Is Autism on the Rise?
The Telegraph
July 11, 2004
One in 500 Indian infants has it. Thats 20,000 new cases
every year. An alarming increase, or stark figures brought to light
by better diagnosis and heightened awareness? G.S. Mudur finds out
In three months, Purnima Jain will have to start turning parents away.
Each month, typically 30 to 40 parents call at the School of Hope,
New Delhi, that provides special education to children with autism,
a disorder marked by unusual behaviour and lack of communication skills.
We want to maintain a teacher-student ratio of 1:3 and were
going to run out of space very soon, says Jain, principal at
the school which moved into a new building just 10 months ago. I
feel really bad for the parents. There just arent enough schools
for autistic children.
Her plight stems from a steep rise in the diagnosis of autism across
India in recent years. The increase in autism were witnessing
cannot be explained by better detection and awareness alone,
says Professor M.K.C. Nair, director of the Child Development Centre
at the Medical College, Trivandrum, and president of the Indian Academy
of Paediatrics. A decade ago, says Nair, his clinic would diagnose
autism in a single child once a month. Now, it typically diagnoses
autism in perhaps 10 to 20 children each month.
Unlike in the US and some European countries, there are no studies
in India that document the rise in autism. But it is possible
that what were seeing in India reflects a global trend,
Dr Shobha Srinath, head of child psychiatry at the National Institute
of Mental Health and Neurosciences (NIMHANS) told The Telegraph. In
recent years, several studies in the US and Europe have shown an unexplained
rise in the diagnosis of autism. In the US, California researchers
have recorded a three-fold increase in autism over the past decade.
Doctors concede that part of the observed rise in autism is also
the result of greater awareness among the public and better diagnostic
strategies. That may have been brought about in large part by intense
lobbying by parents-driven groups trying to sensitise the public and
the government to recognise autism as a problem.
There has been a sharp increase in awareness about autism,
says Srinath at NIMHANS. But sometimes this leads to inaccurate presumptions.
When Rainman first played on Indian screens, hardly anybody in India
knew much about autism. But when Koi... Mil Gaya was released, everybody
thought and mistakenly that Rohit, the character
played by lead actor Hrithik Roshan, was autistic. The widespread
speculation even prompted Roshan to deny that Rohit was autistic.
The presumed incidence of autism, one in 500 newborns, in India translates
into more than 20,000 new cases of autism each year. It isnt
the staggering numbers alone that is worrying doctors and parents.
The infrastructure to deliver special education for autistic
children is woefully inadequate, says Merry Barua, founder,
director of Action For Autism (AFA), a parents-driven group based
in New Delhi involved in education, training and campaigning for the
rights of autistic children and adults.
Experts estimate that there are probably just 10 schools in India
that provide special education exclusively to autistic children. For
a long time, autism just wasnt on the government radar screen,
says Barua. For instance, the Persons with Disabilities Act passed
in 1995 did not cover autism and parents have found it excruciatingly
difficult to get disability certificates.
Disability in India has traditionally been focused on physical disabilities.
It is easy for most people to empathise with someone who is
blind or who lacks limbs. Its hard to understand a developmental
disorder autism, in particular, because of the highly uneven
skills in autistic people, says Barua. An autistic child may
be able to write excellent poetry, but wont be able to talk.
Another child may be able to do a three-digit multiplication in the
head, but wont be able to hold a pencil. Such variable patterns
make it hard to evaluate and quantify autism something required
by law to be labelled as a disability. A government panel six years
ago recommended changes to the Disabilities Act, but the law hasnt
changed yet. Doctors appear to have a hard time recognising
this as a disability, says one parent who, after several frustrating
weeks at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, accepted
a certificate that certified his autistic son as mental disabled.
Early intervention can be crucial in autism, says Srinath
at NIMHANS. Vital wiring in the human brain occurs in
the first three years of life. Connections form between brain cells
and some of this wiring influences the ability for social behaviour
and communication skills. Early intervention through the form
of special education and behaviour therapy can alter the course of
this disorder and can help some children go to regular schools and
even get into mainstream life, says Srinath. But early intervention
hinges on rapid diagnosis.
Learning the Signs
There is no known cure for autism. Doctors say the most effective
treatment so far is structured teaching aimed at early education to
impart new skills that will enable the child to talk, interact, play
and learn.
Typical symptoms of autism
Difficulty in expressing needs or wants verbally or non-verbally.
Repeating words or phrases rather than responding to questions.
Making repeated movements such as rocking or hand flapping.
Displaying a strong preference to routine, disliking any change
in a daily routine.
Displaying emotions, pleasure or distress, for no apparent
reason.
Not responding to questions by appearing not to hear.
Displaying no interest in playing with children of the same
age.
Indrani Basu in Calcutta still cant forget the agonising decade
when she visited the best paediatricians and psychiatrists in town
trying to find out why her four-year old son was different from other
children. She had noticed that he had difficulty following instructions
in class, and he didnt appear to play enough. One doctor censured
her for working, another blamed her for pampering him, others labelled
him as mentally retarded or hyperactive. One psychiatrist said he
had childhood schizophrenia and prescribed medication.
It was only when, against the advice of her Calcutta psychiatrist,
Basu took her son to NIMHANS, Bangalore, in 1998 that he was diagnosed,
at age 14, as having autism. It turned out to be a relatively mild
version of autism, something that might have been mitigated with early
intervention. But in the absence of diagnosis for 10 years, no early
intervention was possible. Maybe it was because of their ignorance
or lack of information, but they messed up our lives, says Basu.
Rapid diagnosis would require higher levels of alertness among parents
as well as doctors. A University of California, Los Angeles, study
on the diagnosis of autism in India published earlier this year indicates
that parents in India notice something different about their child
about six to 10 months later than has been found for parents in the
US.
Norms about child development are culturally shaped and impact
on when a symptom may be recognised as problematic, UCLA psychologist
Tamara Daley said in her study published in Social Science and
Medicine. As a psychologist interviewed points out, a child that
keeps quiet without emotions is sometimes interpreted as a good
child.
A survey conducted by the AFA in the late 1990s among 1000 paediatricians
across India revealed prevailing misconceptions. Half of the paediatricians
wrongly believed that autism is more common among high socio-economic
families, that emotional factors play a role, that it is caused by
cold and rejecting parents a decades-old theory that was junked
by professionals worldwide.
But things appear to be finally changing, though at a pace slower
than desired. Last weeks Union budget extended certain tax exemptions
to people with autism. Delhi chief minister Sheila Dixit laid the
foundation stone for a National Centre for Autism in New Delhi, an
AFA project that will seek to extend education to a larger number
of autistic children as well as train more teachers.
The goal is to work towards helping them integrate into the
community, says Barua. At the foundation stone-laying function
on Friday, Basus son, now 21, sang a poem: So what the hell
I bite my hands/ How I can be strange in a strange mans land/
I just dont get your jokes/ Mindblind. Sometimes the colours
can hurt/ Im not really certain why I flap the lights/ But its
me youre with tonight/ Mindblind.
It could be in the genes
Head injury, emotional trauma, refrigerator moms, and
a common childhood vaccine have been erroneously blamed at various
times, but the cause of autism remains elusive, a subject of intense
medical speculation and research. No one knows the cause,
asserts Dr Shobha Srinath, head of child psychiatry at NIMHANS.
However, recent medical studies point to a genetic component of autism
people with autism appear to have an inborn genetic predisposition
to autism. (Four out of five autistic children are boys.) Most scientists
now believe that autism is the outcome of the interaction of genes
and environmental offenders.
The right question to ask is what environmental factors
chemical or physical insults may be contributing to autism
in children who are genetically susceptible to it, Dr Isaac
Pessah, a scientist at the University of California, Davis, told The
Telegraph. A possible answer may be the interaction of several
genes and several environmental factors.
There is evidence that many genes are involved in autism and a class
of related disorders clubbed as autism spectrum disorders. Pessah
is among researchers now scrambling to pinpoint environmental
offenders by investigating the connection between genes and
environmental factors.
