, it seems that by the middle of January the US
Congress will in all probability approve a further $3 million budget
for autism activities at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
While we in India do not have such dramatic events to report, the small
steps we have taken have not been insignificant. A very important recent
achievement has been the launch of the Diploma in Special Education
in Autism by the Rehabilitation Council of India (RCI). Action For Autism
has advocated for such a course for many years, fully aware of the fact
that unless a rehabilitation training had RCI certification, only a
few would want to train. Finally, overcoming great odds and much misinformation,
AFA has succeeded in its efforts and the course has been started on
a pilot basis. The autism community is deeply grateful to the Rehabilitation
Council of India for this important step.
Nearly a year ago AFA was visited by Pawan Sinha, Professor of Brain
and Cognitive Sciences at MIT. An accomplished yet wonderfully humane
academician, Dr Sinha spent the time at AFA learning about the situation
in India for persons with autism. Pawan Sinha's work focuses on how
the human brain interprets visual information and recognises objects
and faces, which Sinha theorises is a holistic process.
A scientist who considers it important that his work have applied value,
Sinha has put his research to work for the blind. A project close to
Sinha's heart is Project Prakash in India, which has arisen out of Sinha's
interest in understanding how the human brain learns to recognize objects
and making his research interest work in the real world. Project Prakash
studies children who have regained sight following congenital blindness,
and systematically characterizes the development of their visual skills.
This Sinha hopes will assist visually impaired children to be eventually
mainstreamed. The project is hoped to improve the lives of many children
while at the same time answer some of the fundamental questions of neuroscience
regarding brain plasticity and cognitive development. Prof Sinha has
expressed an interest in undertaking a project in which Action For Autism
is privileged to play a part, involving impairment in face processing
with autism. In this issue Professor Sinha writes on the project that
should start early next year.
Neeraja Ravindran is a psychologist from Bangalore whose area of interest
is Autistic Savants. Tito Mukhopadyaya the gifted young poet and author
from Bangalore has fuelled immense interest in talented persons with
autism who are otherwise severely impaired. Neeraja shares with our
readers her interest in this fascinating segment of the autistic population
As we go to press Dr Rita Jordan has been travelling across India giving
workshops in a collaborative effort between autism organizations in
different parts of the country. In another such partnership ASHA of
Bangalore are taking Gloomy Rabbit - a play on autism especially written
by Vijay Nair - to five centres including Delhi.
While the year ends on this very encouraging note of partnering, 2004
promises to be exciting as well. The year starts with workshops on Verbal
Behaviour Analysis taking place everywhere! Autism Network has carried
articles on the subject in past issues. Based on extensive research,
Verbal Behaviour (VB) is increasingly becoming the preferred mode for
teaching children with autism. VB uses Natural Environmental Training
which helps in the generalization of skills learnt. But more importantly,
VB builds compliance. For many teachers struggling with compliance issues,
the biggest treat is to watch their children comply with every instruction
in every setting and with every instructor.
V Suresh a parent in Dubai has been bringing in VB trainers to Dubai
for more than a year. He is now hosting a workshop by Behaviour Analyst
Patrick McGreevy. In January Chennai has Duncan Fennemore whose earlier
workshop at Mumbai many of us were fortunate to attend. In February
Behaviour Analysts Steve Ward and Teresa Grimes will give workshops
in Kolkata and Delhi. It is wonderful that organizations everywhere
are able to take steps to keep abreast with the latest developments
in the field. It bodes well for the autism movement in India.
By mid 2004, God and our supporters willing, Action For Autism will
move to its new premises at Jasola behind Apollo Hospital. We share
this happiness with our readers and wish you all a splendid year ahead!
Characterizing and Improving Face-processing
Skills in Children with Autism
Prof Pawan Sinha
Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
Introduction: An integral component of a child's mental health is the
ability to correctly interpret visual information about other people
in the environment. Deficiencies in these skills can have devastating
consequences. Indeed, one of the most marked correlates of autism is
'an impairment in the use of multiple nonverbal behaviors such as eye-to-eye
gaze, facial expression, body posture, and gestures to regulate social
interaction' (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders,
Fourth Edition). In order to understand the causes and consequences
of such visual impairments and to design rehabilitation procedures for
mitigating them, it is imperative that we precisely characterize the
visual skills of the affected children. With this motivation, we have
undertaken a research project that seeks to improve the lives of children
Goal: We shall focus our studies on the face-perception skills of children
suffering from autistic disorders. Preliminary experimental data suggest
that such children may have impaired face processing abilities. This
jeopardizes their interpretation of non-verbal cues, compromises effective
social interactions and may lead to emotional disturbance and depression.
Our goal is to experimentally characterize the nature and extent of
face-perception impairments, to determine the processing deficiencies
that may cause the observed impairments, and to refine and test VisTA
(Visual Training and Assessment), a novel tool to help the children
overcome their visual impairments.
Impact: This project will be the first to provide us with a comprehensive
set of data regarding impairments in facial processing for autistic
children. The data will be invaluable for understanding the precise
nature of the deficits, evaluating the effectiveness of VisTA, and guiding
the design of other treatment interventions.
Face-processing skills in children with autism
Autism is a pervasive neuro-developmental disorder associated with marked
deficits in a child's social and communicative abilities. Impairments
in social skills are typically accompanied by emotional disturbances
and severe problems in adjustment, making autism one of the most disruptive
disabilities for a child's life. Its prevalence is estimated to be at
least 1:1000 children (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1997).
More recent estimates have suggested an incidence as high as 1:500,
making autism even more common than Down's syndrome. Given its prevalence
and its devastating consequences on the lives of the children affected
and, indeed, their families, our general lack of understanding of autism's
causes and options for ameliorative interventions, is of grave concern.
