
N E T W O R K
August 1997 Vol. IV, No. 2
Page One
The monsoons are with us and so is our second issue of the year. In
this issue we carry a very interesting article by Charles Hart on the
frequently used term of Pervasive Development Disorder (PDD) that is
used to diagnose a child with an autism spectrum disorder. Hart grew
up with a brother who has autism and is the father of a young boy with
autism.
Certainly the situation in India is somewhat different from that in
the US. Here when the family is advised, Your child does not have
autism, only PDD, they are usually given to understand that it
is a mere developmental delay that would sort itself out
with time. In the process the family lose valuable time as it delays
the parents learning about appropriate intervention techniques to help
their child. This kind of situation is more common with the more able
child with autism. What we have to remember is that even the more able
person with autism requires specialised intervention. In fact the earlier
in the childs life this happens, the better the possibilities
of mainstreaming.
In India, food is a major issue in most families. If my child is fat
then I am a good parent A slender child is believed to denote lack of
care. With such social pressures it is not surprising that in most families
with an autistic member eating difficulties is an area of deep concern.
This issue carries the first part of a series on teaching appropriate
food habits to a child with autism.
The AFA Workshops on autism take place in October as they did last
year. This year there are two workshops, one for parents, and one for
special educators and others who work with children. More details elsewhere
in the journal.
Three parents from Action for Autism visited Denmark at the invitation
of the Autism Society Denmark. The study tour included visits to various
facilities: schools, adult workshops, adult residential units providing
us an opportunity to interact and share with some very dedicated and
innovative professionals. Some of the professionals: extremely knowledgeable
and experienced were yet very keen about observations about their system
from these three visiting parents!! All in all a unique experience.
Developing Appropriate Eating Habits,
Part I
Sandra Dawson
We live in a very demanding world. A world that expects us all to cope
with ever-changing rules, standards and norms. As children growing up,
we learn to identify cues that suggest we act a certain way, to be socially
appropriate. We learn to satisfy physical and mental needs by communicating
them to our parents or caregivers. We learn how to deal with physical
difficulties by asking and finding out what is bothering us and why.
Sometimes there may be some difficulties in habits and behaviors that
children outgrow as they develop physically, mentally, socially and
psychologically.
People with autism are different because they have a social and communication
impairment. This along with other things may present a difference in
the development of their eating habits. Eating a very limited diet,
difficult behavior during mealtimes, having to be fed, not sitting to
eat, eating only junk food and eating untidily; all these are only some
of the challenges that parents and caregivers have to face.
A person who is coping with autism may take much longer to outgrow
these habits and change them to socially appropriate ones. Some with
extreme rigidities about change and extreme sensory sensitivities to
textures, smells and tastes of foods, may need to be taught in a very
specific and systematic manner to make it easy for them. Their eating
habits are one of the major concerns of parents and carers of autistic
people. In many situations mealtimes have become a negative experience
where children often feel forced and may resist more and more, until
it becomes virtually impossible to feed them anything. Very often we
become the big spider that scared Little Miss Muffet, by forcing them
to go through an unpleasant experience.
What we really need to do is remember that the child is trying, and
whatever little effort he makes, even taking one bite or sitting for
a few seconds, must be cheered and praised like the conquering of Mount
Everest. Recognize this to be just a small step in the progress of his
eating habits. We want to try our best to make each mealtime happy,
relaxed and fun for the child.
When we begin to teach a child to eat, we want first to put our desires
and wants into perspective, focus on what we want right now for the
child. We may want the child to eat varied foods, to eat on his own,
to eat decently and neatly and to sit and eat. It is good to want these
things for our child, but if were going to aim for all these things
at one time, the possibility of achieving any one of them is reduced.
This is why focusing our attention on what is more important is necessary.
Ask yourself, What do I want for my child right now? And
before you arrive at the answer consider the fact that you are helping
him organize his world, as much as possible. It would therefore be better
to teach him eating habits in the sequence that would be most structured
for him.
One suggestion is to focus first on teaching him to SIT. To do this,
begin by keeping mealtimes very short, and decide on fixed times for
meals. Completely cut out nibbling on biscuits or other goodies between
mealtimes. This will help ensure the child is really hungry and desiring
food by mealtime. Also, decide on one place to sit and eat: at a table,
or wherever the family usually sits to eat will do just fine. This will
help act as a cue that mealtime has begun. Set the food out so that
when the child comes to the designated area, everything is ready. Instruct
the child in simple clear terms Time to eat. Come. Guide
him to the eating area and prompt him to sit. As soon as the child sits,
praise the sitting in a big way. Let the applause be highly enthusiastic
and different from the regular Good Boy that we might say.
Then, let him pick up his food. If the child is used to being fed, then
go ahead and feed him, because we don't want to forget our target -
getting him to sit- and not anything else. Intersperse your conversation
with praise for the sitting. The child may pick up a piece of food and
get up and walk away. At such times immediately remove the food from
his hand, and placing it back on the plate say Sit and Eat
- You want to eat? Sit, always stressing the word sit.
When he comes near the plate, quickly lift him or prompt him into the
chair and praise the sitting. With bigger children, hold the plate out
of reach until the child has sat.