With colleagues at the UC Davis School of Medicine, Pessah is selecting
autistic children and non-autistic children and examining their exposure
to a broad array of factors industrial chemicals, consumer
products, illness of the mother during pregnancy and of the baby after
birth, drugs, vaccines, as well as diet.
The scientists will also seek out correlations between possible exposure
to such factors and the bodys biochemistry. While environmental
factors have not been ruled out, the president of Indias paediatric
community Dr M.K.C. Nair has asked doctors to keep in mind a possible
association between prolonged exposure to TV in children below three
years of age, absence of siblings to play with, and poor parental
commu-nication skills.
Nair emphasises that these are not causes of autism, but could make
things worse for children with inborn genetic predisposition.
The concept of cold parents, sometimes dubbed as refrigerator
moms has long been discounted as a causative factor for autism.
But it makes sense to suggest that such environmental factors
may play a role in contributing to the severity of the disease in
children who are autistic, says Pessah. There is good
scientific evidence that very early behavioural intervention can mitigate
some of the social and communication problems in some autistic children.
Walk to raise funds for
autism centre
March 14, 2004
Express News Service
New Delhi, March 14: A five-km walk was organised this morning to
raise funds to build a centre to conduct research on autism and rehabilitate
children suffering from the disorder.
Kathak dancer Shovana Narayan, a long-time supporter of Action for
Autism, an NGO that has been trying to raise awareness on the developmental
disability for over a decade, was part of the event.
Narayan strode along with the group even as a tiny girl helped hold
up a banner that loudly proclaimed Sponsored Walk for Autism-2004.
I gave my students a lot of work to do and practice and
I told them that theyd better get it done before I returned
from the walk. I try and be here for every function that Action for
Autism organises, said Narayan.
As the group strode along, curious onlookers stopped to stare and
policemen wondered what this procession was all about.
The second annual walk began from the grounds of Sanskriti School
in Chanakyapuri at around 10.30 am and went through the diplomatic
enclave in Chanakyapuri.
Merry Barua, Director, Action for Autism, said: A walk
is a fun way to raise funds. Many families joined us and many more
were eager to come.
The money will go for the construction of the national centre for
advocacy, research, rehabilitation and training. Barua said that currently
the organisation operated from a small, rented building in Chirag
Delhi Gaon. She added that this place had become inadequate given
the demand for its services.
It is really difficult to raise funds for autism, because
the children who suffer from this disorder appear to be normal,
said Barua.
The organisation is planning to lay the centres foundation
stone in Jasola, behind Apollo Hospital, within the next month.
This school will be for autistic kids
Times News Network
February 6, 2004
Mridula Chunduri
HYDERABAD : Parents of six children suffering from autism, a developmental
disorder, have taken up the task of starting a first-of-itskind school
in the state designed especially for autistic children.
Autism is a lifelong developmental disorder that occurs during the
first three years of life, where the child fails to develop communication
and social skills.
"Our children are neither mentally retarded nor are they normal.
So they do not fit into regular schools or special schools,"
said K Laxmi, mother of six-year-old Harsha, an autistic child. "They
need a school where teachers can understand their disability and educate
them based on their individual capabilities," she said.
There are no schools that cater specifically to autistic children,
since they are good at something. While some grasp languages easily,
others are good at mathematics.
"We need to recognise their ability and tap it," Laxmi
said. All the children either go to regular schools or special schools
that only cater to the mentally handicapped, where the autistic children
are "treated as retarded and are only taken care of and not educated."
"Autism is a very individual-specific disorder. Each child has
different capabilities and they need individual attention that no
school can provide," said another parent child, K Subbalakshmi.
To overcome this problem, these parents have decided to start a school
on their own, where they themselves will interact with the children
on a one-to-one basis and help them develop their skills.
The six parents have pooled in funds and opened a classroom where
they conduct group activities for their children. "Our aim is
to provide a solid foundation for our children in academic education,"
said another parent Lata George. "We parents can share our experience
and understand the various aspects of the disability. It will also
help the child interact with strangers and his/her social mingling
will improve," she said.
The school will become a fullfledged one only in the next academic
year, by when these parents are planning to get trained by a Bangalore-based
NGO that cares for autistic patients.
"We are hoping to collect enough funds by June 2004 to start
the school for our children," Subbalakshmi said. Presently, these
parents can be contacted at aaphyd@ yahoo.co.in.
"Autism was never considered a separate disorder, but all autistic
children were treated as retarded children. It is only in the past
two years that people are discovering that autism is a disorder,"
said Astha Kumari, an autism cell trainer at the National Institute
for the Mentally Handicapped, Bowenpally, the only institute in the
city that has a separate wing for autistic children. "A school
such as the one proposed will be of great value," she said. What
is autism?
Autism is a complex neurological disorder that impairs abilities
to communicate, socialise, respond to emotion or express it. How is
it diagnosed?
Autism can be diagnosed during the toddler or pre-school years, although
some children are diagnosed at older ages. Lack of appropriate social
development could be indications of autism.
Boys are three-to-four times more likely to have autism than girls.
Autism occurs in all racial, ethnic, and social groups
Autism appeal to South Asian political
leaders
Pakistan News Wire
January 6, 2004
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan: Ivan and Charika Corea, parents and carers of
an autistic child and founders of the Autism Awareness Campaign, have
appealed to SAARC (South Asian Association for Regional Co-operation)
leaders currently meeting in Islamabad to take urgent action on autism.
Autism is on the rise in India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka,
Nepal, Bhutan and the Maldives - the countries within the SAARC region.
Ivan and Charika Corea initiated 2002 as Autism Awareness Year in
the United Kingdom. Their campaign is now the largest ever movement
for autism in the UK and has the support of the British Prime Minister,
Tony Blair, and parliamentarians of all parties in the Houses of Commons
and Lords in London.
"We need urgent action by the heads of state and national governments
in the SAARC region to look into the rise in autism and find common
ways and strategies in tackling the whole issue of autism," said
Ivan, including joint educational and health strategies and the sharing
of good practice from SAARC countries.
"We recommend the setting up of a SAARC Autism Committee comprising
of officials from the SAARC countries to discuss ways forward,"
said Ivan. "We urge SAARC countries to launch a data collection
initiative in their respective countries and provide public services
for people with autism and Asperger's syndrome. We recommend a common
strategy in relation to the training of special educational needs
teachers and specialist speech therapists in the SAARC region."
He appealed to political leaders to "reach out to the autistic
community in the SAARC region. Autism is a time-bomb waiting to happen.
If there is a rise in numbers of people with autism in South Asia,
are SAARC countries in a position to provide public services for these
people who have a very specific disability? Have staff been trained?
What about the dissemination of information on autism and Asperger's
syndrome in the major languages of the SAARC region?
"There are only a handful of organisations in the voluntary
sector who are in a position to help the autistic community. National
governments must provide support services for all people with disabilities.
We need new ways of thinking where disabilities in the SAARC region
are concerned."
`Autism still remains an underdiagnosed
disorder'
The Hindu
Shonali Muthalaly
CHENNAI DEC. 16. 2003
The World Health Organisation states that one in every 500 persons
suffers from autism, meaning an estimated two million Indians battle
the disorder everyday. In spite of the vast numbers involved, the
condition is often wrongly diagnosed. Either doctors fail to identify
the problem in time or parents ignore vital clues, assuming that their
child will eventually grow into a healthy adult without any help.
Autism affects the normal development of brain with regard to social
interaction and communication. While all autistics have a social deficit,
which means they are unable to relate to other people, about 50 per
cent do not develop speech.
Unfortunately, the disorder is frequently overlooked, misunderstood
and wrongly categorised in India, according to Gita Srikant and Hemamalini
Jairam, who run `We CAN' (We Challenge Autism Now), a centre that
works with autistic children here.
"Ten or twelve years ago, people believed there was no autism
in India, because paediatricians were wrongly diagnosing the disease.