We propose to focus on a hallmark deficit of autism - difficulties
in social interactions. Specifically, we shall investigate whether this
deficit is caused, at least in part, due to problems in high-level visual
processing. Most person to person interactions are contingent on an
exchange and interpretation of subtle facial cues. It is, therefore,
conceivable that an inability to effectively process facial signals
would manifest itself as impairments in social skills. Investigating
this possibility is important since it has major implications for the
design of treatment programs.
There is already some experimental evidence in support of this idea.
Researchers such as Hobson (1986a, 1986b), Tantam et al. (1989), Gepner
et al. (1994), Loveland et al. (1995), Celani et al. (1999), and Dawson
et al. (2002), have reported that children with autism exhibit impairments
relative to normal controls at tasks involving interpretation of facial
emotions in images. While these findings have not gone uncontested (Ozonoff
et al. (1990); Davies et al. (1994)), they serve as an excellent starting
point for our investigations into the visual correlates of the social
impairments in autism.
Our work has three specific goals:
1. To identify core deficits in face processing by autistic children.
2. To determine the processing abnormalities that might cause the visual
3. To design training routines for improving visual skills.
We next describe the motivation for these goals and our planned approach
for achieving them.
Goal 1: To identify core deficits in face processing
Establishing the basic face-processing deficits associated with autism
is important from many perspectives; it is a pre-requisite for diagnostic
purposes, for guiding the course of treatment and for constraining the
search for causes. Past work, mentioned above, has made a beginning
in this direction. However, the focus has been almost exclusively on
the perception of basic facial expressions. Several other face perception
tasks are largely unstudied. Four of the most important ones needed
for normal social interactions are:
1 Face localization in complex scenes (the first step in analyzing facial
2 Classification of complex expressions (for instance pride, shame and
affection, common in everyday interactions),
3 Assessment of attentional locus (a pre-requisite for shared attention
4 Facial identification across changes in viewpoint (as might occur
during a normal interaction).
We shall test two groups of children on these four tasks. The first
group will include autistic children and the second will be a control
set comprising normal, age-matched children. Children will be diagnosed
for autism at the collaborating hospitals using DSM-IV criteria and
their syndrome severity will be assessed using the Childhood Autism
Rating Scale (CARS) (Schopler et al., 1988). The children will participate
individually in psychophysical experiments designed to probe performance
on each face perception task. Psychophysical sessions will be augmented
with ERP recordings whenever feasible to permit more comprehensive comparisons
between experimental and control groups.
Goal 2. To determine the processing abnormalities underlying deficits
in face perception
By identifying the core deficits in face processing, as described above,
we expect to improve our understanding of the causes of at least some
of the social impairments exhibited by autistic children. To understand
the genesis of the face processing deficits themselves, it is imperative
that we explore another level of causation - what underlying visual
processing deficits might lead to the observed problems in face perception?
We shall address this question in a hypothesis driven fashion. Our hypothesis
is derived from an observation that several high-functioning autistic
individuals have made in describing their sensory experience (VanDalen,
1995; Williams, 1999). The world, to them, appears fragmented and lacks
the 'built-in form of coherence' (Frith, 1989). We shall explore whether
'fragmented perception', or alternatively, the lack of configural processing,
is a plausible causal factor for the observed deficits in face perception
tasks. Our approach will involve psychophysical studies with autistic
and normal children. The facial stimuli used in these experiments will
be transformed so as to selectively influence piecemeal or configural
processing (transformations will include Gaussian blurring, vertical
inversion and image part permutations that preserve the features but
not their configuration). By measuring the influence of these transformations
on performance and face-specific ERP signals, we shall be able to infer
the nature of visual processing deficits that might underlie face perception
impairments in autism.
Goal 3. To design training routines for improving visual skills
Goals 1 and 2 seek to uncover the causes of social skill impairments
in autistic children. Goal 3 is meant to apply this knowledge towards
the design of methods that can alleviate the deficits. To the best of
our knowledge, there are currently no interventions for improving visual
processing by children with autism. We propose a novel approach, VisTA
(Visual Training and Assessment) to address this need. VisTA has several
of the characteristics considered desirable for autism related interventions
(McConnell, 2002) such as the ability to involve both children with
autism and their normally developing peers, portability for use in various
settings throughout the day and easy monitoring of progress.
VisTA is based on a technique for image presentation we have recently
developed called RISE (Random Image Structure Evolution) (Sadr and Sinha,
2001, 2003; Pollak and Sinha, 2002). RISE enables the presentation of
images as time-series while carefully controlling potentially confounding
influences from low-level image parameters. In a RISE sequence, images
gradually evolve and become progressively more recognizable. An observer's
point of perceptual object onset in such a sequence serves as a quantifiable
marker for object perception proficiency. We have used RISE for assessing
object perception skills of children with different developmental histories
(Pollak and Sinha, 2002), for studying phenomena such as object priming
and for identifying object-specific neural responses (Sadr and Sinha,
VisTA extends the usage of RISE to the domain of visual training. VisTA
presents time series showing face images evolving from randomness. The
task of the observer is to try to determine what the evolving image
depicts (say, a particular expression or a specific individual) as soon
as possible after the beginning of the sequence. Since the image is
very degraded near sequence onset, the observer is forced to use overall
configural information rather than relying on piecemeal cues. Our pilot
experiments with normal observers suggest that they find the task engaging,
in the nature of a game, and show significant improvements in their
ability to recognize objects using partial information after a few training
sessions. We believe that the same procedure when conducted with children
with autism, using appropriate facial stimuli, can mitigate their tendency
to rely on fragmentary information and improve their ability to use
overall facial configuration. This would translate into better performance
at many of the socially relevant face-perception tasks such as recognition
of subtle facial expressions.
Logistics: We plan to conduct our experimental studies at two institutions
that draw a significant population of children with autism.