It is very important, if you ever want this lesson to register, for
the child NOT to get the food unless he is sitting. Keep repeating
this if necessary each time the child gets up. Very soon, he will get
the message that if he wants food at all, he will have to sit. Importantly,
no negative comments should be made at this time or any other time,
in the hearing range of the child. Comments like If you dont
sit you wont get your food or other such negative statements
must be avoided. Stay positive in what you say. Sit or Eat
is usually enough. Again may we stress that comfort is necessary.
When you remove the food from the childs hand or are trying to
get him to sit again, it should be done in a very matter of fact way.
If frustration or stress is present, it will be sensed immediately by
the child and the chances of him sitting or eating may reduce. So stay
comfortable.
One child we know started with eating namkeen, right through the day.
As the forcing stopped and comfort and acceptance came in, the child
began to eat a little of so many other foods. Today he loves to eat
dosas and egg and rice and dal. He tries different fruits and raw vegetables
in salads. We have come across quite a few children who have thrived
on only rotis and curd, or coconut cookies and namkeen mixtures for
months at a time, and have now grown into healthy young people.
The earlier the child learns appropriate eating habits, the easier his
life and the lives around him are going to be when he is older.
In the beginning give your child a small quantity of food that he likes
very much. . It may just be a single type of biscuit only glucose or
only coconut cookies, or even one kind of namkeen mixture. It doesnt
matter what the desired food is, use it. The chances that he will eat
it, are so much higher if a) he is hungry and b)if he likes the food.
Also if the quantity of food is small, it finishes with a few bites,
allowing the child an opportunity to complete the activity, and giving
him a sense of accomplishment. This will possibly work to make him try
harder next time.
Be prepared in the initial stages for the child to even skip a meal
or two, off and on. It may seem a little heartless but children, more
often than not, know better than adults how much food their bodies need.
Along with being accepting and comfortable it is very important to be
consistent and persistent. This is something we have repeated
in many articles before this and is equally important in developing
appropriate eating habits.
As time goes by and you remain very persistent and consistent in your
reactions, and instructions, the child will learn to sit for longer
and longer periods. Very naturally, as parents and carers we also want
the child to learn to eat other foods, less liked foods, but those that
provide a balanced diet. So if the child is sitting for at least 8-10
minutes at a stretch, you can now begin to slowly introduce new foods
during meals. Again start with extremely small amounts of a food that
is eaten on and off. A square centimeter of bread, or a teaspoon of
rice, or curd and dal. Whatever you introduce to your child, please
do remember to consider his sensitivities and preferences. If dry foods
do not agree, begin by introducing wet foods or vice versa. Always praise
or cheer. Whenever the child eats something outside the preferred list,
praise enthusiastically. Encouraging a balanced diet can be a long process,
and it may take from a couple of months to a few years. But in later
years when the child is eating all kinds of foods the effort you have
put in now will be well worth it.
We have only been talking about the first step in teaching an autistic
child to eat. In further issues of the journal, we will discuss how
to teach other things like eating on their own, eating neatly, and getting
over particular dislikes. For those whose children are still at the
first stage, we would like to suggest that you try this and see if it
works. Were sure that this will be of some help to you.
Relationship-Building for Students with
Autism
Karen J. Christof and Steve R. Kane
From Teaching Exceptional Children
Editor's note:
At our counseling sessions with families, at our workshops, and also
our training our teachers, we have been repeatedly stressing the importance
of not making assumptions about the behaviors exhibited by a child with
autism. One prevalent belief that we encounter frequently is that behaviors
are a result of conditions in the immediate environment. From our work,
we know that this assumption is often faulty. Another prevalent belief
is that all so- called self stimulatory behaviors are harmful and must
be stopped. We believe that such behaviors can have a communication
intent. We are happy to share with our readers this article by
Christof and Kane from TEACHING EXEPTIONAL CHILDREN, that elaborates
lucidly on the above and other points, and takes it further into the
area of building relationships for children with impaired social skills.
Impaired social relationships have always been considered the definitive
feature of autism. Yet, only in recent years has it been recognized
that individuals with autism can and do develop sustained social attachments.
Now it is possible to consider their capacity for interpersonal relationships
as a source of therapeutic gain in the educational setting. The relationship
between teacher and student creates natural reinforces that motivate
the child to learn. This article provides strategies for building relationships
in the classroom.
Behavior as communication:
In recent years, there has been a shift in focus from the form that
autistic behavior takes to the function it serves, based on the recognition
that every behavior regardless of its outward form, is inherently meaningful.
Even such atypical, socially inappropriate behaviors as echolalia, self-stimulation,
and self-injury can serve communication functions. The behavior might
indicate a request, a response to some-one's presence, or simply the
identification of something familiar.
The functional meaning of behavior cannot be understood on the basis
of objective observation alone. Inferences must be drawn from an assessment
of contextual variables. For example, a child's sudden repetition of
a cooking commercial in the grocery store may mean " I want cookies"
or "This is the place where cookies are sold" whereas the
same echolaliac utterance in the classroom could mean " I'm bored",
" I can't do this", " I'm hungry", or any number
of other messages. An adequate interpretation of this behavior would
require an analysis of the whole behavioral ecology- the interactions
among the child, his or her behavior, and the social and physical environments.
An analysis such as this, which account for variables that are not easily
quantified, extends far beyond the traditional behavioral focus on immediate
antecedents and consequences.