Parents were told that their children were mentally retarded, or that
they had `childhood schizophrenia', a condition that does not even
exist," says Ms. Hemamalini. Today, not much has changed. While
more information is available for parents on the Internet, most of
them are still misguided by healthcare professionals, according to
We CAN. At least 70 per cent of the autistics come to them sedated
on an array of drugs, although autism needs no medication.
Late diagnosis is another problem. Ideally, an autistic child should
be put on an `early intervention programme' by the time he or she
is 18 months old. In reality, autistics are brought to special schools
only when they are much older, which makes teaching considerably more
difficult. We CAN, for instance, meets about two new autistics a week,
and a good number of them are in their teens. As some autistics are
very intelligent, they can excel in areas such as academics and computer
science, where not much social interaction is required, provided they
are properly trained. In fact, one per cent of all autistics are `savants,'
which means they are exceptionally gifted in one area, for example
in mathematics.
We CAN, one of the few centres in the country that deals specifically
with autism, has just about 12 children. It is unable to admit more,
because each child needs a lot of individual attention.
"We do not want to grow beyond fifteen children, and there's
already a waiting list," says Ms. Gita, adding, "We are
trying to encourage people to open similar schools in different parts
of the city. If you live in Vadapalani, you cannot bring an autistic
child all the way to our centre in Besant Nagar, here."
The Rehabilitation Council of India acknowledged the need for an
autism-specific training for teachers only last year. At the moment
there are just a handful of established institutes for treating autistics.
As diagnosis improves and awareness spreads, a demand for schools
for autistics is expected to rise.
Autism is still not included in the country's Disability list. "Till
two years ago, the Government was not even convinced it existed,"
says Ms Hemamalini. "Even today, if you want train travel concession,
you have to misrepresent your child as mentally-challenged."
Awareness month
We CAN is organising an `Open House' to observe an awareness month
on December 20 and 21 to discuss autism and the teaching methods used.
On January 7 and 8, it will hold a workshop on verbal behaviour,
which will be conducted by Duncan Fennemore, a consultant on behavioural
interventional programmes for children in the United Kingdom, Europe
and the Middle East. For more details, We CAN may be contacted at
24461013.
Telltale signs
Lack of eye contact
Apparent lack of response when called
Speech delay
Difficulty in peer group interaction
Difficulty in communication - verbal and non-verbal
Inconsistent responses to situations
© Copyright 2000 - 2003 The Hindu
Diploma course for autistic children
Times News Network
November 1, 2003
NEW DELHI: In the first step of its kind, the Rehabilitation Council
of India (RCI) has launched a year-long diploma course in autism spectrum
disorders to address the educational requirements of children with
autism.
It has been a long-pending demand and this course, a diploma in special
education, is a pre-service teachers training programme. The qualification
for enrolment is Class XII or its equivalent.
Two institutes selected to run the course are Delhi-based Action
for Autism and School of Hope, Tamanna. The two other centres are
the Spastics Society of Karnataka and Mind's College of Educational
Research in Mumbai.
The RCI, in charge of the regulating training policies in this field,
says that given the benefits of intensive early intervention in preventing
the ill-effects of autism, the course aims to mainstream children
with autism by creating professionals who will use structured strategies
and give intensive training to them. Approved by the RCI on a pilot
basis, the course curriculum has been developed with the help of special
educators, policy makers and parents
Talking Autism
Times of India
September 30, 2003
Rita Jordan is a Reader in Autism Studies at the University of
Birmingham, UK. She has worked as a teacher and research officer in
the field of special needs, concentrating for the last 23 years on
individuals with autism a neurological spectrum disorder which
generally manifests itself first in children between the ages of 18
and 24 months. The initial symptoms include the child's lack of response
to his or her name being called and other language and communication
impairments. In New Delhi recently for an international workshop,
she spoke to Madhusudan Srinivas :
Where are we in the field of autism today, both internationally and
here in India?
India has begun to move forward in terms of the facilities available.
East or West, the myths about autism are beginning to disappear. It
is being realised that autism can hit any kind of family. In the past,
autism was "rare". Not so, any more. It is now acknowledged
that autism affects a wider group of people than was thought to be
the case earlier.
Why has this happened?
Instead of autism, we have begun to talk of ASD, or autism spectrum
disorder. In the sense that instead of being a specified disorder,
identifiable by a specific set of 'symptoms', there is now a wide-ranging
list of indicative signals, as it were, which come to be categorised
as au-tism. This acknow-ledgement that it is a spectrum disorder has
led to an increase in the number of cases being diagnosed. Recent
research in the US and the UK suggests that about one person in 160
all over the world is autistic. Relative to India's population, that
could mean a huge number of autistic people. Even in the UK, we are
not equipped to cater to that kind of need, in terms of initial diagnosis
and counselling, special aids for specialised learning and teaching,
and support for the integration of adult autistic individuals into
society.
Among all these challenges, which is the most important?
Early intervention makes a vital difference. The sooner you have
a diagnosis and the sooner parents can prepare to face up to it, the
better off everyone is. Most people with autism require some form
of social support as adults. While in the West this support has come
from setting up homes (some of which, depending on their level of
ability, are run by autistic individuals themselves), India has a
different social structure, namely, a joint family network
although it is now slowly crumbling. Families which have children
or other individuals with autism too must be supported. Not everyone
can provide lifelong support to the individual with autism. It must
also be remembered that some autistic indivi- duals require complete
and life-long support. While some need help even with basic personal
needs, others can be productive and contribute meaningfully to society.
What is the argument in favour of social support?
It is a matter of responsibility as well as in the best interests
of society to invest wisely and well in the welfare of individuals
with autism, including their families and caregivers, and the institutions
which help in all this. An overall cost-benefit in this sector works
out to a plus only when you invest all around right from the beginning
, i.e. diagnosis, and early intervention, rather than provide homes
for adults with autism on the lines of old age homes. You have to
factor in the effects of what might happen if we don't invest now.
If there is no proper education and support, the cost to society will
be huge in terms of the burden on the mental healthcare system, the
breakdown of a large number of families (the consequences of which
will anyway impact on society, in terms of money as well as morale).
What's more, such individuals, if not cared for and nurtured, may
often end up being violent. Many stalkers could be on the autistic
spectrum. They don't mean harm but they end up doing harm. The cost
of incarceration is tremendous especially in comparison to
the cost of early diagnosis, intervention and support system. The
effects of autism could range from extreme beha-viour to what is perceived
as routine bullying in the school toilet. There has been an actual
instance of an autistic boy who was unable to take it and pulled out
a knife in school toilet since the female 'shadow' couldn't accompany
him into the boys' toilet. Nobody knew how he got the knife. The other
risk is that autistic individuals are so guileless that they can get
'set up'. They also find it very hard to speak a lie.
Can you comment on the different methods on offer for teaching children
with autism?
After going up a lot of blind alleys, the Autistic Society in the
UK concluded that parents are the key, and that there is no single
size that fits all experience alone can provide the answers.
What about the question of mainstreaming versus segregation?
Integration definitely is desirable. We shouldn't build isolated
places where parents or caregivers also become isolated. The ideal
setting for teaching children would be a resource base within a mainstream
school, as part of the school. In India, the immediate need is for
some centres of excellence ironically, special schools should
be working frenetically at making themselves redundant!
Special autistic section to come up at
GIMRC
Times News Network
September 27, 2003
CHANDIGARH: The Government Institute for Mentally Retarded Children
(GIMRC) is likely to have a separate section for children battling
autism.
The decision to start a separate autistic section was taken after
a detailed discussion between parents of autistic children and doctors
from the psychiatry department of Government Medical College and Hospital
(GMCH) held on Saturday. The meeting was attended by 20 families with
autistic children.
GIMRC joint director Prof B S Chavan said that autism has not been
included in the Persons with Disability Act, 1995, as one of the disabilities
as a result of which parents are finding it difficult to obtain a
disability certificate and are denied various concessions and benefits.
Therefore, after detailed discussions, it was decided that the parents
of autistic children through their association - Parents/Guardian
Society for Welfare of Mentally Challenged Children - would write
to the chief commissioner (disability) to include autism as one of
the disabilities in the Persons with Disability Act.