1. Children's Hospital in Boston
The Children's Hospital in Boston is a 300-bed comprehensive center
for pediatric health care. The Hospital's Department of Psychiatry evaluates
and treats children with a wide range of emotional and behavioral disorders,
including autism. It typically records more than 15,000 outpatient visits
and 400 inpatient admissions each year, making it one of the largest
pediatric psychiatric services in New England. The Department develops
interventions for various complex psychiatric problems using cognitive,
behavioral, group, and biological methods.
2. The OpenDoor Center for Autistic Children in New Delhi, India
This center is operated by Action For Autism (AFA), a founding member
of the World Autism Organization. AFA provides counseling, assessment
and educational programs. Children diagnosed with autism are referred
to AFA by prominent national hospitals such as the
All India Institute of Medical Sciences and the National Institute of
Mental Health and Neurosciences. AFA received 123 referrals in 2001.
The OpenDoor Center is the first specialized school for children with
autism in South Asia.
Our decision to work with AFA besides the Children's Hospital is driven
by two considerations:
First, it stands out in terms of the dedication of its members and
their willingness to collaborate on such a project. The staff, in particular,
have impressed me greatly with their deep passion for helping children
with autism and the very welcoming attitude towards this undertaking.
Second, it serves to bring much-needed attention to the problem of
autism in India. India is estimated to have more than 2 million children
with autism and yet public awareness of this disorder and governmental
resources directed towards it are insignificant.
We hope that reports of this work for the scientific and lay audiences
will play an effective role in improving the state of knowledge in India
regarding autism and possible interventions. This is necessary for improving
the quality of life for the many children with autism in India who may
otherwise be treated as social outcasts.
In summary, we propose to characterize face-processing deficits that
may contribute to the social impairments observed in children with autism.
We also seek to improve the children's face-perception skills through
the use of a novel training technique, VisTA. The prospect of helping
the many children who have to overcome challenges imposed on them by
autism is a very compelling one and we look forward to getting the project
underway by the beginning of year 2004.
Ceani, G., Battacchi, M. W., and Arcidiacono, L. (1999). The understanding
of the emotional meaning of facial expressions in people with autism.
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 29, 57-66.
Davies, S., Bishop, D., Manstead, A. S. R., and Tantam, D. (1994). Face
perception in children with autism and asperger's syndrome. Journal
of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 35, 1033-1057.
Dawson, G., Carver, L., Meltzoff, A. N., Panagiotides, H., McPartland,
J., and Webb, S. J. (2002). Neural correlates of face and object recognition
in young children with autism spectrum disorder, developmental delay
and typical development. Child Development, 73(3), pgs. 700-717.
Frith, U. (1989). Autism: Explaining the enigma. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Gepner, B., de Schonen, S., and Buttin, C. (1994). Face processing in
young autistic children. Infant Behavior and Development, 17, 661.
Hobson, R. P. (1986a). The autistic child's appraisal of expressions
of emotion. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 27, 321-342.
Hobson, R. P. (1986b). The autistic child's appraisal of expressions
of emotion: A further study. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,
Loveland, K. A., Tunali-Kotoski, B., Chen, R., Brelsford, K. A., Ortegon,
J., and Pearson, D. A. (1995). Intermodal perception of affect in persons
with autism or Down syndrome. Development and Psychopathology, 9, 579-593.
McConnell, S. R. (2002). Interventions to facilitate social interaction
for young children with autism: Review of available research and recommendations
for educational intervention and future research. Journal of Autism
and Developmental Disorders, 32(5), 351-372.
Ozonoff, S., Pennington, B. F., and Rogers, S. J. (1990). Are there
emotion perception deficits in young autistic children? Journal of Child
Psychology and Psychiatry, 31, 343-361.
Pollak, S. and Sinha, P. (2002). Effects of early experience on children's
recognition of facial displays of emotion. Developmental Psychology,
Sadr, J. and Sinha, P. (2001). Exploring object perception with Random
Image Structure Evolution. MIT Artificial Intelligence Laboratory memo.
Sadr, J. and Sinha, P. (2003). Exploring object perception with Random
Image Structure Evolution. Cognitive Science (in press).
Schopler, E., Reichler, R. J., and Renner, B. R. (1988). The childhood
autism rating scale. Los Angeles, CA: Western Psychological Services.
Tantam, D., Monaghan, L., Nicholson, H., and Stirling, J. (1989). Autistic
children's ability to interpret faces: a research note. Journal of Child
Psychology and Psychiatry, 30, 623-630.
VanDalen, J. G. T. (1995). Autism from within: Looking through the eyes
of a mildly afflicted autistic person. Link, 17, 11-16.
Williams, D. (1999). Like colour to the blind. Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
December is Autism Month!
o Training Workshop By Dr Rita Jordan
o Heritage Tram Ride
o Christmas Party
o Parents Perspective: A Workshop/Discussion on Parent initiative to
meet lack of services
o World Disability Day Walk to Freedom at India Gate
6 - 7 December
o Workshop by Dr Rita Jordan at IIC, supported by
The British Council:
Planning and Executing an Educational Curriculum with a Focus on Communication
o Inauguration By Dr Rita Jordan of AFA's Diploma in Special Education:
Autism 2003 - 2004 Training
o Dinner for families and supporters.
o 'Gloomy Rabbit '
A play on autism in collaboration with ASHA, Bangalore at the Shri Ram
Centre (part of a five city tour).
o Picnic at The Garden of Five Senses
o Christmas Party at Open Door
o Innovative Communication Programming Workshop at the IIC by Dolly
Bhargava Speech Language Pathologist
o Talk on Stress Management for parents of autistic children: Dr. Harish
o Talk on Sexual Issues in Autism
o Dinner Party for children and parents. Sponsored by Kamini Lakhani
: information on venue and timing from Forum For Autism Library
Why Verbal Behaviour
Children diagnosed with an Autistic Spectrum Disorder do not learn
to communicate in a way that is characteristic of typical children.
Some do not develop any speech at all; others may develop speech which
is idiosyncratic and repetitive. These are complex impairments, which
hinder the child's learning and progress in all areas of development.