Functional analyses of behavior have revealed that, although children
with autism have impaired social skills, they can develop relationships
with others. It has been found that these children seek comfort and
interaction more from family members than from strangers. Such findings
stand in contrast to the popular image of the autistic child as being
aloof. When behavior is observed in its natural context and in light
of its function, the child with autism can no longer be seen as an asocial
being.
The capacity of social relationships has not yet been recognized as
a valuable resource in the education of individuals with autism. For
the past two decades, the emphasis has been on managing discrete behaviors.
Behavioral training procedures were founded upon the assumption that
each behavior is solely as a response to conditions in the immediate
environment. More recently, applied behavior analysis has been expanded
to include the consideration of communicative functions and ecological
variables. Nevertheless, the continued reliance on adult-directed activities,
which place the child in the role of responder, often hinders spontaneity
and the emergence of social interactions.
Precise behavioral technologies may be necessary to reduce problem
behaviors that are extremely disruptive or potentially harmful. However,
the results of such interventions will be impermanent unless time is
also spent on developing alternative behaviors based on the learners
natural strengths. Positive programming has been defined as a gradual
educational process that is based on a functional analysis of the presenting
problems and involves the systematic instruction of more effective ways
of behaving. It recognizes the need to decrease maladaptive behaviors
while simultaneously facilitating the development of appropriate ones.
Positive programming begins with relationship-building. In fact, the
development of relationships is an essential but often unspoken component
of all good teaching in order to have a working classroom, the teacher
must develop a rapport with students based on mutual understanding and
trust. Every teacher will find certain children easy to like and work
with but others more difficult. To shape a class as a whole, however
the teacher must build relationships with all students. As a result,
they will become motivated to meet the teachers expectations. The relationship
will become as reinforcing as any reward used to manage behaviors. Difficulty
in relating to people is one of the most obvious and crucial deficits
in autism. Yet, as in normal development in autism the child's awareness
of self emerges with awareness of others. The development of relationships
should be considered a cornerstone to the child's entire education.
In some cases, the bond may remain on a rather primitive level, with
the caregiver meeting the child's primary need for food, warmth, and
comfort. But in most cases, a rapport that is mutually interesting and
enjoyable will develop over time.
Strategies for the development of relationships:
Students with autism present a particularly difficult challenge, because
they interact in atypical ways. The process of building relationships
takes longer and must involve many of the students unusual behaviors
and interests. The following strategies can facilitate this process.
Understand what motivates the student. Search for clues to the meaning
of behavior. Be aware of physical state and health needs. Observe the
people and things that interest the student, and try to understand what
it is about them that draws his or her interest. Take note of what excites
the student, what causes anxiety, fear, or frustration. Test the validity
of your conclusions against your observations.
B displayed ritualistic patterns each morning. Even taking his coat
off and hanging it up could take as long as an hour. B would repeat
each step in the process until he seemed satisfied with how it was done.
B's teacher noticed that the intensity of ritualistic behavior decreased
around the same time of day that the effect of his medication wore off.
What appeared to be a characteristic of autism was in fact a side effect
of B's medication. Focus on the students strengths. Don't focus on problem
behaviors. What you attend to will influence how you will feel about
the child as well as the child's own self-concept. T exhibited
a range of behaviors during group activities. At times, she would leave
the group to run around the room. But she tended to join
the group for singing or language-oriented games. T's teacher chose
to attend only to her positive interactions with the group and to ignore
her disruptive behaviors.
Recognize the behavior is communication. When a child is unable to
complete or participate in an activity, it does not mean that he or
she is being bad or non-compliant. The child may not understand what
is going on, maybe tired or bored or just be unable to concentrate on
the task. Even when an interpretation of behavior cannot be found, the
potential for communicative content can be recognized. R screamed with
different intonations in different situations. A high-pitched shrill
consistently indicated a ear infection. Many other screams indicated
frustration with difficult demands.
Approach the student on his or her terms, in non-threatening ways.
Parallel the student's spontaneous action - whether it is spinning a
coin, tapping a rhythm, or singing a jingle. This will give way to directed
turn-taking, and eventually reciprocal interaction. With more passive
children, arrange the environment (e.g. during a snack). M preferred
to spend his time lining blocks. When interrupted, he would either move
away or become aggressive. M's teacher approached him by sitting near
him and playing with her own blocks in a similar way. This gave M the
opportunity to accept her presence without feeling threatened.
Later, she varied her play in order to draw M's interest and model new
skills.
Give the student control with a structured situation. This will help
establish the give and take of the relationship. Control is often provided
in the context of a choice. Be careful of how the choice is worded.
The options should be distinct and meaningful to the student. Make sure
he or she has the time needed to process and respond to the choice.
With students who are unable to make choices, follow their lead when
preferences are spontaneously expressed. Let them determine the course
of the interaction. When asked an either/or question, O could only respond
to the last choice she heard. Her teacher avoided this dilemma by presenting
O options visually and allowing her to choose.
Promote the student's sense of self-worth. Be willing to modify a task
or even give it up. The objective is to help the child feel competent
in doing something and that doing it is worthwhile. The student's
self-confidence will contribute to the stability of the relationship
and to the experience of learning. Encourage the student with praise.
Use clear and simple verbalizations and a good deal of body language.