Moreover, keeping in view the shortage of teaching staff at the GIMRC,
parents have decided to employ a special educator at their own cost.
Interested candidates having requisite training and experience in
the area of autism may contact Prof Chavan on 647760, 621342, 891408.
Tackling
autism
The Hindu
Smitha Sadandan
June 9, 2003
ATTENDING A marriage function with her son, Sanju, is a nightmare
for Sudha Menon, whose husband works abroad. The six-year-old looks
adorable but runs around like a self-propelled buzz-saw making eerie,
high-pitched keening noises, impervious to his mother's commands to
"behave properly". Some onlookers sympathise. Others do
not attempt to hide their disapproval by tutting loudly and declaring
in a barely concealed voice "The child is not normal!"
What the onlookers don't realise is that Sanju is autistic, and for
him, instructions to "be quiet" or "behave properly"
hold little, if any, meaning. The smallest of things, such as going
to a park or shopping, present difficulties to parents of such children.
"People are quick to pass judgements. Society has yet to make
a sincere attempt to understand and accept these children," says
Sudha.
Autism, a developmental disorder, is on the increase for reasons
still unclear. For instance, the number of children diagnosed with
autism and referred to the Institute for Communicative and Cognitive
Neurosciences (ICCONS) centres in the State has more than quadrupled
in the past five years -- from a 100-odd autistic cases in 1998 to
more than 550 cases today.
Autism is known as pervasive developmental disorder (PDO) and is
considered to be a result of neurological problems affecting the brain.
The impairment of social interaction, communication and reciprocity,
repetitive behaviour and abnormal motor behaviour are central to children
on the autistic spectrum, ranging from mild to severe. Autistic disorder
starts in early childhood (becomes apparent between the ages of two
and three) and manifests itself as the child grows older.
Abnormal behaviour such as delayed or no response to stimuli, repetition
of certain words or sounds (known in medical parlance as echolalia),
reversal of pronouns (saying `you' instead of `I') are some of the
many behavioural characteristics of autistic children.
"Instead of playing imaginatively with a toy car, an autistic
child would spin its wheels or just sit in a chair and rock it for
hours on end. This is because they are devoid of cognitive ability,"
explains Dr. Punnen Thomas, paediatrician, ICCONS.
Unlike other developmental disorders, autism does not have a cure
or exact methods of early diagnosis. Though autism remains life long,
children affected by autism can learn and function productively through
a comprehensive training programme and treatment, point out experts.
"The seeming surge in the number of autistic cases and closely
related disorders in the State could be the result of the broadening
of diagnostic criteria, medical advancement and increasing awareness
among parents," says Dr. P. A. Suresh, director, ICCONS. The
ICCONS, which started in 1998, is the only centre in the State that
offers exclusive treatment to autistic children. The institute, now,
has centres at Shornur and Thiruvananthapuram. Each day, a new case
or two is referred to its centres.
"We took our daughter, Ashni, to a number of doctors. They all
convinced us she was fine. We lived with false hope all these years.
Ultimately, it was a scan done under the recommendation of a neurologist
that revealed that Ashni was autistic. This was some six months ago;
we wasted precious time till then," says Yasmin Nawaz, mother
of a three-year-old suffering from autism.
One of the biggest difficulties faced by such parents is obtaining
an accurate diagnosis of the child's mental and physical health at
an early stage. Often, the parents take the child to a paediatrician
only to be reassured that "the child is fine". Dissatisfied,
they take the child to a psychologist only to be told that the child
is a "slow learner". A stopover at a psychiatrist's clinic
may offer the parents a different explanation: "The child has
to be put on medication to control hyperactive behaviour." Eventually,
some neurologist offers the most plausible explanation: "The
child might be autistic".
Not long ago, autism was assumed to be comparatively rare, affecting
as few as five in 10,000 people.
Latest studies, however, suggest that as many as two in 1,000 kids
might be affected with autism, which varies in degrees of severity.
Autism may occur in isolation or with one or more developmental disorders.
Studies have also revealed that boys are more likely to have autism
than girls.
"A possible reason is that a disorder, fragile X-syndrome, associated
with autism, is more common in boys than in girls. And about 40 per
cent of children with fragile X-syndrome are likely to be autistic,"
says Dr. Suresh.
Children ought to be evaluated by a multi-disciplinary team comprising
a neurologist, psychologist, paediatrician, speech therapist, learning
consultants and other professionals who have adequate knowledge of
autism.
"Parental input and development history of a child are important
factors that aid accurate diagnosis," says paediatrician Dr.
Elizabeth Mathew, Sree Uthradom Tirunal (S.U.T.) Hospital. Therapies
and integrated intervention programmes available in the State include
behaviour analysis, occupational therapy, communication therapy, social-skill
development and sensory integration therapy.
"Parents may, initially, find it difficult to accept that their
child is autistic. But a joint effort on the part of therapists as
well as families can go a long way in improving the lives of autistic
children and adults," says Annamma George, speech therapist,
Sree Chitra Tirunal Hospital.
Most parents are unable to comprehend the gravity of the situation
and at times shun the autistic child. This could have an adverse effect
on the therapy sessions, points out Dr. P. S. Mathuranath of Department
of Cognition and Behavioural Neurology, S.C.T. Hospital. "The
problem aggravates when an autistic child has unrealistic parents
who expect the child to conform to the standards of `accepted social
behaviour."
To compound the existing problem is the lack of centres with good
infrastructure and trained staff, unlike in the West. This hinders
their rehabilitation. "Moreover, parents must remember that autistic
children are highly gifted in certain aspects -- they may have a very
good IQ or may be good at mathematical calculations," says Dr.
Mathuranath.
In recent years, there has been talk of the MMR (measles, mumps,
rubella) vaccine, administered to children aged about 15 months, as
being the cause of autism, but this has been disproved. Another misconception
is the notion that autistic children do not register the faces of
loved ones.
"This is not true. At D.C.M.R., we try to bring them back into
society and work on the lines of Merry Barua of Delhi (Action for
Autism). If the child does not point at objects, fails to speak two-word
phrases or shows inability in fine motor coordination, parents ought
to take note of it," says Fr. Thomas Felix who runs the Developmental
Centre for Mentally Retarded (D.C.M.R.).
Their motto for autistic children is "maximum interaction and
minimum isolation". But little has been done on the health front
by the Government to help autistic children. Even the scientists have
not been able to offer any convincing explanation regarding the cause
of autism, so far. Genetic research indicates that some form of autism
or related disorder runs in the family of an autistic person. In the
midst of all the scientific and medical hypotheses being floated,
the parents of autistic children are left to grapple with a bewildering
array of problems affecting their autistic child. Yet, they do not
lose hope.
Says Sherly Chandran, mother of a 16-year-old autistic and a staff
with the ICCONS, "I know my son will not recover from autism,
but I'm glad he has adapted to the therapy sessions so well. He has
improved beyond my expectations and through the training, has begun
to speak almost coherently and even sing too."
© Copyright 2000 - 2003 The Hindu
Born different-- Autism: Early
diagnosis and intervention help
The Week
March 9, 2003
By Rashmi Saksena
Autism was just another word for Meena till six months ago when her
son Siddhartha was diagnosed with the brain disorder. As the three-year-old
sits with eyes downcast, seemingly unaware of the bright red toys
around him at Open Door, the Delhi school for autistic children he
attends, the only comfort for Meena is the knowledge that she is not
alone. Around two million in India are autistic.
Reaching out for help: An autistic child at Open Door in Delhi
Described as neuro development spectrum disorder because symptoms
range from mild learning and social disability to severe impairment
with multiple problems, autism remains a low profile disability. The
word autism was first used by Dr Leo Kanner, a psychiatrist at Johns
Hopkins University, to identify a group of children who were self-absorbed
and had severe social, communication and behavioural problems. The
Government of India recognised autism as a disability in 1999 by establishing
The National Trust for the Welfare of Persons with Autism, Cerebral
Palsy, Mental Retardation and Multiple Disabilities, under the ministry
of social justice and empowerment.