We all want our children to talk. But before a child can develop 'conversational'
speech she must acquire certain pre-requisite skills .She must for instance
be able to ask for things, label things, receptively identify things
.To acquire all such skills she needs to imitate both motor and vocal
Verbal behavior (VB) is a programme that is based on an assessment
of the language deficit of each child and thereby providing a training
programme to teach skills necessary to use language in everyday life.
Each language skill is taught separately, and once mastered a child
is then taught more advanced speech skills like conversation. Verbal
Behavior is being used successfully in the US in teaching children with
autism and other communication disorders to acquire functional language.
As we are aware, Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA) has been widely used
in the US. So how is it different from VB? To quote a parent who has
successfully switched her son from ABA to VB: "VB is ABA fine-tuned"
.VB is more flexible with a lot of Natural Environmental Training .The
reason why VB is so successful is that it uses the child's likes and
interests to motivate so that she will want to communicate in an appropriate
On Working as a Special Educator Using Verbal Behavior
When I first met R he was two and half years old. R cried a lot and
the only thing that soothed him was the swing. R's mother A and I worked
out a programme and R started to improve. He learnt to sit at the table,
we taught him some basic instructions which he learnt to follow. He
even started to verbalize a little. However, his verbalization was not
consistent . It seemed to come and go and was not always meaningful.
There were still phases when he was stressed and would cry a lot. R
was progressing, but slowly.
Shortly thereafter A and R went the US where R was put on an intensive
programme based on Verbal Behavior. During their three months there
A received training so that she could work with R herself, and also
train others to work with him, on their return to India.
By the time they returned the change in R was huge. He was asking for
things he wanted. He could receptively identify a number of things from
an array of at least five to six pictures. He could label a number of
items from pictures, or in the environment. He could do the same using
a book containing 10-20 different pictures. His imitation had improved
greatly: not only motor but also vocal and even facial expressions.
What this change told me was how much more connected and aware R was.
And he was a much happier little boy. He still has his crying phases
but much shorter and less intense. He is a lot more independent in such
things as toileting, eating and dressing. He is compliant and follows
instructions with all those around him. He enjoys learning.
What I really like when I work with him now is thatwhen he does something
right he looks right at me and smiles. We don't just work at the table:
we work sitting on the floor, in the garden, on the balcony. Play is
an important part of the intervention program so that R learns to play
appropriately. Toys are brought to the tabletop so the table is a fun
I don't want to give the impression that it is all smooth sailing;
it is a lot of hard work. But the progress is apparent to all who know
R. R has just turned four; it is now five months since their return
from the US. R is slowly being introduced to learning in a small group.
He can now ask not only for things he wants but things he needs for
an activity he wants to do, like a brush to paint with, or a spoon to
R still has a long way to go but he has made a great beginning and
is ready to learn. VB has enabled little
R to learn how to learn.
A Confounding Paradox:
The Savant Syndrome
A psychologist and special educator based in Bangalore
Jeremy can stand at the side of the railroad tracks and give you the
cumulative total of the numbers on the boxcars, however many, as the
end of the train rolls by. But he is severely autistic and cannot count.
The central core of the brain includes the lower brainstem, the medulla
oblongata, pons, parts of the thalamus and hypothalamus and the cerebellum.
The most popular theory about the formation of the universe is the Big
Bang theory. 24,628 * 35,482 = 8,73,85,0696.No, these are not facts
and figures I am reeling out of my head. These are answers to relevant
questions that were posed to Samarth. Answers that were given in less
than a minute, with no manual, textual or mathematical aid. Samarth
is all of 6 years old and he is autistic.
All of us are familiar with Tito's name. His books are being read the
world over and almost everyone who is familiar with Tito's writings
will agree that the thoughts, style and comprehension that goes into
each of his lines can only be described as phenomenal. Such talent can
be viewed as marvelous and unbelievable even in a normal adult, let
alone a severely autistic teenager.
How many of us, as parents and special educators of children with autism
are left flabbergasted by a sudden revelation of some stupendous skill
or ability in our child? How many times are we left standing in dumbstruck
astonishment at our child's ability to do complex mental mathematical
operations or exhibit mastery and adeptness at music or drawing or display
a phenomenal memory? How many times are we left wondering about how
come a child, who can barely take care of his needs, who can hardly
even indicate a need to use the toilet or tell us that he is hungry,
who seems to take a zillion years to grasp just the first three letters
of the alphabet, still excels to such mind blowing proportions in some
Jeremy, Samarth, Tito and all other such people you might be familiar
with are called savants. (Earlier described as the "idiot savants"
by Dr. Langdon Down) And their condition over the last few years has
been described as the Savant Syndrome.
"Savant Syndrome is an extremely rare condition in which persons
with serious mental handicaps either from Mental Retardation, Early
Infantile Autism or major mental illnesses (Schizophrenia), have spectacular
islands of ability or brilliance which stand in stark, markedly incongruous
contrast to the handicap. In some, the savant skills are remarkable
simply in contrast to the handicap (talented savants or savant I) while
in the other, rarer form of the condition, the ability or brilliance
is not only spectacular in contrast to the handicap, but would be spectacular
even if viewed in a normal person (prodigious savants or savant II)."
(Dr. Darold Treffert, Extraordinary People)
The condition can be congenital or it can be acquired and develop in
an otherwise normal person following injury or disease to the nervous
system. It occurs in males more often than females in an approximate
ratio of 6:1. The skills often appear suddenly, without explanation,
and can disappear just as suddenly.
The ability or brilliance, while spectacular, occurs within a very
narrow range, considering all the skills in the human repertoire. It
occurs generally in one of the following areas: calendar calculating;
music, almost exclusively limited to the piano, violin or the flute;
lightning calculating and mathematics; art, including painting, drawing
or sculpting; mechanical ability; prodigious memory (mnemonism); or
very rarely, unusual sensory discrimination or extrasensory perception.