Express his or her own pride as in 'You must feel good about that',
instead of 'I'm so proud of you.' P could meet complex demands, but
he had a low tolerance for frustration. When P became anxious, his teacher
would adjust the demand and ask P to do a little more before putting
his work away. In that way, problem behaviors would be avoided and P
would leave the activity having experienced some success. Help the student
learn the acceptable limits. This contributes to relationship-building
by promoting a sense of security and predictability.
Be calm but firm when setting limits. Avoid feeling personally challenged
by the child's disruptive behavior. A would become aggressive when other
children were upset. Sometimes it would be necessary to hold her physically.
At such times, the tension in A's body would quickly give way to a posture
of accepting comfort. A's aggression appeared to be an expression of
fear. She eventually learned to ask for additional support from additional
staff.
Be aware that the student may attempt to relate through negative behaviors.
The child who appears unrelated, may in fact be initiating interactions,
in inappropriate ways. These may be the only means available. Establishing
positive alternative means will diminish the need for negative behavior.
When C first came to school, his only means of approaching people for
attention was to bite. His biting decreased when other means of greeting,
(e.g. 'give me five') were learned.
Conclusion:
Each relationship will have its own unique characteristics. The strategies
discussed here are not intended to be exhaustive or mutually exclusive.
No one strategy for developing relationships can be isolated. Teachers
of children with autism must take enough time to understand their students
and give the students the opportunity to accept them. The gradual process
of positive programming is achieved most effectively when founded upon
a sincere relationship between teacher and student.
References
Donnellan, A.M., Anderson, J.L. & Messaros, R.A. (1984)
An observational study of stereotype
behaviors in proximity related to occurrence of autistic child-family
interactions. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 14, 205-210.
Donellan, A.M. & Kilman, B.A. (1986). Behavioral approaches
to social skill development in autism. In
Schopler, E. & Mesibov, G.B. (Eds), Social Behavior in Autism (pp.
213- 236) New York: Plenum Press.
Donellan, A.M., La Vigna, G.W., Negre Shoultz, N., & Fassbender,
L.L. (1988). Progress without
punishment, Effective Approaches for Learners with Behaviour Problems.
New York: Teachers College Press.
Donellan, A.M., Mirenda, P.L., Mesaros R.A., & Fassbender, L.L.
(1984). Analyzing the communicative
functions of aberrant behavior. Journal of Association for Persons with
Severe Handicaps, 9: 201-212.
Sigman, M. & Ungers, J.A. (1984). Attachment behaviors in
autistic children. Journal of Autism and
Developmental Disorder,. 14, 231-244.
Volkmar, F.R. (1987). Social development. In D.J. Cohen
& A.M. Donellan (Eds)
Handbook of Autism and Pervasive Developmental Disorders, pp 41-60.
New York :Wiley.
Autism Conference, Philippines
Sandra Dawson
In April this year, the Autism Society, Philippines held its Third
National Conference. We had the opportunity to attend the same as representatives
of Action for Autism. This visit to the Philippines was sponsored by
the Danish Council of Organizations of Disabled People. During the 10
day long trip we attended the conference, visited schools, centres,
institutions and had talks with various members of the ASP, as well
as other professionals in the field of disability.
'Autism Intervention Beyond Expectation' was the theme of the three
day conference. Most of the people in attendance were parents of autistic
children. There were also professionals connected with the disability,
such as pediatricians, occupational speech and physical therapists,
teachers and special educators, both contributing to as well as receiving
from the conference. The programme was essentially a seminar where they
combined updating everyone on the progress of facilities, research and
know-how across the world, with workshop sessions in which they shared
methods of actually dealing with children of al age groups.
The sessions tried focusing on as many aspects of autism to uncover
the complexities of the disability. Topics were divided under main heads,
some of which were social skills. Using sensory strategies, How motion
differences affect Autism, and Speech therapy. During the conference,
attendees were updated on various kinds of therapies available for the
disabled child, so that parents would have the knowledge of these and
professionals could recommend them if necessary. The different aspects
of special education- its need and requirement, the processes and input
involved in planning for individual children (Individual Education Plans),
vocational training and the use of computers with autistic children
were presented through various talks.
Of special significance was the session on the use of sensory strategies
for behavior commonly seen by an occupational therapist. It is interesting
to note that all over the Philippines, as in many parts of India, most
professionals separate the various therapies available to children with
disabilities like speech therapy, occupational therapy, and sensory
integration therapies. Not all kinds of therapy are available at a particular
centre or facility, which inconvenience families financially and otherwise.
This speaker spoke of strategies involving a holistic approach which
were suggested to be more effective. We visited the centre at a later
date to watch her effectively combine these different therapies in a
manner similar to the way Action for Autism does to create individual
programmes depending on the need of each child.
Along with various objectives, it is the long term goal of the ASP
to set up a nationwide network of local chapters in cities and regional
centres. So far the society has eight chapters and there were
representatives from six of these chapters sharing their progress, as
well as needs of local people.
The theme of the conference was thought -provoking, but rather broad
based, because it brought into the picture so many different aspects.
The conference also tried to touch on each aspect of intervention. Some
subjects were covered completely and gave the listeners a clear perspective
on what the disability was about, but there were also some subjects
that the speakers could not do justice to either due to lack of time
or the fact that the topic (such as certain therapies and strategies)
may not necessarily be useful for autistic persons.