Parents still have to knock at many doors before they get an accurate
answer to what makes their child different. "My son reached his
milestones in time but did not speak till he was two," says Meena.
"Some said he is a late speaker. Our paediatrician did not bother
about it. Only when we mentioned autism did he look at the possibility."
Says Merry Barua, credited with putting autism on India's map by
founding Delhi-based Action For Autism (AFA): "Most autistic
children are not diagnosed." Merry's 22-year-old son Neeraj is
autistic. "I went to leading paediatricians because I felt there
was something wrong with my baby. He did not speak or play and just
walked around in his nursery school. Once I was late by three hours
to pick him up and I was told that he had not once asked for his mother.
But no doctor could diagnose."
When Neeraj was four and a half years old, Merry met a friend who
was trained in the UK as a special educator for children with special
needs. She advised Merry to see a psychologist who worked in Kolkata
and Canada. Neeraj was diagnosed as autistic "but there was little
information about the disorder". To know more, she read books
on the subject. She trained and worked in the US as a teacher for
autistic children, and visited special schools in the UK, Denmark
and the Philippines before setting up a classroom back home for her
son. Another girl with the same disorder joined in.
Merry started AFA, a non-profit organisation, in 1994 and the demand
for services has kept her busy ever since. AFA conducts training workshops
for autistic children and their parents. Her Open Door is India's
only model school for autistic children. AFA networks with six organisations
in India and one in Nepal to train parents and professionals, and
plans to set up a national centre for advocacy research and training
for autism in Delhi.
Shakeela, a teacher from Ladakh, took her 7-year-old daughter Asma
all over India for a diagnosis. Asma does not establish eye contact,
flaps her hands and can barely communicate. A doctor in Chandigarh
directed her to Merry.
If Puja's neurologist uncle had not come visiting she would probably
have not discovered why her son Rishabh at two and a half years did
not speak and respond, though he had passed a hearing test. "My
uncle told me to go to NIMHANS," says Puja. "They gave a
diagnosis in two minutes."
Priya was worried when her 6-year-old son Manish showed a "different
behaviour". When no doctor in Jamshedpur, where they lived, could
diagnose his condition she took him to Delhi.
Life for her has completely changed after the diagnosis, just as
it has for Puja, Shakeela and Meena who moved to Delhi to train their
children at Open Door. "Parents of normal children and teachers
don't understand," says Priya. "Some tell children not to
mix with the odd one. We mix only with each other because we understand
each other's problems."
"Autistic children look normal, so people find it difficult
to accept them as disabled," says Aloka Guha, chairperson of
the Trust, which recently organised a medical seminar in Delhi. "Severe
cases get clubbed with the mentally retarded. We are sensitising people
through our 369 committees across the country."
Though awareness about autism leaves much to be desired there is
a dramatic increase in the number of cases in the last decade. "In
India diagnosis is happening but research is lacking," says Dr
Vrajesh Udani, a paediatric neurologist and epileptologist at P.D.
Hinduja National Hospital in Mumbai, who has been studying 60 autistic
children over six years.
Early detection and intervention can make a lot of difference, as
they did in the case of a 9-year-old autistic girl who ran around
naked. "Within a month of intervention she became socially acceptable
and now goes to a regular school," says Dr Vibha Krishnamurthy,
a paediatric specialist in developmental and behavioural disorders
at Jaslok Hospital, Mumbai. Vibha visits schools to sensitise teachers.
"I know five schools in the city that have children with Asperger
syndrome (a mild type of autism) and high functioning autism."
The next step, she feels, should be a prevalence study. "We could
look at other parameters... a challenge in India as most children
have no records."
Immunisation, diet, television, breakup of the joint family and other
environmental factors are being studied. "But nothing has been
proved," says Vibha. "So we are looking at our population.
Autism is showing up in all strata of society." There is a rising
demand for services. Anything can help just as the hug machine developed
by Dr Temple Grandin who herself is autistic.
Action for Autism: 011-26416469, 26416470. autism@vsnl.com The National
Trust: 011-23217411. nationaltrust@ren02.nic.in www.nationaltrust.org.in
This programme helps kids
DEALL with autism
Express News Service
February 18, 2003
Mumbai, February 18: INITIALLY, Kavita Singh did not find anything
wrong with her son. He had begun walking at a normal age and had also
learnt to mumble a few words.
But after some months, he stopped talking. He wouldnt
make eye-contact, avoid interacting with other children and throw
tantrums frequently. Thats when we realised there was something
missing, Singh recollects. A visit to a paediatrician
when the child was two years and five months old revealed he was autistic.
Though no epidemiological studies have been conducted
in India, detection of cases of autism is on the rise around
one in 250 cases as against an earlier rate of one in 10,000,
says Bangalore-based Dr Pratibha Karanth, former professor of speech
and language pathology at the All India Institute of Speech and Hearing,
Mysore. Earlier, only cases of severe autism would receive
attention. Now, even mild forms are being noticed, Dr
Karanth adds.
Once her son was diagnosed as autistic, Singhs life began revolving
around his speech therapy sessions, sensory integration classes and
play-school. His condition is improving. But it involves
a lot of running around. My family is supportive but it is taxing,
Singh says.
There may be a solution for parents like her. In 2000, Dr Karanth
devised the Communication DEALL programme which aims at providing
integrated intervention to autistic kids below
five years. The programme is currently being implemented in Bangalore
and Mangalore and will begin its Mumbai chapter in March.
DEALL or Developmental Eclectic Approach to Language Learning aims
at providing training to pre-school children through a team of speech-language
pathologists, therapists and pre-school teachers.
The programme offers the necessary therapy and training
under a single roof. The objective is to try and get the child integrated
into regular school, Dr Karanth explains. The duration
of the programme is one year. If we think that the child
needs some more time, we continue the programme for longer,
Nair says, adding that the current success rate of the programme is
approximately 40 per cent.
Singh is considering the programme for her son who is now three.
It will save me the running around. Besides, three hours
of rigorous training from qualified professionals is what attracted
me to it, she says.
Govind Krishnan (name changed) has a two-year-old daughter who is
mildly autistic. He is keen on Communication DEALL though it isnt
convenient in terms of distance. We currently take her
to Vashi for therapy. But we arent looking at our convenience
right now, he reasons.
Autism-affected demand separate I-cards
The Hindu
February 14, 2003
NEW DELHI FEB. 14. The National Trust for the Welfare of Persons
with Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation and Multiple Disabilities
has begun the process of lobbying with the Union Ministry of Health
and Family Welfare for issuing separate I-cards for persons with autism.
``Autism is not recognised as a separate category of disability and
though the number of cases of autism was on the rise, it still is
being clubbed with mental retardation,'' says Aloka Guha, Chairperson,
National Trust, adding that the Persons with Disability (Equal Opportunities,
Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995, too recognised
only seven categories of disabilities and autism does not figure anywhere
in the list.
On a conservative estimate, there are 20,000 persons living with
autism in Delhi alone. However, since autism is not recognised as
a separate category of disability, they remain hidden and invisible
missing out on the social benefits accruing for other categories of
disabled persons including a disability certificate where they are
certified as autistic.
Even among the members of the medical fraternity, there is a considerable
lack of awareness on what exactly constitutes autism. To clear their
confusion and to help them come to grips with the disability, the
National Trust held a one-day seminar on autism spectral disorders
on February 13 by a Canada-based development paediatrician Mervyn
Fox in association with the Union Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment.
Mr. Fox has also authored a book on the subject of autism for the
National Trust which was released on the occasion. "Family-centred
care is the only long-term therapy for tackling autism spectral disorders,''
he said.
Agreeing that the profile of disabilities was changing considerably,
Merry Baruah of Action for Autism and a parent of an autistic child
herself lamented that "there was no separate diagnostic criteria
for autism which was indeed unfortunate''. However, even cerebral
palsy was till recently clubbed with mental retardation and it has
now been recognised as a separate category of disability.