Savant Syndrome is very rare and studies have placed the incidence
at 1:2000 in an institutionalized, developmentally disabled population.
The incidence of this syndrome is seen to be much higher in patients
with Early Infantile Autism - it occurs in almost 10% of the cases.
Similarly, talented savants are found to be more common than prodigious
savants - less than 100 cases of prodigious savants have been reported
in all the world literature during the last 100 years.
The Autistic Savant
Raymond Babbitt was probably the person most responsible for making
the term "autistic savant" a household term. This brilliant
and accurate portrayal of an autistic savant by Dustin Hoffman in the
Academy award winning movie Rain Man was largely responsible for creating
an awareness - about not just the condition of autism but also in giving
a wonderful picture of the special, hidden and truly remarkable abilities
that some of these individuals might possess, in spite of their handicap.
Dr. Treffert defines the term "autistic savant" in the simplest
Autistic disorder + extraordinary special skills + remarkable memory
= Autistic Savant
However, it should be remembered that not all autistic persons are savants
and not all savants are autistic. Approximately 10% of people with Autistic
Spectrum Disorder (ASD) have Savant Syndrome at a "splinter skill",
"talented" or "prodigious" level, with the splinter
skills being the most common representation by far. As said before,
Savant Syndrome can also occur in other forms of Developmental Disabilities
such as Mental Retardation (MR), but with much less frequency. Since
MR is more common than ASD and since the frequency of savant skills
in that group is much lower than in persons with autism, it turns out
that approximately 50% of persons with Savant Syndrome have Autistic
Disorders and 50% have some other form of developmental disability including
Among the 10% of persons who are autistic, there is a wide spectrum
of savant abilities. Most common are what are called "splinter
skills", such as obsessive preoccupation with and memorization
of obscure facts such as sports trivia, license plates, the city's bus
systems or with things as bizarre as motor sounds of various electrical
gadgets. "Talented" savants are those people whose special
abilities are more specialized and honed, making those skills spectacular
when seen against the person's overall disability. Finally, "prodigious
savants" are those individuals whose skills and abilities are so
spectacular that they would be obvious even if they were to occur in
a non-disabled person. There are fewer than maybe, 50 persons living
worldwide who would meet the criteria of a prodigious savant and approximately
50% of that group would be autistic savants.
The skills in the autistic savant continue to be seen within a very
narrow but remarkably constant range of human abilities such as music,
usually piano and almost always with perfect pitch; art, typically drawing,
painting or sculpting; lightning calculating; calendar calculating;
mechanical abilities and spatial skills. Map memorizing, remarkable
sense of direction, unusual sensory discriminations such as an enhanced
sense of smell or touch and perfect appreciation of passing time without
knowledge of a clock face are some of the other less frequently reported
skills in these individuals. In most autistic savants, a single special
skill exists while in others multiple skills occur. The skills tend
to be mostly right hemisphere in type - non-symbolic, concrete and directly
perceived - in contrast to the left hemisphere skills that are more
sequential, logical and symbolic, including language specialization.
In a recent research conducted by Dr. Trevor Clark (Autism Association
of New South Wales, Sydney), autistic savants also seem to show exceptional
adeptness in areas of memory, hyperlexia (i.e. the exceptional ability
to read, spell or write), athletic performance and computer abilities,
in addition to the range of skills already mentioned.
Now comes the really intriguing question:
How do they do it?
This is the first question that leaps up in all our minds the minute
we encounter the paradox that is the savant. And there have been about
as many theories to answer this question, as there have been investigators.
Theories that have been suggested thus far as possible etiologies for
the Savant Syndrome include:
o Presence of an eidetic or photographic memory in the savants which
can account for their ability to remember even obscure things with remarkable
o Possible genetic link that could result in the savant skills being
o Sensory deprivation and social isolation factors which makes it possible
for the savant to be extremely aware of even minor changes in the environment
and also produces intense concentration and preoccupation with other
bizarre endeavors such as studying calendars or almanacs or memorizing
o Concrete thinking and inability to reason abstractly: According to
Scheerer, Rothmann and Goldstein, the limitation to concrete thinking,
with the natural human desire to achieve optimum capability, creates
in the savants a continual expansion in his repertoire of these repetitive
and narrow skills because "it is the only way he can come to terms
with the world that is beyond his grasp". This concentration of
skills and channelising of energies into such abnormally limited methods
of retention and expression creates abilities, which on the surface
seem miraculous. Yet, given the narrow outlets for the expression of
these abilities, the abilities are not so astounding (Scheerer et al).
o Compensatory activity and the search for reinforcement have been
seen as major factors that seem to influence the Savant Syndrome. Dr.
LaFontaine stresses positive reinforcement as a powerful motivator for
the intense concentration, skills and practice seen in the savants.
According to Dr. Edward Hoffman, in an institutionalized setting especially,
for the savant, "his mental feats are immensely socially reinforcing;
he will receive a great deal of attention and interest that a normal
retardate would not." Essentially, the savant uses the reinforcement
from others to meet needs for self-esteem and the special skills acts
as a compensation for the inferiority they might otherwise feel.
o Left brain injury and right brain compensation - In recent years,
this has been a theory that provides one of the most plausible explanations
for the condition of the savants. According to one researcher, since
the skills most often seen in an autistic savant are those associated
with right hemisphere functions and the skills most lacking tend to
be those associated with the left hemisphere, left brain injury with
right brain compensation seems to be a very plausible explanation to
the condition. Another researcher, Bernard Rimland, has also highlighted
the simultaneous nature of right brain activities in contrast to the
sequential nature of left-brain activities seen in the autistic savant.
Several brain imaging studies such as PET and CAT scan report findings
in several cases also seem to strengthen this theory.