One of the highlights of the conference, however, was the time when
families shared strategies that they had adopted, that had worked. They
encouraged people to build support groups of parents and siblings and
whole family support systems. There were representatives from two different
sibling support groups. Siblings shared what it felt like to have an
autistic brother or sister- the fun they had, as well as the difficult
times. Many people were particularly touched by the fact that to children
even a disabled child can be 'just another' child if adults are accepting
and encouraging.
We had the opportunity to meet and talk with them later on and saw
how it was still easy for them to talk and laugh and be themselves because
of a very positive attitude. For some of them, of course, it had taken
quite a bit of encouragement to get up and share their feelings.
At the end of the conference there was a general feeling of satisfaction
that was shared by almost everyone, a feeling of achieving something,
an assurance of moving one step ahead.
As compared to our country, there is a much higher level of awareness
of autism. This is perhaps due to the small size of their country,
but it would be unfair not to give credit to the ASP for the amount
of very hard work they have put in over the recent years to build awareness
and bridge the gaps between knowledge and ignorance.
It wasn't just at the conference that we saw this kind of positive
and onward movement. Later on we visited different schools and centres
and saw that this was reinforced. The first centre we had the
opportunity to visit was KAMPI. Its expanded form is in Filipino, which
translated means 'Federation of Persons with Disability in the Philippines.'
KAMPI is an umbrella organization that sets up cross-disability self-help
groups of disabled persons. It aims, of course, at improving the lives
of people, and has a few of its own rehabilitation centres for this
purpose. In addition, KAMPI develops programmes and generates and mobilizes
resources. We visited two of its centres, one of which also catered
to autistic children. Their results so far have been encouraging and
positive.
We also visited the Able Centre, which is run by Anna Lisa Yap, who
has been mentioned before. We spent a lot of time there and we were
especially encouraged by their willingness and openness to give and
receive information. Teacher-Mom is another school that works
with all age groups and functioning levels of autistic individuals.
It gets its name from their main objective, which is to train mothers
to be teachers for their own children. They demonstrated their ways
of working with a couple of children. It was a pity we visited Philippines
during their summer vacations, otherwise we would have been able to
see many more schools, because the ones we did visits also did not have
regular classes on; just a few children were in and out occasionally.
The Learning Centre is a small setup that works solely on molding adult
autistic individuals and equipping them with enough knowledge to be
able to get up and hold a job. They explore various possibilities and
interests with each person and work on the ones that do well. Some learn
office skills, others cook and still others do packaging and sorting
activities. Interestingly, a representative from the centre was at the
conference sharing how a few of their young people ad actually held
2-3 month part-time jobs at Nissan Company office and an Avon cosmetics
packaging factory. That was something that really encouraged us to delve
into the immense possibilities here in India for simple jobs that an
autistic person can perform. We saw a great sense of fulfillment in
those autistic people.
We also met a couple of people who were trained in Music Therapy with
autistic individuals. We were not able to watch a session, but we were
able to discuss the need and strategies we could adapt and adopt.
This trip to the Philippines was an eye-opener in many ways. It taught
us a lot as well as assured us that we too were seeing results of an
equally great magnitude taking into consideration the size of the Indian
sub-continent. We hope to keep in close touch with families and professionals
there and hope to network at some time so that we can build opportunities,
facilities, know-how and strategies for the autistic community in India.
Is There a Difference Between Autism and
Pervasive Developmental Delay (PDD)
Charles Hart
From A Parent's Guide to Autism: Answers to the Most Common Questions
Ed note: The term 'Pervasive Developmental Delay' is meant
in the same manner as 'Pervasive Developmental Disorder;' it is not
a different diagnosis.
This question confuses many people and the answer may confuse them
even more. A large number of people with autism, "within
the autistic spectrum" or "affected by the syndrome of autism",
will not be diagnosed with any of those terms. The more capable
and verbal they are, the more likely their diagnosis will be called
PDD (Pervasive Developmental Delay) or even more evasively, PDD-NOS
(Pervasive Developmental Delay, Not Otherwise Specified).
What's going on? We are watching language change. When
Dr. Leo Kanner described his first group of patients with his new-fangled
label of autism, most of them had enough speech and self-help skills
that they might be called high-functioning be a later generation of
researchers. It was only after we discovered that some severely
disabled people also had characteristics of autism that we began applying
the term to people with such an incredible range of talents and abilities.
The "A-word" was supposed to help people, freeing them from
a mistaken diagnosis like schizophrenia or mental retardation.
But, as so often happens, the word became devalued through misuse.
The most sensational, most severe cases of autism received the greatest
publicity. The quiet, moderately disabled persons (like Kanner's
original patients) were unnoticed by journalists and television writers.
Gradually, but surely, the public image of autism became like Barry
Kaufman's first impression that it was "the most irreversible category
of the profoundly disturbed and psychotic."
Today, some professionals continue using the term autism as it was
used 30 or 40 years ago, to cover a broad range of symptoms connected
with language and social dysfunction. Others refuse to apply that
diagnosis unless the individual shows extreme symptoms in each of the
several areas. The call milder forms of the disability PDD.