While efforts are also on to develop a separate course for special
educators dealing with autism, it is a struggle for many parents to
get a disability certificate stating that their child was autistic.
"I had to struggle a great deal to get a disability certificate
for my autistic child and when I managed to get one, he was certified
as mentally retarded and not autistic,'' said one parent.
A
Boy, a Mother and a Rare Map of Autism's World
The New York Times
November 19, 2002
By SANDRA BLAKESLEE
Tito Mukhopadhyay sits in a darkened laboratory, pointing at flashes
of light on a computer screen. On his right is a neuroscientist, one
of several who are testing Tito's ability to see, hear and feel touch.
At his left, Tito's mother, Soma, watches quietly. Tito, who is 14,
often stops the testing with bursts of activity. His body rocks rhythmically.
He stands and spins. He makes loud smacking noises. His arms fly in
the air as if yanked by a puppeteer. His fingers flutter.
Everyone waits.
Tito reaches for a yellow pad and writes to explain his behavior:
"I am calming myself. My senses are so disconnected, I lose my
body. So I flap. If I don't do this, I feel scattered and anxious."
Tito has severe autism, a disorder that occurs when the brain mysteriously
fails to develop normally in infancy and early childhood. Born and
raised in India, Tito speaks English with a huge vocabulary. His articulation
is poor, and he is often hard to understand. But he writes eloquently
and independently, on pads or his laptop, about what it feels like
to be locked inside an autistic body and mind.
"Tito is a window into autism such as the world has never seen,"
said Portia Iversen, a co-founder of Cure Autism Now, a Los Angeles
research foundation that brought Tito and Soma to the United States
in July 2001 and continues to support them. Autism experts are studying
him, amazed to discover, for what they say is the first time, a severely
autistic person who can explain his disorder. "Tito is for real,"
said Dr. Michael Merzenich, a neuroscientist at the University of
California at San Francisco Medical School, who has run extensive
tests on Tito. "He unhesitatingly responds to factual questions
about books that he has read or about experiences that he has had
in detail and in high fidelity."
"I've seen Tito sit in front of an audience of scientists and
take questions from the floor," said Dr. Matthew Belmonte, a
neuroscientist and an autism expert at Cambridge University. "He
taps out intelligent, witty answers on a laptop with a voice synthesizer.
No one is touching him. He communicates on his own."
Nor is Tito a savant, an autistic person with a single extraordinary
talent like the mathematically gifted character in the movie "Rain
Man." "Tito thinks and feels and has opinions like all the
rest of us," said Dr. Samuel Smithyman, a psychologist in Los
Angeles who is Tito's personal analyst. "He defies the assumptions
we have about autism." Tito was assessed with well-validated
diagnostic tests and meets all the criteria for autism, said Dr. Sarah
Spence, a pediatric neurologist at the University of California at
Los Angeles.
Like many autistic children, Tito appeared to develop normally. He
learned to sit and walk like other babies. But by the time he was
18 months old, he was showing signs that he was not like other toddlers,
especially in the way he distanced himself from social settings and
did not talk.
After his severe autism was diagnosed at age 3, Soma decided to educate
him anyway, using methods she would make up as she went along.
"I saw that Tito had very good memory with roads, position of
objects in the room, and also he would make complex patterns with
match sticks," said Soma, as she prefers to be called. "I
just wanted to divert his interests toward communication and learning."
For 10 years, she and Tito lived in small apartments in Mysore and
Bangalore, where she taught him, day and night. Although Tito wanted
to hide in a corner and watch a ceiling fan, Soma took him for daily
walks amid the colors, smells and sounds of local markets. Tito's
father, who lived and worked in a distant city, visited occasionally.
Soma first taught Tito to recognize letters and sounds on an alphabet
board, choosing English over more difficult Indian dialects. Then
she tied a pencil in his hand and showed him how to make each letter,
often refusing to let him eat until he could do so. Around then, a
method called facilitated communication, in which a parent or teacher
holds the wrist of an autistic person as he or she taps messages on
computer keys, had been widely discredited. Critics said teachers
were prompting autistic people to respond through a kind of Ouija
board effect.
"I was desperate to show people that Tito's poems came from him
and not me," Soma said. "I put myself in other people's
shoes and knew we needed genuine proof that he could write independently."
The mother also read Tito stories and books - Aesop's fables, Thomas
Hardy novels and the complete works of Dickens and Shakespeare - and
demanded that he write his own stories in return. Tito continues to
write poetry and essays every day. His first book, "Beyond the
Silence," was published two years ago in Britain by the National
Autistic Society. "I need to write," he said recently, scrawling
the words on a yellow pad. "It has become part of me. I am waiting
to get famous." Since traveling to the United States, Tito has
visited six laboratories for neurological testing. Because he cannot
hold still long enough for brain imaging, he cannot offer researchers
pictures of his mind in action. Instead, he gives them clues about
his mental states in poems and essays that can then be explored in
specially created tests.
"When I was 4 or 5 years old," he wrote while living in
India, "I hardly realized that I had a body except when I was
hungry or when I realized that I was standing under the shower and
my body got wet. I needed constant movement, which made me get the
feeling of my body. The movement can be of a rotating type or just
flapping of my hands. Every movement is a proof that I exist. I exist
because I can move." Tito seems to lack a sense of his own body,
the kind of internal map, Dr. Merzenich said, that normal children
develop in their first few years. The maps involve brain regions that
specialize in the sense of touch and movement and are widely connected
to other areas, and they are highly dynamic throughout life, changing
in response to everyday experience. By imaging the brains of higher
functioning autistic people who can stay still in scanners, researchers
in the laboratory of Dr. Eric Courchesne at the University of California
at San Diego found that autistic people had mixed-up brain maps. Although
a normal person, for example, has a well-defined brain area that specializes
in face recognition, some autistic people have face-recognition areas
in parts of the brain like the frontal lobes, where no one had dreamed
they could be laid down. The same is true of maps that help plan movements.
This means body maps are formed in autistic children, but they may
be scrambled differently in each person. In imaging experiments starting
at the University of California at San Francisco, Dr. David McGonigle,
a radiologist, is exploring the hypothesis that some autistic children
may have scrambled body maps. Many cannot identify parts of their
bodies in a mirror. Even if they know "nose," for example,
when asked to point at the nose they may put a finger to an ear. They
also tend to be clumsy. With eyes closed while standing, they wobble
and stagger. Ms. Iversen, whose 10-year-old son, Dov, is severely
autistic, notes that maps for face recognition form early. "I
smile, you smile, and maps are formed," she said. But if you
do not have a faithful mental map of your own face and body, she said,
you cannot read the expression on someone else's face.
The inability to interact socially is a core
problem in autism. People who lack normal body maps may not be able
to build consistent mental models of the world, Dr. Belmonte said.
They may not be able to integrate sights, sounds, smells, touches
and tastes. This is what Tito is talking about when he writes that
he cannot perceive the world with more than one sense at a time. "I
can concentrate either at what I am seeing or what I am hearing or
what I am smelling," he wrote, not long after he began meeting
neurologists. "It felt nothing unnatural to me until I realized
that others could simultaneously see and hear and smell." In
Dr. Merzenich's lab, Tito has had extensive testing to explore his
unusual perception. Sitting in a darkened room, he listens to beeps
followed by flashes of light on a computer screen. Most people can
sense the sound and the light, even when they are separated by only
a fraction of a second. But unless the light follows the sound by
a full three seconds - an eternity for most brains - Tito never sees
it. "I need time to prepare my ears," he told Dr. Merzenich.
"I need time to prepare my eyes. Otherwise the world is chaos."