Though all these theories do seem correct in their own right, they
can all still be considered valid as only descriptions of the various
traits seen in the syndrome and cannot be considered as the cause of
it. There have been a lot more recent findings that seem to shed more
light on the etiological factors; yet, there has not been a definitive
theory that can explain the Savant Syndrome. The savant continues to
remain an enigma to most people who come across him. As LaFonatine concludes,
"the behavior of the idiot savant appears to be complex and truly
difficult to comprehend."
AFA Initiates Mother & Child
AFA has been running its Mother Child Programme
for three years with great success.
The programme seeks to maximize the benefits of the time that the mother
spends with the child, teaching focused, one-on-one intervention on
a daily basis over a three month period. The programme is aimed at
training mothers to go back able to take charge of their child's development.
Mothers form a group where they work with their children under the guidance
of an experienced, trained therapist. They are given extensive feedback
and an opportunity to compare perspectives and forge links with parents
experiencing similar difficulties.
From January 2004 AFA is initiating a sponsorship scheme in order to
reach families from disadvantaged socio-economic groups. AFA will sponsor
one mother and child from outside of Delhi and one mother and child
from within Delhi to attend the programme. For the mother coming from
outside of Delhi accommodation, travel and course costs will be entirely
sponsored by AFA.
Criteria for applicants are as follows:
- household income less than Rs 7000/- per month
- child with diagnosis of autism
- family currently has limited access to services
Please send applications marked 'Mother Child Sponsorship Scheme' to
AFA indicating which course you wish to attend in 2004:January, July
All applications should be accompanied by a letter of recommendation
from local NGO / school principal / paediatrician / psychiatrist or
Q. I am a father of a seven year old
son who has autism. I came to know that you are helping the parents
of autistic children In this regards I would like to know the following
from you. What are the schools with hostel facility that train autistic
children. Secondly the list of doctors with their addresses who are
curing autism through Herbal/ Ayurvedic Medicine, Acupuncture, Allopathic
and Homeopathic treatment.
A. There are no residential schools in
India that are trained to handle children with autism. There are some
special schools with hostel facility, but not for autism. Families of
children with autism use them mostly when they have no option but to
leave their child there. Otherwise if a child's progress is the motivation,
then these schools are not an option.
To answer your second question, there is no medical cure for autism.
There are periodic claims by practitioners of various kinds who claim
a cure. None of these are unfortunately proven or true. The truth is
that autism cannot be cured. However with proper training all children
can progress significantly.
Q. I have a son with autism. I came to
know that I am pregnant again. I want to know what the chances of Autism
are and are there any other parents who had a child with autism but
still had a normal next child. Please guide as soon as possible.
A. First of all congratulations! I can
only imagine that your are experiencing many mixed feelings right now,
but among those, happiness and excitement. Of course, there are many,
many families with one autistic child and other children who are not
autistic, Moreover, because autism is believed to be at least in part
of a genetic disorder, you are also correct that there is a higher likelihood
of a second child also being autistic. I have heard different estimates,
but 1 in 20 is often cited, or slightly higher , because oftentimes
families with autistic children choose not to have a second child, and
we do not know whether those children would also be autistic.
So there is no easy answer to this question. I would suggest that you
access research in this area on the internet. But most importantly discuss
it with your husband. I am not sure whether speaking with a genetic
counselor would be of any help, if there are such people, because the
genetics of autism are still so unknown. As mentioned, though there
are many families who choose
to have additional children and while it is of course a
very difficult decision, no one can make it except for
you and your husband.
Q. My son is three and half years old
and has been diagnosed with ASD (Moderate). We are at present residing
in Singapore. We have been taking him for speech and occupational therapy
since March 2003.
He also receives modulated music therapy for sound sensitivity. This
is basically based on Mozart and western classical music.
We are planning to visit India, Chennai and Bangalore, next month and
would be staying there for some months. We would like to continue with
his therapies in India.
Is there any kind of music therapy available in India with classical
music - Carnatic or Hindustani - as my son loves carnatic music very
much. Ever since my son was diagnosed with autism we have been getting
a lot of information and details regarding various kinds of treatments
and therapies. What kind of treatment would be best in this case, to
integrate my son into the mainstream?
A. It is good to learn that you have
found good speech and occupational therapy services for your son. He
must of course be receiving structured teaching along with. Early and
appropriate intervention can lead to quite significant progress. During
your visit to India you will find that there are a number of good services
for children with autism in Bangalore as well as Chennai.
I am not sure what modulated music therapy is, that you mention you
are using for your son's sound sensitivity. For sound sensitivity you
also use what are known as EASe CDs. EASe CDs are a set of four CDs.
They can be played at home on a good CD player, they do not require
any specialized training, and help children deal with sound sensitivities.
They are a form of what is commonly known as Auditory Integration Therapy
(AIT), and do the same job as and at a fraction of the cost of the more
expensive AIT that are given by AIT practitioners.
As for Carnatic music, there can be no dearth of facilities in either
Chennai or Bangalore. Music per se is therapeutic for most children
including children with autism. Most of them love music, can spend hours
listening to music, and appear calmer when doing so.
As you rightly observe there is now a flood of information on therapies
that benefit children with autism. Included in this are yoga, reiki,
reflexology and acupressure. All of these can be beneficial to all people.
But none of them are proven to be especially suited to children with
autism. So while it is okay to give these therapies to children with
autism, articulately when they seem to enjoy them, they must not be
at the cost of well established methodologies which use structure and
an understanding of autism and are based on behvioural principles.
Q. I am a mother of an autistic child
who is exactly four years old. He was diagnosed last year in June. But
after coming to Bahrain a lady who is working for an organisation carried
out a check on the CARS with him. She says that according to the CARS
he scores non autistic but has behaviour problems which can be dealt
with and sorted out. My son has some meaningful words.