Dr. Doris Allen, a developmental specialist at the Albert Einstein
School of Medicine, calls PDD "a way of not diagnosing autism",
a diagnosis doctors use when they want to avoid the work. PDD
has become a professional euphemism, a soft term for something considered
too harsh or too blunt.
People have the most well-intentioned reasons for avoiding the real
diagnosis. They want to protect a child from a label that might
trigger fear, rejection, and the loss of opportunities. I once
heard a doctor confide to another, "I won't call this child autistic.
That would be like throwing him on a trash heap where no one will ever
give him a second chance." That neurologists admits she will
only diagnose autism in the most severe cases. Meaning well, she
has become part of the problem. Every time doctors or psychologists
refuse to call a more capable child autistic, they are narrowing the
definition without scientific evidence. The diagnoses becomes
more devalued, spiraling downward until there are fewer and fewer children
with the diagnosis and more and more diagnosed with PDD.
As long as we have no reliable biological tests to identify autism,
it will be hard to qualify these people for services. Insurance
companies, government regulations and school services all rely on guidelines
for eligibility and benefits. It took nearly forty years to convince
officials that children with autism needed special education and communication
therapy. All of those entitlements depend on children having the
keyword in their diagnosis. When they are called PDD or PDD-NOS,
they can't get the benefits they need.
Reading this, you may well ask, 'what difference does the diagnosis
make, anyway? Who cares?' Good question! Labeling
people just for the sake of categories makes no sense and can do a lot
of harm. Unfortunately, they can't get their entitlements if their
diagnosis doesn't fit the language in the regulations. We shouldn't
ask medical authorities to rewrite scientific guidelines to fit political
or economic policies. When researchers discover new subtypes or
better ways to identify different forms of autism, let's rewrite the
regulations for the services. However, at this time, the arguments
about autism and PDD have no scientific value. Public attitudes
and the whim of the person conducting the diagnosis, not the biological
evidence, seem to determine who has autism and who has PDD.
Perhaps one day, we'll offer services based on people's individual
needs, not just their labels. Then the diagnosis of autism, PDD,
or Asperger Syndrome will no longer matter.
Update on Open Door
We have moved. Open Door is now located in rented premises in Chirag
Delhi. We had two and a half very happy years in the apartment in Vasant
Kunj that its owners, the Chopras very generously allowed us to use.
We would like to take this opportunity to thank them for their support.
We would also like to thank the residents of Sector A, Pocket A, Vasant
Kunj, and particularly the Malhotras for being such wonderful neighbours.
Barring a handful of exceptions our neighbours were friendly, accepting
and often keen to know about Autism. We are happy that in our time there
we created some awareness of the condition.
In late April we were visited by Margaret Jensen, Kirsten Broager and
Siv Damgaard-Larsen. Their visit was connected with support by the Royal
Danish Embassy for a small training and awareness project to be undertaken
by Action for Autism. They observed classroom activities through a one-way
viewing window, met some of the parents of students attending Open Door,
and discussed with the staff the work of the school.
In June a team from Open Door visited Kathmandu to conduct a three-day
workshop on Autism. It was attended by parents and professionals from
the entire Kathmandu Valley and was organised by the Navjyothi Centre
at Baluwatar. The workshop was made possible with support of the Danish
Council of Organisations of Disabled People and the Ministry of Education
of the Royal Government of Nepal. The team took the opportunity to additionally
visit the CBR Project being run at Bhaktapur.
Book Reviews
Higher Functioning Adolescents and Young Adults with Autism:
A Teacher's Guide
By Ann Fullerton, Joyce Stratton, Phyllis Coyne, & Carol Gray
Illustrations: Georgianne Thomas
Higher Functioning Adolescents and Young Adults with Autism is written
as a guide for all those working with such individuals, especially
in an educational setup. This book has been compiled by Ann Fullerton,
Joyce Stratton, Phyllis Coyne and Carol George, with illustrations by
Georgianne Thomas, a very high functioning adult with autism.
A detailed study to explain different situations, adolescents and adults
with autism, face in mainstream schools and difficulties due to sensory
integration problems, learning pattern differences and social disability,
has been done to show teachers why, their autistic student may do things
or react in ways they do.
The insights provided by higher functioning adults with autism, are
specially significant. With this new information, persons with or without
autism are better able to understand each other. Clearly described situations
from the lives of young adults, with autism have been used as examples
to highlight the challenges of changing peer relationships, social demands
and the struggle to form an adult identity.
The second half of the book focuses on materials and strategies to
help guide individuals with autism towards independent living according
to their specific needs. It details structuring the learning and working
process of each person with examples of work schedules, time management
plans, planning chart, visual aids and visually coded work areas. These
are especially helpful. The guide also details ways of assisting autistic
adolescents and adults with understanding social cues and providing
them with accurate social information keeping in mind the fact that
they all have unique perceptions of social situations.
Recently, there has been a lot of interest in the concept of using
social stories to teach autistic youngsters social skills and this book
gives us an introduction to the concept. It is a very clearly structured
way of teaching abstract concepts which is exactly what we need with
autism.
This book is highly recommended to both teachers as well as carers
of higher functioning adolescents and young adults with autism. It will
be useful in helping them towards an independent life.
Disability: Challenges vs. Responses
By Ali Baquer & Anjali Sharma
Disability: Challenges vs. Responses is a first publication by
Concerned Action Now, an advocacy organisation for disability issues.