Tito says that people with autism, at least those who are like him,
choose one sensory channel. He chose hearing. Most of the time, Tito
attends to the sounds of language and to oral information, which may
help explain his gift for poetry. Vision, Tito said, is painful. He
scans the world with his peripheral vision and rarely looks directly
at anything. Other autistic people like Dr. Temple Grandin, a professor
at Colorado State who earned a doctorate in animal science, specializes
in vision. "When I talk about anything new, I have to look at
the picture in my mind, and then language narrates it like a slide
show." Dr. Grandin said when she met Tito in Dr. Merzenich's
lab, where they were tested side by side in September. For Tito, willing
his body to do things is a particular problem, Soma said. "If
he's sitting on the couch and I ask him to go to the kitchen, he cannot
do it," she added. "But if he hears me open a bag of cookies,
he moves like a gazelle on pure impulse." That is another sign
that Tito's brain is disconnected, Dr. Merzenich said. Children gradually
develop higher circuits to control their impulses as the frontal lobes
mature and connect to circuits that developed earlier. Each stage
rests on earlier circuitry; if that is abnormal, later-to-develop
regions may never be organized correctly.
Still, Tito's behavior and writings dispel a popular notion that autistic
children do not feel empathy, Ms. Iversen said. Tito has feelings
and notices emotions, she said, but he can be stoic about his disorder.
When a mother at a large autism meeting asked Tito for his advice
to parents, Tito replied simply, "Believe in your children."
Most experts say they believe that abnormalities in several genes
contribute to developing autism, along with environmental factors
that have yet to be fully identified. Many parents say the first symptoms,
like the lack of eye contact, as in Tito's case, do not appear for
about 18 months. This accident of timing has led some to associate
vaccines given at that age with the onset of autism. But it is equally
plausible, many experts say, that the symptoms appear at that time
because that is when the brain naturally reaches new levels of complexity.
If primary sensory regions like the auditory cortex have prenatal
defects, entire pathways of subsequent brain organization would not
form properly.
Researchers have measured swarms of electrical discharges in the primary
hearing regions of autistic children while they sleep. Such epilepsy-like
activity may affect the way the brain organizes its circuitry in childhood.
Others note that the brains of autistic children are larger than average
and that the brain's basic building blocks, called cortical columns,
contain many more cells than normal and make excess connections to
other cells. Such hyperconnectivity may cause autistic children to
become overwhelmed by details because their minds are never free to
integrate the whole picture. Moreover, their brains are wired in such
a way that they are prone to associate things that do not normally
go together. Tito says that at 4, he was looking at a cloud when he
heard someone talking about bananas. It took him years to realize
that bananas and clouds were different. As researchers continue to
study Tito, Soma works with a small number of children in Los Angeles
to see whether her teaching methods can help others. Unlike many educators
who try to slow things for autistic children, Soma demands rapid responses,
which she says prevent the child's brain from being distracted.
It is too soon to tell whether she will succeed. But parents like
Ms. Iversen have been impressed. When her son first used the spelling
board, Dov broke his muteness, asking for a navy blue blazer and algebra
lessons. When she asked him what he had been doing all those years
when he couldn't communicate, he pointed out letters to spell "listening."
New
Delhi Center Has Ripple Effect
The New York Times
November 18, 2002
By JOHN O'NEIL
The school that Merry Barua runs in New Delhi is the
largest autism service center in southern Asia. Last year, she persuaded
the Indian government to recognize the existence of autism for the
first time though it has not financed any treatment. A former
prime minister, Sonia Gandhi, attended a fund-raiser concert that
Ms. Barua's group, Action for Autism, held this month. Yet
when Ms. Barua started her efforts, she was simply a mother facing
"a very desperate life at home," she said, trying to cope
with her autistic son's increasingly difficult behavior. She scraped
together the money for a two-week course at an autism center in America.
"Because my life got easier, I was able to help others,"
she said. In 1994, with two other mothers, she started the Open Door,
India's first autism school, with a single teacher and two students.
Then she started a newsletter, "and the
organization took off," she said, as the newsletter and later
a Web site, www.autism-india.org, fed the thirst for information from
the many parents who in the mid-1990's were hearing about autism for
the first time. The center's school is larger
now, with about 50 students, but the emphasis is still on training
parents and sharing knowledge. "The basic idea behind all our
programs is to try to have a ripple effect," Ms. Barua said.
A particular emphasis is on parent training, in the hope that not
only are parents able to provide instruction at home but also able
to pass that knowledge along. All told, Ms. Barua estimated that several
thousand children had been affected by such outreach efforts.
The Open Door has also spawned a half-dozen similarly
parent-run schools in other Indian cities. She
said that Action for Autism receives some support from the Danish
Autism Society and occasional checks from Indians overseas. Teachers
and consultants from other countries come regularly to speak and conduct
training sessions. But for the most part, Ms. Barua said, her group
relies on raising money locally. "We have very low costs,"
she said with a laugh, adding that staff members work for "totally
stupid amounts." Items on her wish list
include: whiteboards and felt pens, $50; a portable music system,
$500; two trampolines, $80 each; new books on autism, $1,000. Her
big goal is to raise $1 million to build a center on property in New
Delhi that the government donated last month. Ms. Barua is working
on a sponsor-a-brick program "so people don't feel threatened
by a humongous sum."
When
a disabled child needs a guardian
Times of India
By GEETHA RAO (Bangalore)
OCTOBER 25, 2002
There is one question that preys on the minds of parents whose children
suffer from autism, cerebral palsy, mental retardation and multiple
disabilities: who will look after their children when they die? Is
there a case for guardianship? Pradeep Kumar, Assistant Commissioner,
Office for the Welfare of the Disabled, reassures them that the National
Trust for Welfare of Persons with Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation
and Multiple Disabilities Act 1999 and Rules 2000 will give them the
answers. Who can look after mentally disabled
children once their parents die? That's some thing that worries parents
of such children. But with the National Trust for Welfare of Persons
with autism, cerebral palsy, mental retardation and multiple disabilities
Act 1999 and rules 2000, they can be assured that their children can
be given guardianship, and that these guardians will look after them
after their parents' death. Unfortunately, not many are aware that
they can apply for guardianship and safeguard their children's future.
Not just parents, sometimes even government officers do not know this.
What is the role of guardians? The
person appointed as guardian shall take care of the person with disability
and his property, or be responsible for the maintenance of such a
person. The guardian should, within a period of six months from the
date of appointment, furnish an inventory of immovable property belonging
to the person with disability. He must also furnish details of the
movable property received on the person's behalf. Also, within a period
of three months at the close of every financial year, he should have
an account of the property and assets in his charge.
How can a person apply for guardianship?
A parent of a person with disability or his relative
can apply for guardianship to the local level committee, appointing
any person of his choice to act as guardian. Any registered organisation
can also make an application in the prescribed form to the local level
committee for appointment to guardianship. For this, they must use
Form A. Form A is available at the district deputy commissioner's
office and the assistant director, office of women and children development
in all districts.
Who can become a guardian? Natural
parents, a relative, a registered organisation or any one who wishes
to become a guardian can become a guardian. Till such a person is
18, parents are allowed to take decisions for them. But after that,
they become guardians.
Does guardianship mean that the disabled person
has to live with the guardian? Not necessarily.
Who monitors the guardianship? The
local level committee headed by the district magistrate monitors the
guardianship.
Can there be more than one guardian?
Yes, There is separate guardianship available. There
can be one guardian for care, and another for property. The local
level committee looks into both kinds of guardianship.
Can a guardian be removed? Yes, a guardian
can be removed if the parent, relative or registered organisation
finds the guardian abusing or neglecting the ward. This includes solitary
confinement, sexual abuse, physical abuse or chaining. A guardian
can also be removed if he is found misappropriating or neglecting
the ward's property. If the committee is satisfied that there is ground
for removal, the guardian can be removed and a new guardian be appointed
in his place. For further information, contact
Pradeep Kumar on 548 2641 or the Karnataka Parents Association for
the Mentally Retarded Citizens on 656 4608.
Hope for autistic children
The Hindu
September 30, 2002
By Alladi Jayasri
Every week, at Prathibha Karanth's consulting rooms, at least two
sets of frantic parents bring their toddlers, plying her with questions,
scared and mystified, as to why the children are violent, unresponsive,
anti-social, incapable of feeling emotions, and unable to take care
of themselves. Or in less alarming degrees, not displaying the normal
social skills or responses appropriate to their age.