A. Your situation - of receiving mixed
information about diagnosis - is a very common one in many places, especially
with younger children. It is important to educate yourself on the most
common behaviours and characteristics of autism so that you can monitor
your son's behaviour and come to some decision yourself as to whether
you feel he meets the criteria. Professionals, of course, can be extremely
useful in providing an objective opinion, but it depends on their experience
and expertise, whether they observed you son on a 'typical' day, whether
they have a sophisticated understanding of autism, etc.
It is preferable to not rely on the CARS as the only indicator of diagnosis,
though it should not be ignored, either. Because your son is younger,
it may be somewhat less reliable. I would suggest that you learn as
much as possible so that you are in a better position to understand
his behaviour and know how to work with it, whether he is autistic or
not. You could also try to seek out a professional in Bahrain whom you
feel has a lot of experience and does not rely on a questionnaire such
as the CARS. The only contact information we have available for someone
in Bahrain is the Bahrain Autistic Society firstname.lastname@example.org. I am
sure you have already spent some time looking, but some sources on the
internet you could learn more about autism are the:
National Autistic Society: http://www.nas.org.uk and
Autism Society of America: http://www.autism-society.org. There is also
information on our site that you may find helpful http://www.autism-india.org
Q. I have a query about my daughters
For the past few months she gets excited and turns aggressive when she
goes to play with other children.
At times she shouts and beats other children. We have written a social
story on her playing quietly in the park. She likes to listen to the
story but does not stop beating her peers in the park I know these are
attention gaining behaviours but how do I control them. Please advice.
A. Perhaps you could write us about what
happens before a behaviour takes place. What happens after? Since you
feel the behaviours are attention getting, you want to look at the consequences
to you daughter and see if you can change them. Write and tell us: Who
is there with her. In what situation does she hit? What exactly was
happening before the behaviour? What do the children do when she exhibits
this behaviour? What do the adults do or say to her. This will help
us to answer your query better.
We regret not carrying our letters column in this issue due to lack
Our apologies to those who wrote in to share their views.
There was excitement in the house. Everyone was awaiting the arrival
of my second child. Rohit, my elder son, 5yrs old at that time was the
most thrilled. He had already decided on a name - Sachu. On 20 September
1993 I gave birth to a beautiful baby boy and we called him Sachu. When
Sachu was six months old we flew to Muscat to join my husband. Sachu
was the perfect child: a very cheerful baby, he threw no tantrums. He
crawled, stood up and walked at the right time. His milestones were
all normal. But something was wrong. Two years passed by but not a word
came from him. All our friends told us that some children speak late.
That reasoning consoled us at that juncture. Sachu was cute, chubby
and with big round eyes. Nobody found anything amiss in him. But during
that time he started becoming aloof. He could sit for hours together
playing with a toy or even just an empty Pepsi can.
Sachu was sensitive to certain sounds, was attached to objects rather
than people. He was terrified of sitting on the toilet seat. By now
quite hyperactive, he had self stimulatory habits like hand flapping,
and worst of all he was still not toilet trained. But he had a fantastic
By then we were panicky. We came back to India to consult the doctors
here. Our journey consulting doctor
after doctor ended at the All India Institute of Speech and Hearing,
Mysore where Sachu was diagnosed Autistic and we were given a home based
training schedule. After the initial shock and disbelief, we got a hold
on our emotions because we had another child who needed our attention.
We received a lot of support from people though some blamed Sachu's
behaviours on our parenting.
Back home with the help of Raksha, a special school in Cochin, Sachu
achieved many goals. Elizabeth Philip the Psychologist and Jayadevi
his special teacher gave their unconditional support, love and encouragement.
Sachu started responding to us, made eye contact and also started interacting
with his brother and cousins. In the meantime, Sachu attended a playschool
and completed his preschool, LKG and UKG. Simultaneously, his home based
training schedule continued. He learnt skills like brushing, bathing,
dressing etc. Toilet training took almost a year and that was one major
achievement. His speech started picking up - from small sounds to words
and finally to sentences and vocalising his needs.
We heard of Dr Subramaniam a homeopathic doctor in Changanacherry who
treats differently abled children. Since then Sachu has been under his
treatment for all his ailments and we found considerable improvement.
Then started our search for the next school to continue his education.
We were advised to put him in a regular school where he would be able
to interact and socialize with children of his age and adults. We were
able to secure admission for him in a wonderful school - The Choice
School where he was accepted and was showered with so much of love and
affection from the teachers, students and the support staff. Being uncertain
of his new surroundings, he got a bit apprehensive and anxious, which
made him a little aggressive. He would pinch the teachers who tried
to make conversation with him. But he never ever harmed any child. Since
he didn't take the initiative to talk to his classmates, they would
come out of their way to talk to him and included him in everything.
After the initial hiccups, Sachu settled in quite well. He got used
to the teachers and the hustle and bustle of the school atmosphere.
Now he is able to read, write and speak. He has a good memory. He is
fascinated by computers, vehicles and the people who drive them. He
loves music and musical instruments. He is still sensitive to certain
sounds and certain musical notes especially high pitched notes. Sachu
is in Std 3 now. For him, his school is a home away from his real home.
The one person who is a major influence and who played the key role
in Sachu's progress is his brother Rohit. Initially, he was very hurt,
troubled and disappointed that his brother couldn't speak. He missed
all the fun that brothers have - fights, games and the usual boyish
pranks. It was almost as if his world had come crumbling down. He cried
secretly and would keep small notes under his pillow to Jesus and the
tooth fairy- asking them to make his brother speak. He was too little
to hear a lecture on Autism, so we had to explain in the simplest way.
We told him that Sachu was very special to God and he wanted a nice
loving brother to look after him and that was why God gave him to us.