This comprehensive handbook is an excellent effort that attempts to
document the challenges faced by persons with disability and their families,
and the means that sections of society have devised to meet these challenges.
This 'section' is by and large the continually growing and increasingly
effective volunteer sector.
An important inclusion in the book in the Indian Disability Act, which
has been reporduced in full. This is significant since barring
disability activists, most persons with disability as well as most families
of the disabled are completely unaware of the Act. For anyone
wanting to be a disability activist and not quite sure where to start,
this book is a good place.
The Indian Disability Act lists merely seven categories of disability,
viz blindness, low vision, leprosy cured, hearing impairments, locomotor
disability, mental retardation, and mental illness. An interesting
inclusion in the book are case studies of four disabilities: Autism,
Hemophilia, Achondroplasia (Dwarfism) and Alzheimer's Disease, that
are not yet acknowledged by the Government.
As a resource in disseminating information on disability and in implementing
rights of the disabled, this book should find a place in every resource
centre working in the field. Additionally, it should be available
to the general reader as we believe that this book can help correct
stereotypes of disability and help people see the disabled and their
families for what they are: ordinary people trying to make the
best of a challenging situation and trying to live ordinary, everyday
lives.
Helpline
Q. My son cannot wear his clothes
by himself, but can remove them very easily. If he gets angry he throws
things around him, and often bangs the doors and window panes, or bangs
his head on the door or window pane. Please give suggestions about his
regular activities.
A. Since your son is toilet-trained,
and can undress himself, maybe you could now teach him to dress himself
and bathe himself. You could use the method of backward chaining.
Start with the easiest garment to put on, like a pair of shorts. You
help both his feet into the pants legs, and then help him to pull it
up hand on hand. Your son seems to be able to follow instructions, so
you could also put it on half-way and then give him short clean instructions
"Pull up", "Higher", AND DON'T FORGET TO PRAISE!!
In a similar manner, you could teach him to bathe himself. It is summer
now, and this is a good time to start. In the beginning, you will have
to go through the initial bathing process and leave the last couple
of mugs for him to pour. Again break down instructions into a short
clear step by step process. "Dip mug", "Lift up",
"Pour". The pouring may have to be done hand on hand, and
usually means guiding and not doing it for him or forcing him into compliance.
As far as his behavior is concerned - you want to IGNORE unwanted behavior
and PRAISE BIG - desired behaviors. So if he is angry and throws things,
you want to a)IGNORE IT; b)Remove anything breakable from sight
and c) Remove him to another room. This must be done very, very comfortably,
with as little attention and verbal input as possible.
You haven't mentioned whether he goes t school or not. But you could
prepare a daily schedule for him anyway. Specify times and activities,
keeping in mind, the various things he has to do, during the day, E.g.
Wake Up; Brush Teeth; Bathe; Dress; Breakfast; School etc. If
he does not read, you could use small pictures to represent each activity
like drawing a toothbrush, plate shirt etc. This will help him to feel
more organized and comfortable. As each activity is completed, you can
take it off the chart and tick off the word.
Q. My eight year old daughter has
been diagnosed as having Asperger's Syndrome. These days she seems to
scream a lot. Any question she answers with a scream. When she
is happy also she screams. When she is upset, she screams. Formerly
she used to scream, but after her exams finished, and we went to Bombay
and came back she did not scream for about a month. But once I just
shouted at her mildly, and now her screaming has increased to more than
before.
There is a gentleman who has done Ph.D in music and is also in the
education field and has read a lot on the subject. He has started
music therapy on my daughter. If you have any information on this,
regarding its use in behaviour modification or increasing concentration,
could you please send it.
A. As for your query, regarding
your daughter, many a time such behaviour like the screaming are done
purely to get a reaction. You must give a thought to whether or
not you react to her screaming. If she is getting any attention for
it (even a comment, about it later on can be enough attention sometimes),
then chances are that she is going to keep doing it. What you will need
to do is IGNORE her COMPLETELY whenever she screams, but pay her a lot
of attention and praise her a lot when she is quiet. And praise POSITIVE.
Instead of saying 'Oh Good! You're not screaming', you want to say 'Oh
Good! You're sitting quietly!'
The important thing to remember will be to be very consistent and very
persistent. Please don't give up in a week or even two. This has been
going on for quite a while, and chances are that its going to take a
bit of time before it subsides, but we can assure you that it will.
When you are responding to a scream, there are two things at work here.
a) We are reinforcing negative or unwanted behavior, and b) we are losing
an opportunity to teach her an appropriate way of responding. If she
screams a request at you maybe you could tell her, 'If you want water
say 'Give water'. " And CALMLY wait until she does do. If she does
not respond in the way you have requested, it is very important, that
you don't finally give in to her want.
Music therapy need not be a therapy on its own but can be incorporated
in with other teaching methods. I'm sure your daughter might be very
fond of music - use it as a reward. Also use it whenever possible in
the instructions you give. (Sing them out to her instead of speaking,
the chances of her responding will be higher!) If you know someone
who has enough knowledge about the disability, and is willing to teach
your daughter an instrument, or just spend time with her playing some
music, then that would be a great idea to explore.
Q. My daughter hits her little
brother, and other members of the family. She removes her clothes. She
is also a poor sleeper. Can we give her Serenace to make her sleep?