Autism and related pervasive developmental disorders (PDD) affects
at least 15 in every 10,000 people, and research is advanced just
enough to link them to biological or neurological disorders.
The search has been on to find a cure since autism and PDD first
became known, and to help the affected people enter the mainstream.
The past couple of decades have seen if nothing else, a coming together
of parents and families of autistic children to make common cause,
share the problems, and work towards a solution.
But the eminent speech-language pathologist, Prathibha Karanth, is
impatient, with answers that elude research and experiment. Dr. Karanth,
who trained at NIMHANS and worked at the Mysore-based All-India Institute
of Speech and Hearing, pioneered the Communication DEALL (Developmental
Eclectic Approach to Language Learning).
And less than two years since it was initiated, DEALL has proved
to be the light at the end of the tunnel for more than 50 children.
Five children on the DEALL programme are already in regular schools,
and for Dr. Karanth, they are the vindication of her conviction that
earlier the intervention, easier the integration of the child into
the mainstream.
Parents of one child have relocated from the Middle East so that
it can overcome the debilitating disorder, and another mother brings
her three-year-old from Peenya, although there is another baby for
her to look after.
Another child, who finished therapy with Dr. Karanth, is happily
attending regular school, and his mother is volunteering her time,
and sharing her experience to encourage parents who continue to be
devastated on discovering their child's condition.
Communication DEALL, says Dr. Karanth, a winner of the Young Scientists'
Award early in her career, was a response to the virtual absence of
intensive early intervention for alleviation of these disorders. DEALL
aims to provide intensive stimulation and training to small groups
of pre-school children with developmental disorders, in the areas
of communication, cognition, behaviour, and socialisation, enabling
their integration into the normal school set-up.
Parents are wary of being candid about their child's disorder history,
as they fear, with justification, that it may mean a prejudice against
the child. "I tell them to call only if some problem develops,
and there are indications of a regression, although it is remote,''
she says.
There is nothing that sensitivity and understanding cannot handle,
but school managements and other parents are often short on those,
when it comes to autism, as any parent of an autistic child knows.
This has only made Dr. Karanth all the more determined to show that
autism is conquerable. She has put 15 toddlers on DEALL in a new Montessori
school, Creative Foundation, in Fraser town.
The school's Neelam Calla, who had no qualms about "mixing these
extraordinarily gifted children with others'', however, sent off letters
to all parents, and was touched to find that nearly every one of them
welcomed the idea.
For Dr. Karanth, this means autism or PDD can be "erased'' and
the child integrated without the trauma or ignominy associated with
the disorder.
© Copyright 2000 - 2003 The Hindu
Their need is special
The Hindu
August 6, 2002
By PRASSANA SRINIVASAN
Children with autism, a developmental disorder, require special attention.
And catering for their needs are several organisations in the city.
ROHAN IS just four-years-old; he can read long sentences with ease.
But, ask him to recite the alphabet and he stammers. Rohan is one
among many children who suffer from the developmental disorder, autism.
Autism is defined as a life-long developmental disorder primarily
affecting communication and social skills, thought and behaviour.
It was in 1943 that Leo Kanner, a child psychiatrist of the John Hopkins
Medical School, gave the disorder the term `autism'.
Studies reveal that signs of autism are evident before the age of
three, and boys are four times more affected than girls.
Although, it occurs as early as 18 months in a child, the symptoms
surface as the child develops. Statistics estimate that five to 15
of every 10,000 children are diagnosed with autism. The child fails
to develop language skills appropriate for its age and is unresponsive
to parents or any other stimuli. "My son did not respond to me
or anyone else at home even when he was two. In the beginning, we
thought he was hearing impaired, but we discovered that he responded
to the sounds from TV or radio. So we took him to an ENT specialist
who found that his hearing was normal. He suggested that we go to
a child psychiatrist and that's how we learnt he was autistic,"
says Gayathri. Awareness of autism is considerably less even among
educated parents and not many children are given the right treatment.
Like Vidya's son, who was wrongly diagnosed as being mentally challenged
and put in a special school. "I found that there was no progress
in his behaviour. On the contrary, he was getting worse as the days
went by. We consulted a child psychiatrist who suggested that we remove
him from school immediately. For a long time, he was under individual
supervision, after which we put him in a special needs school,"
she says.
"Although 50 per cent of autistic children are bound to be mentally
challenged, one must understand that autism is not a mental illness.
One can call it a spectrum disorder, in the sense that each child
has a unique problem. One child might be extremely sensitive to sound,
while the other may be sensitive to smell. So the child's need has
to be assessed and addressed, and a structured pattern of development
activity provided," says Sulata Ajit of Sankalp (ph: 6182588).
Subhashini, Lakshmi and Sulata, with other in-house occupational
and speech therapists, cater for the needs of over 30 autistic children
in their school, which was started in 1999. "It is also wrongly
understood that those who are autistic have a conscious desire to
withdraw from social interactions but again, one must understand that
their withdrawal is not a conscious desire but a result of the neurological
disorder," says Sulata.
"It is very important that the child is not nagged all the time.
Rather than asking him not to do a certain action, if the child is
given the choice to do what he/she wants, it will help improve behaviour.
Here, we do not follow any prescribed curriculum, but we do follow
a structured learning programme. After thorough observation and informal
evaluation, we start teaching the children. We also have in-house
occupational and speech therapists who give the required treatment,"
says Sulata, a special educator herself.
Autistic children do not look different but what sets them apart
is their apparent inability to relate to the environment. There is
also a wide variance in their intellectual ability. Some can be hyperactive
while some tend to be slow learners. Many autistic children are visual
learners and are less confused if the information is presented visually.
"Hyperactive children are said to have Asperger's syndrome, a
variant of autism. They are highly able people who are autistic. Unlike
other autistic children, they are more independent and able to help
themselves. They may have excellent rote memory but have problems
in socialising," points out Sulata.
"Some parents are happy to put their child in a regular school
without realising the consequences. But the problem will arise when
the child goes to the higher classes," says Hira, a parent, who
attended the recent workshop on autism conducted by We Can (Ph: 4473136),
a Chennai-based organisation, working with autistic children.
"It took a long time for us to come to terms with the fact that
our child was autistic. After that, we have spared no effort in caring
for the toddler. But social acceptance is still a dream for these
children. People are ready to accept a badly behaved normal child
but are not anywhere close to accepting these special children,"
says Radhika a desperate parent.
"Early diagnosis and educational evaluation is very crucial
in managing the problem. Help and guided supervision can work wonders
and the person can lead a more independent life that is close to normal,"
says Hema Jayaram of We Can.
It is a positive sign that various groups in Chennai are creating
awareness about autism. It still requires the help of parents, psychiatrists,
paediatrics, school authorities and the public to give such special
children understanding and the space to develop as individuals.
The Signs...
SINCE AUTISM is considered a spectrum disorder, there are many terms
to describe children with autism, such as autistic like, high functioning
or low functioning, less-abled or more-abled and so on. However, there
are certain characteristics typical of children with autism. Here
are a few:
-- Avoiding eye contact, lack of interaction with other children
and inability to communicate by word or gesture.
-- Inability to accept affection, and problems relating to people,
objects and events (the child may resist cuddling or scream when picked
up).
-- Violent behaviour towards others, throwing tantrums for no apparent
reason.
-- Repetition of others' words and something heard earlier (echolalia).
-- Hyper or hyposensitivity to sensory stimuli such as touch, hearing
and smell. (For instance, some children may dislike being touched,
some might be hypersensitive to sound, others have an affinity for
bright colours).
-- Need for sameness and insistence that the environment remains
unchanged.
- Unusual mannerisms such as grimaces, hand flapping, rocking, jumping
and often treating others as inanimate objects.
-- Paying attention to minor or insignificant details of an object
or a situation and then putting these details together to form a bigger
picture.
-- Use of meaningless language and difficulty in understanding abstract