He wants us to give him lots and lots of love and care so that one day
he would say "Thank you, Achacha". God has been great. Sachu
is blessed with such a wonderful brother. There is good rapport between
them and Sachu adores his big brother. They talk, play games, sing and
go for walks together. Rohit now understands what Autism is and fully
accepts his brother's condition. He is in Std 10 now. With the help
of Navjyothi Centre, Kakkanad, we have formed a parent group named Anugraha
Society for Autism. The dedicated and able team consisting of Dr. Sitalakshmi,
Dr. George, Fanny Palathinkal and the Sisters of Navjyothi have arranged
for parents and professionals to attend training programmes which have
helped us to understand our child better.
We know that this is the just the beginning. We have a long way to
go with our little Sachu. As we tread this path, with a different and
special child - we know God is with us and he has a special plan for
him. We thank God for Sachu - who has brought out the best in each one
of us. We have been blessed with family and friends and a lot of wonderful
people who have accepted Sachu and have helped us to find information
on Autism and have supported us in every step of our journey.
Planning and Executing an Educational Curriculum with a Focus on
Communication and Behaviours
Reader in Autism Studies at
The University of Birmingham
6 and 7 December 2003,
India International Centre, New Delhi
For information call
Annie at: 29256469 29256470
or Email: email@example.com
LIBRARIAN REQUIRED AT AFA
AFA is seeking a volunteer to work in
the library for 2-3 hours a day
approximately three days a week.
The librarians duties include:
- running the reading room
- issuing books
- organising library memberships
- ordering and cataloguing
new books and publications
- maintaining press cutting files.
If you are interested in this position
please contact Merry Barua at:
Action For Autism
T 370 F Chiragh Dilli Gaon, 3rd Floor,
New Delhi - 110017
Tel: 29256469, 29256470
Innovative Communication Programming
A Full-day Workshop by Dolly Bhargava SLP with Ylana Bloom
INDIA INTERNATIONAL CENTRE, NEW DELHI
December 28, 2003, 6.15 pm
Dolly Bhargava is a speech language pathologist and an augmentative
communication consultant working in Sydney Australia. She has worked
with children and adults with intellectual and/or multiple disabilities
in a variety of settings, including schools, home, group home, day care
centre and day programs. Dolly Bhargava has co-authored a number of
books and teaches online courses. She has presented seminars nationally
o Introduction to AAC
o Assessment of Intentional and Symbolic Communicators
o Using Visual Connectors and Question Maps to determine the types of
communication systems that would be needed for any given activity, identify
the vocabulary that is needed to be included in the communication systems,
and a map for the communication partner to know how and when to use
the communicative systems to scaffold the individual's receptive and
o Using commercially available books to develop literacy skills in children
with communication difficulties. Creating your own personalized material
to develop literacy skills in older children and adults with communication
o Using positive behavior support to minimize challenging behaviour,
promote environmental management and skill building
- Rs. 300/- per parent attendee (Rs. 250/- for members)
- Rs. 550/- per parent couple (Rs. 450/- for members)
- Rs. 400/- per non-parent attendee (Rs. 300/- for members)
- Rs. 350/- for each attendee from an organisation that has taken membership
if more than one person attends
ON THE SPOT REGISTRATION
- Parent Rs. 400/ and Non-Parent Rs. 450/
We regret that cancellations for this workshop will not be refunded.
Please fill in the form below and mail with a SASE to:
Action For Autism, T370F Chirag Dilli Gaon,
New Delhi 110017,
Or download a form from our website at:
Advanced Training Programme to Train Resource Persons
by Steve Ward MA CABA and Teresa Grimes MS BCBA
o Initiated by and in partnership with West Bengal Autism Society
February 27, 28 &29 2004, New Delhi
Steve Ward and Teresa Grimes have trained under Vincent J Carbone and
worked under researchers Drs Mark Sundberg and Jim Partington (authors
of the ABLLS and Teaching Language to Children with Autism and Other
Developmental Disabilities) and have many years experience working in
the field of behavior analysis specifically focusing on children with
Those working with children with autism are aware of the difficulties
in teaching them to attend and follow instructions and enjoy the process
of learning. It is therefore important that children learn that learning
is fun and that communication is powerful. Verbal Behaviour is empirically
verified and one of the latest and most effective methods used in teaching
children with Autism. Teaching takes place in the child's natural environment
making it easier for the child to apply his learnt skills in everyday
Participants will learn teaching strategies based on the science of
behaviour analysis. Participants will learn to think and behave as behaviour
analysts and understand how to increase desired behaviours, decrease
undesired behaviours, and teach new skills.
The workshop is planned for parents, special needs professionals, speech
pathologists, psychologists, and anyone working with children with autism.
The Workshop will be limited to 40 participants only. Seats available
strictly on a first come first served basis.
Topics will include:
o Assessment (ABLLS)
o Framing an IEP
o Compliance Training
o Teaching Strategies
o Teaching Language Skills
o Natural Environment Training (NET)
o Advanced Language Skills.
Registration before 15 January 2004:
o AFA Members: Rs 3,500/-
o Non Members: Rs 4,000/-
Registration after 15 January 2004:
o AFA Members: Rs 4,000/-
o Non Members: Rs 4,500/-
Accommodation: Rooms with breakfast from noon of
26 February to noon of 29 February 2004
Childcare: Childcare will be available only to those participants who
register in advance. Childcare will not be available to
For information on registration, etc fill in the form below or download
after 20 December, 2003 from the AFA website:
NOTE: Participants will receive a certificate of participation on completion
Activities planned in the coming year by:
Forum For Autism, Mumbai
o Walk for Autism. Volunteers please register
o Talk on Financial Planning-Taxation, Insurance Policies, Getting Certificate
for Qualification under Income Tax, Investment avenues for the future
of the child by a parent Mr S Ranganathan at Shishuvihar Dadar
o Picnic to Alibaug:
Volunteers please register for 25th and 26th January, 2004
o Siblings workshop (follow-up) by:
Ms. Sunita Kulkarni at Shishuvihar, Dadar
o What options do we have?
Discussion with Mr. Vasant Thakkar of Savali (Shelter for CP children)
on various models of residential care
for adult autistics.