A. To start with, it would be important
for you to know a little about autism, so as to understand the REASONS
why your daughter, may be doing, the things she does. Now to your
queries. There are many times when our children are throwing things
around and shouting or hitting, and then there are times when they are
sitting very calmly and nicely. Most often, we tend to ignore them,
when they are quiet, and yell at them or tell them over and over again
to 'stop', when they are exhibiting unwanted behavior. Now all children
want attention. And if they get attention by kicking, and screaming
then they are definitely, going to do that more. On the other hand,
if you can be focused and aware to catch your child every time she is
quiet or calm, and PRAISE her profusely, but IGNORE her anytime she
does something you do not want, then these unwanted behavior will go
away.
It is very important to remember to be very consistent and persistent.
Stop saying 'No' to her completely, and make absolutely no comment about
her acts at all even in reference to it later. If you ignore it a few
times and give it attention a few times its not going to work. Consistency
in every environment, by every person is important. We realize
this may be difficult for you at the start. We can assure you that it
will be worth while.
Her desire to be without clothes, and hitting other children to make
them cry, could also be attention getting behavior. Just be aware to
remove the other child or grandparent, so they are not hurt an ignore
her. These behaviors could also be due to sensory defensiveness. This
is basically a hypersensitivity or lack of sensitivity of the senses
(touch, taste, smell, hearing, sight). There is a possibility that she
is very sensitive to the feel of certain fabrics, against her skin.
Try on different types of fabrics, cottons, terrycots, polyesters etc.,
and tight or loose garments, pants or shorts, T-shirts or shirts and
see which one she keeps on. If the reason of her sensitivity is tactile
sensitivity then chances are she will keep on one of the kinds of garments/fabrics
you try on her. If not and the reason is for attention, then praise
every time, you see her with her garments on, and if she takes them
of don't comment. After a few minutes, try to put it on again. If she
puts it on PRAISE big. Keep doing this and there is every chance she
will begin to wear her clothes again. Again you will need to phase it
in - start with only one garment.
You've inquired about the 'Option Method'. Basically this approach
involves a very accepting, non-judgmental happy attitude, by everyone
around the person with the disability. We believe that autistic people
can and do learn to be happy and content, which in turn helps them to
cope with their disability, particularly if all around them learn to
accept and understand their difficulties.
Auditory Integration therapy has been done with some autistic people.
Of them, it has helped some and not helped some. No one can guarantee
a positive change due to AIT at anytime. Right now there is noone in
India who is trained, to perform the therapy. Mrs Saroj Madan was here
earlier with Georgiana. The reason AIT helped Georgiana Stehli so much,
was perhaps because her hearing sensitivity was very high and that was
the main cause of a lot of her autistic behavior. But autism is a lifelong
disability, and though AIT has helped her come so far as to lead a near
normal life, she still has autism. She also still has other sensitivities
such as her acute sense of smell, which she told us about on her visit
here.
You've also inquired about 'Serenace'. Our belief is this drug and
the likes of it are best avoided. As you learn to be comfortable about
your daughter's autism, and be consistent in your responses to her,
she will also calm down. Many autistic people have erratic sleep patterns
and may sleep for only 4-6 hrs in the 24 hour period. If she is safe
in her bed or walking around the house, then you want to let her be,
and go to bed yourself. Ignore any noise she might make. Just make sure
that she is safe and the house is child proof.
Medication is something we prefer not to advocate. Our belief
is that in sedating a child, we'll just be reducing the opportunity
for her to learn and progress. But we also want to make very clear
that this is our subjective opinion; you as parents have to take the
decision yourselves. We only make suggestions.
Letters
I am greatly impressed by the genuine human emotion coming through
your newsletter. Here is wishing it all the best.
Dr. Amita Dhanda.
New Delhi
I have an autistic son Neel about four and a half years old. I have
been receiving 'Action for Autism' since last year and find it quite
interesting. The practical tips column is useful. Keep up the good work.
Bharat D. Shah
Coimbatore
I write to ask you if you can let me have information concerning
your national association, how it helps Asperger Syndrome sufferers,
and interesting news about people in your country, their hobbies and
work.
I work for the British Government, which I hope will be changed by
the forthcoming election. I am undertaking a course with the Open University.
I am studying French and English, hoping later to add German, and possibly
Spanish in order to qualify for a language diploma. I am interested
in football and collect programmes of all sports, having a collection
of more than 10,000. I am also heavily involved in the Legion
of Mary, A Catholic Society.
My Asperger diagnosis dates from September 1992, and I attend a
Social Skills Group at the Maudsley Hospital in London.
I have just been appointed Editor of 'Asperger United'. Our first
edition under my management has not yet been published. However I enclose
a previous copy for the interest of you and your members.
I will publish information concerning India in our next edition and
hope I can get an extra copy printed and sent to you.
John Joyce
Asperger United, International Editor,
Surrey England.
Ed: We have placed Asperger United in our Resource Centre for interested
readers.
You will be happy to know that Auditory Retraining according to
the Berard Method is now available in India at an affordable price.
Dr. Radhike Khanna and I have both been trained under Dr. Guy Berard
and are willing to take clients here, at S.P.J. Sadhana School.
Sr. E. Gaitonde, Principal
S.P.J. School
Mumbai